Florida Keys News - Key West Citizen
Tuesday, June 9, 2009
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
No more health subsidy for poor
HMA contract for indigent medical care has expired

A 10-year contract that provided funding for the non-emergency treatment of poor people in the Lower Keys has ended, and will force those patients to make tough decisions about procedures ranging from simple blood tests to cancer treatments.

When Health Management Associates took over the lease of Lower Keys Medical Center a decade ago, the company agreed to set aside $2 million a year for 10 years to pay the hospital as well as participating doctors for the care of low-income patients without insurance.

Those contributions ended May 1, said Lower Keys Medical Center CEO Nicki Will.

Will said the hospital will continue to operate its primary care clinic two days a week at dePoo Hospital. And the hospital, by law, is required to treat anyone who comes into its emergency room.

Elective surgeries, blood tests or lab results no longer will be covered by the indigent care fund. Also, most cancer services also are not considered emergencies, and indigent patients now will have to have a payment plan in place before they can have certain procedures, tests or chemotherapy.

Some drug companies work with the clinic and cancer patients to provide free chemotherapy and other drugs, Will added.

She emphasized that cancer is not an emergency, citing for example a man who goes to the primary care clinic with a bad knee.

"They would get a referral for knee surgery," Will said. "In the past, the physicians and the hospital would receive payment from this designated fund for the surgery, but that is no longer the case."

Some money remains to pay physicians for their services in cases like the knee surgery, but there is nothing left for the hospital, Will said.

"And we already provide $20 to $30 million in free care every year," she said, acknowledging that "people may have to make different decisions when it comes to elective surgeries and other procedures. Our county has one of the highest indigent populations in the state."

Indigent refers to people without insurance who cannot afford to pay for health care.

Some people may not get a preventive screening if they cannot afford it, Will acknowledged. Those screenings, such as colonoscopies, can prevent more serious and costly hospital services.

"Now the patient will be told up front what the payments will be, and a payment plan can be formed," she said. "Then the patient can decide what to do and whether to proceed."

There has been minimal discussion of renewing the fund, but no decisions have been made, Will said, adding she is keeping a close eye on the Obama administration and possible changes to the nation's health care system.

The hospital recommends that people have their own family physicians rather than visiting the emergency room for minor injuries or illnesses. Those without a family doctor can go to the primary care clinic on Tuesdays or Saturdays, but now may have to pay for services other than an exam.

The primary care clinic, run by Dr. Jerome Covington, can prescribe medicine, Will said, and the clinic staff will help patients enroll in free programs or for discounted prescriptions.

mbolen@keysnews.com

Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

Who will have to die?

I've had the good fortune to meet and come to know many people in Key West who have to depend on the "free" system of health care available only to the poorest of the poor unless they qualify for Medicaid. It isn't really free of course. Actually its quite a bit more expensive than it has to be, relying as it does on the emergency room, perhaps the most expensive department in the hospital. The primary care clinic and St. Jerome have literally saved lives by diagnosing critical health conditions before they reached a critical stage.

For a time my wife received her health care at the Primary Care Clinic. With a pre-existing condition -- diabetes, private health insurance was simply not affordable on our combined social security and retirement income. Not yet eligible for Medicare, we did the best we could for her preventive care and prayed there would be no catastrophic illness. Thank God, there wasn't, and Medicare finally kicked in. Rather than leave the caring ministrations of Dr. Covington, she switched her care over to his private practice with Drs. Whiteside and Dr. Majors. (I get my care from the Veterans Administration, but that's another story.)

Still, we were better off than many others.

The solution to this dilemma, however, won't be found locally. It will only come when our 'leaders' come to accept that the system we have is dysfunctional and that, like the rest of the first world, we will introduce a single-payer system that puts the doctor-patient relationship back in the forefront, eliminates the insurance middlemen who consume huge chunks of the health care dollars we all spend, and reins in the drug companies who barrage us with millions, maybe billions, of dollars of consumer-directed advertising for drugs that all too often are neither effective nor safe. (Listen to the lists of side effects and risks that accompany these ads).

The Senate takes up health care next week. In the meantime, someone, somewhere, maybe here, will die because ...the patient will be told up front what the payments will be, and a payment plan can be formed," she said. "Then the patient can decide what to do and whether to proceed." And the patient will decide, well, I can't afford that, and will go home to die.

Once Again it is the Poor People of the World

Who are treated the very worst. Shameful. Abosolutely Shameful!!!

Upside Down Priorities

The U.S. spends billions of dollars on war, prisons for non-violent drug offenders, and corporate bailouts but forces the poor to choose between cancer treatment or death. The working people of the Keys shouldnt have to make such choices. Working people cannot afford to live a decent life in the Keys anymore.

Our elected officials

are doing a dynamite job of making this place into a third world county.

Treated the Worse?

Are you kidding me? I might feel bad for the "poor people" if they wanted to strive to achieve, however everything is handed to them therefore they have no incentive to work or make themselves better. Also, I know plenty of people who are not "poor" and choose not to have insurance b/c they know that the system will pay for them. My wife and I come from humble backgrounds and have worked our way through college to obtain respectable jobs. This came at a price of debt and sacrifices. We are now working hard to move forward and honor our obligations in life, however we don't drive cars we can't afford, buy houses that are out of our reach or spend money on useless items such as rims for our vehicles. If people took more responsibility in their lives maybe they would not need free health care. The sad and scary part is that Mr. Obama and his liberal cohorts are only going to make things worse by providing more government assistance which will provide even more incentive not to work towards a better life. It amazes me when I see a person pull up to Dr. Covington’s office in a 60K vehicle but they need assistance, how about the person using food stamps only to have $1000s of jewelry hanging off of them and their kids, or females with no job or health care having children, which we foot the bill for, parents who claim they can not afford to buy holiday meals or gifts for their small children yet spend $3000 on a set of wheels for their Escalade. Stop having apathy for these people and demand they take responsibility in their life.

And you have a college degree?

It never ceases to amaze me when people take a few observable generalizations and cast them out as evidence to argue why poor people are poor.....geez...oh by the way you forgot to mention that all poor people have very expensive tatoos

This is a disgusting thing to say.

I cannot believe the ignorance with the comment that people "choose" to not have health insurance. Do the 18,000 people who die each year in this country b/c they lack sufficient health care "CHOOSE" to die because they were "too lazy" to get health care? Nonsense. This is the Reagan-esque "welfare queen" argument to rationalize robbing the poor and working class while the rich get richer. Health Care is a RIGHT!

. . . Your kind of people

. . . Your kind of people are dying out...Thank God! When a race of people believe that they can deny others basic human rights and services on the basis of skin color, or religion or socio-economic level then that race deserves to leave the world and become history. You are an embarrassment to enlightened people of all ethnicities!

How do you make that jump

Typical liberal comment. When it comes to hard working people who stand up for their rights, the liberals jump right to race, religion, economics and an inaccurate interpretation of the Constitution. I am willing to bet that you have not made one donation or contribution to help the so called "poor" people, but rather rely on those who you believe are an emabarrasment to the enlighted people. I would be curious to know what you are "enlighted" about.

I'll tell you exactly how I am enlightened but it won't help you

I know that when people are denied health maintenance it ends up costing the taxpayer MORE because of critical care and hospitalization at a later time.. It is a proven fact! I also know that when people who assume that "poor" people are worthless and cease being compassionate it only aggravates the situation. Look at crime statistics for cities who had mental health care and medical care provided by the taxpayer including adequate housing for the homeless. Then look what happens to crime when those services are abruptly discontinues. Crime including property crime explodes. Maybe crime on YOUR property. As for myself and my contributions I tithe a minimum of 10% to my church which among other things supports a meals on wheels program. I volunteer with two non-profit agencies one of which involves caring for bedridden terminally ill persons and the other which provides educational support for children. I attend and contribute to more than 10 other benefits yearly. I have worked and paid taxes since 1972. Only the porcine, selfish and greedy deny others food, shelter and medical care. Do you have the right to kill others?

Your kind of people

Our kind of people are well and surviving!!!! This is not a racial issue, but more of a "why don't you try to better youself" issue! I have worked for 35 years only to find that my taxes continue to increase because of people like you that believe medical and every other perk is a "basic human right" that should provided for them. The only "human right" that you are entitled to are the right to freedom (is there such a thing anymore???) the right to free speach and the right to get a job and support yourself and family!!!!!!!!! No one has to be poor. Granted, there are situations that may necessitate receiving public assistance, but for the most part, it is those that choose not to work, not to strive for a better life, not to give back, but only take and abuse the welfare system. I'm all for helping those that need help. But I am not for supporting those that are too lazy to even attempt to work and provide for a life that is a "basic human right". You need to review what our "human rights" are. Get a job (yes, I've had to work in very low paying jobs, but I did it to support my family and build a better life!!!!), work to support those that you have brought into this world and then tell me what "human rights" are! We are all humans. I wish for free health care also, but I'm not willing to ask others to pay for it. God help us all....

You pitiful fool.

Thank God most people have more intelligence and compassion than you do. May God have mercy on your frail soul.

The poverty solution

You are absolutely right! Poverty stems solely from laziness, and both are signs of genetic inferiority. Why don't we round up all these disgusting indigents and put them in labor camps! Include those who don't have the IQ to land high-paying jobs, while we're at it. (And those too dense to recognize sarcasm.) If they happen to succumb to disease, well it just improves the gene pool. ---------- Christ! Are you some kind of neo-Nazi?

YOU ARE INGORANCE AND REPUGNANCE PERSONIFIED

How elitist can you be? Without any information whatsoever you condemn people to death? I worked for 26 years was responsible and paid my taxes only to be diagnosed with cancer. And no I wasn't a smoker or a drinker/druggie. Are you saying only some people (the wealthy) deserve to live? You make me puke with your "my money makes me important" attitude! Karma has a way of making you eat your words and everyone's future is uncertain. I hope you find yourselves filling out paperwork one day and praying to God that you'll get treatment for your life threatening disease before you die. But if you have your way you won't be that lucky.

Poor, Poor People

The only people treated badly are those of us who work, pay taxes, and own homes. We foot the bill for these poor people when we have to use the hospital by being charged 10 times what it should cost for service.

Where do you get your info?

What comic book do you have a subscription to for your facts?

florida keys health system

I guess they are trying to make up for all the legal problems they have had in the past, need feds to investigate entire health system in the keys

Amen

No sympathy here. Maybe more people who have their lives in paradise subsidized by hard working taxpayers will leave the county. It is hard enough to survive and provide for your own without the additional burden of the free loaders and takers. Politically incorrect? Reality sucks.

Let them eat cake!

Its working people who clean the pools, serve food and drinks, clean the hotel rooms, etc., that make the Keys what it is. Yes, they are owed a decent living.

There is that word

It all comes down to that word "owed" Today's society believes they are "owed" something just because they actually work. It amazes me that someone actually thinks because I clean your pool, hotel rooms, serve you food that you owe me. Yes, I owe you the cost of cleaning my pool, hotel room and the food/drink and nothing else (and maybe a tip, if you do your job well). I suppose you want me to give you an ownership interest in my life as well b/c you have signed up to work in the service industry.

So you think this can't happen to you?

You think you are the only person who has a lifetime of hardwork in Key West behind you? Reality does suck. You want reality ? Here it is and I'll use big letters so you can understand it! IT TAKES TWENTY TIMES THE MONEY TO LET SICK PEOPLE REACH A POINT WHERE THEY HAVE TO BE HOSPITALIZED. THE REALITY IS IT IS CHEAPER TO KEEP PEOPLE ALIVE AND FUNCTIONING THAN IT IS TO PUT THEM IN A HOSPITAL BED. What is being done is insuring that medical costs will skyrocketfor all taxpayers. You are an imbecile! IMBECILE!

The true measure of a society

is how they treat the poor. Obviously according to you this society is doomed! I hope your riches get you into Heaven. It is obvious that your works on this earth won't, nor will your selfishness and greed. May you lose everything you have and have you money slip through your grasping claws while you die untreated from a terminal illness! Then I believe you will have a different view of the poor.

I understand that there are

I understand that there are those who are less fortunate and some who fall on hard times but there is a great number who know the government gives handouts so there is no incentive to work hard and provide for your self and family and they are to blame for this mess.

Hope

The US sends millions of dollars oversea each year to give other health care including the ship HOPE that travels to south America providing free health care. If we the taxpayer of this country can do that them why can we not do it here at home?

X KEYWESTER

I left KW.8 years ago because every stinking thing coasts tripple what it should. I do miss the water as I lived and worked there for 33years.Even as a very successful bodyshop owner, I just could NOT get burned even on a soda pop not one more day. A real good boat & trailer and I still go boating at all my favorite lobster holes. BUT as soon as my cooler is full, I aim right back here where I payed off an acre with a home In just 5 years.I could never even think of that in key west. It was paradise now I see a true picture of failure. The crooked politicians and the BUBBA system makes me sick. I love snipe point and spearfishing the great DEAD barrier reef, BUT puke on the system that made me want to leave in the first place. GOOD KARMA!
More Florida Keys Headlines
Friday, July 30, 2010
5 comments
Friday, July 30, 2010
Friday, July 30, 2010
1 comment
Friday, July 30, 2010
Friday, July 30, 2010
1 comment
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Friday, July 30, 2010 -
Thursday, July 29, 2010 -
Wednesday, July 28, 2010 -
Tuesday, July 27, 2010 -