Florida Keys News - Key West Citizen
Friday, March 20, 2009Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
County shuffles sewer funds

The Monroe County Commission has decided to spend $3.7 million on much-needed sewer projects instead of building a new Public Works facility on Rockland Key, a project now in limbo.

The commission on Wednesday agreed to take the money from a fund set aside for the construction and put it toward the Cudjoe Regional Wastewater System, a $194 million plan to build a central treatment plant on Cudjoe Key to serve 10,000 homes and businesses from Lower Sugarloaf Key to Big Pine Key.

The money will cover most of the $3.9 million shortfall to complete design work for the sewer project, according to a report by county budget Director Tina Boan. The county likely will move the remaining $200,000 from some other wastewater fund.

The county had planned to move a county garage and road work operations from its current location abutting the Key West International Airport to the county-owned property on Rockland Key.

"There is no rush to get that project completed right now," county Public Works Director Dent Pierce said. "We can operate where we are now. We understand there is more pressing issues like wastewater."

A previous County Commission had directed the staff to use county-owned waterfront property such as that at the airport for more money-making activities. So the county had planned to lease the land to Hertz, the only car rental company that does not have an on-site facility at the airport.

Hertz would have paid the county $1 million up front for a 20-year lease and then about another $75,000 a year, Monroe County Airports Director Peter Horton said.

The county is under a state mandate to connect all Florida Keys properties to advanced wastewater treatment systems by July 2010, an undertaking for which it lacks about $350 million. The county is woefully behind, and most elected and county officials doubt Monroe will make the deadline.

The state Legislature last year agreed to bond $200 million in wastewater funds for the Keys, about $50 million a year for four years. The money was appropriated as part of a larger Everglades restoration bill, but has not been allocated.

With the state's dire financial situation, some doubt the county will receive the $50 million this year.

For more than a year, County Mayor George Neugent has urged his fellow commissioners to start the process to implement a 1 cent countywide sales tax, with proceeds going to sewer projects.

tohara@keysnews.com

Wastewater treatment a MUST!

Wastewater treatment is vital to our waters and that is why the State imposed the mandate. The residents are frustrated how our Commissioners have handled this project and failure to wisely spend the money and get the job finished on time. Now the citizens to be connected last are hearing that if the County does not get funds, then residents will have to pay the full tab. What happened to fair and equitable treatment for taxpayers?

Gastesi Got It Right - Private/Public Partnership - Not FKAA

At the same Board meeting, County Administrator again called the commissioners attention to a better way to get the sewers done at a greatly low costs to residents. Again the Board ignored him. One should ask why the Board continues to force the residents in unincorporated Monroe County to pay the highest connection rate in the county. Plus, FKAA has had 10 years to get it done and yet most of the unincorporated areas are still waiting. Now the citizens lose services and needed improvements and county employees are expected to do more with less. Citizens lose all around once again. It surprises me that so many residents expect so little from our elected officials that no one is outraged any more.

check your facts first

If you use a private company who's main goal is profit, you are going to get terrible results. The private company will build sub-par plants and collection systems. These will need steady amount of upkeep and man hours just to keep them operational. Plus they will have to be upgraded every few years at the tax payers expense. The FKAA is state. That means they are a not for profit company. They can not inflate prices on any of there projects or services. They only bill for material and labor, no mark ups! FKAA may be higher up front but that is because you get what you pay for. Also the FKAA has not had 10 years to get the wastewater up and running. The county commisioners of the past are the ones that dropped the ball on that. Again the FKAA is state and can not start any projects with the county's go ahead and money. It is all public knowledge, look it up. If you do not believe me, then watch what happens to Marathon after they get all there privately built wastewater plants and collections systems up and running. Or Islamorada who has got started and has a few lawsuits already because of sewage flowing into houses instead of to the plants.

Not one fact in your drivel

Yes, please check your facts. FKAA is a state entity, why must the BOCC pay them to perform their responsibilities? The FKAA asked for and received WW authority in 1997 so they did have at least 10-years. The FKAA uses private contractors to build every project. I dodn't see inferior construction now why would it change? Bottom line is your argument is all wet.

Thier argument is not as wet as yours!

Again I must remind YOU that FKAA gets there money from the state and county. Which comes from us tax payers (BOCC)! Does not matter when they got the wastewater authority. What matters is when the commisioners chose instead to put the money to other uses rather than the wastewater projects. The blame is all on our local government. Now that time is up the cost has skyrocketed and again we (the tax payers) take the hit not the people who actually put us in this bind. SO I must ask. If not the FKAA than who?

PW Facility not as urgent as Sewage Plant


This was probably one of the smarter ideas that have come out of the commission. Prioritizing needs is one way that the sewage system will get funding.

Not really

The county pays rent to the airport for the PW compound in KW. It is also missing out on the rental car revenue. Also, county work crews spends a lot of time (money) traveling to and from KW to get back to the unincorporated county. So lets see keep paying rent, build in a 50% productivity level from PW employees and miss out on revenue. How is that a good long term plan?

you must be new to the keys!

For those of you that think the wastewater is not important, you need to go diving or fishing in our near shore waters. The water is terrible. Look at pictures of the keys in past decades before it was heavily populated. The water is beautiful with over 100 feet visability. Ask a true conch how the water has changed in recent years. It as all due to human waste. There is no industry down here causing polution, it is all of us. Take Layton for example. Before their wastewater plant came on line, their canals and near shore waters were nasty. After a year, research showed and extreme change in the water quality for the better. Imagine if all the Keys were on sewers. Even the PW director thinks it is a good idea to put the money into the wastewater project.

oh, Please

Come on, get real. Have you ever seen what the rest of the [world] flushes into the oceans? While our actions are important and need to happen, the air and water are truly a shared resource and the amount of [refuse] the rest of the world dumps into the air/oceans makes the keys contribution look truly insignificant. Visit India or China, or closer to home Mexico or SA.

so then you are against cleaning our waters?

We have great water now. But imagine if it got even better. The water is why I live here. I am all for cleaning it up. Lets set a higher standard!

On site aerobic system cleaner than their central systems

It would be cheaper and cleaner if they allowed property owners to keep (or install if they don't already have one) an on-site aerobic system. Dumping the effluent from thousands of people into shallow waters only a foot or two deep around Cudjoe is not the answer. The effluent from a central plant is NOT clean. Take a paddle around the effluent of Bay Point if you need evidence.

please call The FKAA's wastewater division...

And take a tour of any of their 3 wastwater plants. They will explain the process and the plant functions to you. I toured the Bay Point plant myself. The effluent there looked like bottled water. The water comming in was the nastiest thing I have ever seen. I live on the Bay Point sewer system and I am thankful for what that plant does after seeing what goes on there.

that is not true

the aerobic systems only get rid of small amounts of CBOD and ammonia. They still discharges effluent that has large amounts of Phosphorus and Nitrates. But most importantly the aerobic systems have no disinfection at all. That means diseases going back into the local waters. They will not even come close to the 2010 AWT standards.

Living in Paradise

Wow! Living in paradise really does come at a cost. Why would anyone want to invest? Seems those who live there must be willing (or more likely hurting)to put up with such high costs of living. Hope it's all worth it. Worrying about how I could afford to live there would certainly diminish quality of life!! Hope it's worth it.
More Florida Keys Headlines
Tuesday, February 9, 2010
1 comment
Tuesday, February 9, 2010
Monday, February 8, 2010
4 comments
Monday, February 8, 2010
43 comments
Monday, February 8, 2010
14 comments
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Tuesday, February 9, 2010 -
Monday, February 8, 2010 -
Sunday, February 7, 2010 -
Saturday, February 6, 2010 -
Friday, February 5, 2010 -
Friday, February 5, 2010 -