Florida Keys News - Key West Citizen
Saturday, July 4, 2009Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
District to fine-tune partnerships
School Board cites confusion over Habitat for Humanity project

Hoping to avoid confusion that arose from a recent home-construction project with Habitat for Humanity, the Monroe County School Board says it will fine-tune the terms of partnerships with Habitat and other organizations by clarifying who is responsible for specific costs.

In May, Habitat finished a home-building project with Marathon High School construction and engineering students. After construction at the high school, the modular home was erected at a private lot in Marathon. It will now be the home of a local teacher, according to Bruce Ferraro, executive director of the Marathon chapter of Habitat.

That project, funded by a Florida Success grant, ended with confusion over which agency -- the school district or Habitat -- was responsible for various expenses.

In a contract between the district and Habitat, the district put up $80,000 in Success grant money for lumber, supplies, hardware, and salaries of instructors and local contractors who mentored students during the project. Habitat was to reimburse the district when the house was completed.

However, it turns out that state law requires the district to return grant money if it is reimbursed from another source. That apparently came as a surprise to school officials, including the School Board.

It is still a sore point for board member Steve Pribramsky, who asked the board Tuesday why the house shouldn't belong to the district.

"If it's our money, why don't we hold the mortgage?" he asked. "It was [built with] money that came from the Monroe County school district."

Pribramsky is hoping a potential loophole will allow the district to have it both ways. Because the Success grant was discontinued statewide, he believes the district might be able to both seek reimbursement and keep the grant money -- because there is no longer a grant program to accept reimbursement.

He has asked attorney Latour Lafferty to look into that possibility.

Board members were unanimous in their desire to undertake future home-building projects with Habitat, but they considered ways they might lower the district's costs, and iron out confusion over reimbursement. For instance, the Habitat contract stipulated the school system would pay for supplies, lumber and hardware, but it remained unclear at the end whether the district would be reimbursed by Habitat for about $20,000 in tools.

Habitat's Ferraro, praising the partnership, assured board members Habitat would pay the construction costs of houses in the future. He said the program was an effective teaching tool.

"I interviewed a number of students, and they are much happier doing something where they see the results," Ferraro said. "One student we gave a scholarship to said he wanted to help his family and friends rehabilitate their houses."

jguerra@keysnews.com

How many students benefited from this $80K debacle

What I've heard is the students weren't allowed to use tools, but basically were the clean up crew. Really great on the job training. NOT.

What is the cost to the

What is the cost to the district for the students insurance to use power tools to construct a house? Here is another hidden cost of doing "business as usual." I know workman's comp and insurance for a construction worker is extremely high; are the students even covered? School board members, you are exposing the district to an extreme liability if insurance is not provided!

Here is an idea! Save

Here is an idea! Save hundreds of thousands of dollars and create this as an OJT (On the job training) class. Simply bus the students to a habitat home site and let them work on-site and construct from the ground up. One teacher, a lot less spent on tools and material and the kids still get to learn how to build a house.

Again, like the KWHS

Again, like the KWHS bio-diesel program, the wants of a few appaently outweigh trhe needs of many. The school board agrees to buy all hardware, lumber and building supplies to build a house. We remain in limbo as to how much or even if we are geting reimbursed. Again, how many students are in this house building program? When will the board realize they need to stop taking money away from programs that benefit hundreds of students district-wide and giving it to one class that benefits maybe 20 to 25 students at most? Is all of the "positive publicity" to pacify the few and feed the board's ego really worth sacrificing the education of hundreds?

The only thing these bozos

The only thing these bozos can fine tune with any competence is adjourning a meeting. It seems to be the only thing they are capable of doing; they sure can't agree on much else, less get anything right the first time.

This article needs to be placed under the School Scandal

This is one of many debacles that have taken place under the guidance of Randy Acevedo. The taxpayers of Monroe County need to be able to read this article and know how more of our monies were [allegedly] misused (stolen) thanks to Bruce Ferraro and Mark Hooper.

I have an idea...

More partnerships with organizations people tend to trust... hmmm... maybe more opportunities to hide misappropriated school system funds. All the tools bought on school credit cards? Oh, let's say those were for Habitat for Humanity. Yeah, that's the ticket...

Time to realize, all that

Time to realize, all that matters is bloating an already gigantic ego. The board jumps at the first thing that guarantees them publicity and or media attention. We hear how great the Habitat project is, yet it has resulted in another financial mess. We hear about the accolades and awards for IT technology, yet they can't even close out an e-mail account in a timely manner when an employee resigns, quits, gets fired or even arrested for an alleged felony against them. We throw thousands more into IT, yet we can't even afford paper for the copiers. We grant $71,000.00 to a biodiesel program with 25 total students,(they get to keep $21,000 from last year and get another $50,000 for this year.) yet we take away thousands of dollars from fine arts programs that benefit hundreds of students. But hey, we hear we will get national publicity and we will recieve honors and awards from conventions we will attend. (I believe I was told the budget for the music, district wide was less than $58,000.00 last year.) We watch district employees spend thousands of dollars on trips and conferences and get reimbursed, yet we can't afford for students to take a school bus on a field trip three miles from their schools. We build new schools, what a feat; and we can't afford to repair the damaged air conditioners and then tell the staff they must keep their windows closed during summer school. And thru it all, we have board members saying everything is great. Yeah, right... what a joke. These people are clueless.

What's the lesson here?

In a contract between the district and Habitat, the district put up $80,000 in Success grant money. (Here we go boys and girls.) State law requires the district to return grant money if it is reimbursed. (That seems reasonable and it is the law.) That apparently came as a surprise to school officials, including the School Board. (A surprise? This information is there from the start in black and white for all to read. If it's a surprise now, it means you didn't do your job in the beginning.) Steve Pribramsky asked the board Tuesday why the house shouldn't belong to the district. "If it's our money, why don't we hold the mortgage?" (How about because the School District isn't a bank, even if it has been treated as such recently. I certainly don't want the District in that business and especially not when the mortgage is that of an employee. Can you say slippery slope?) Pribramsky is hoping a potential loophole will allow the district to have it both ways. He believes the district might be able to both seek reimbursement and keep the grant money -- because there is no longer a grant program to accept reimbursement. (Did I miss something here? Is Mr. Pribramsky proposing something that seems right on the edge of illegal? There may not be a grant program, but I'm pretty sure the state still exists. What's the lesson here, if you can double your money do it, even if it's shady? As a friend of mine is fond of saying, "just because it's legal doesn't make it right.") He has asked attorney Latour Lafferty to look into that possibility. (Great, get a lawyer involved. I guess you have to spend money to make money. Right?) Watch out Mr. Pribramsky, your stripes are beginning to show. Does this story give anyone else a sick feeling in the pit of their stomach?

Morons....

Is there anything that this School Board can get right? Tell me why they should not be Recalled once and for all? I see Andy is also on the Board of Keys Federal. It is a wonder there is any money left there.

It appears the only thing

It appears the only thing they can get right is taking a break.

Yes. Me.

What is becoming more painfully evident every week is that very few people pay any attention to anything,until it becomes a "story". We are becoming an entire culture with A.D.D. "Due diligence".What a quaint concept.We just may be doomed...

ADD again ?

You've used that line a bit too much. I'm glad we've got folks out there like you walking point to keep things in check before they become a "story".

Maybe they can contract out

Maybe they can contract out the education of the students to someone who really gives a darn. Then the existing board can continue worrying about what they feel is important, like real estate, afforable housing, construction, internet technology, travel, and other things that have little to nothing to do with education.

The good, the bad, the ugly

The good: Marathon High School engineering and construction students were involved in a hands-on project, a teacher gets the home, Habitat gets publicity. The bad: confusion over who owes who money. What does the contract between Habitat and the school district state? Surely this was spelled out. The ugly: the perception of incompetence (best case) or fraud and self-serving greed (worse case)on the part of some folks in positions of power and public trust.

In few words,my feelings exactly. Thanks.

The concept is quite wonderful.Cloaking it in absolute righteousness is not so... Nearly always, egos taint projects like this. When this all fades,I really believe it will be a positive memory. And hopefully will continue. We do need to teach more people how to build things....Well.

Go to the Habitat for Humanity website

They have so many rules about who can do what, I doubt that the kids did much more than watch. And they are a religiously based organization. What about separation of church and state? Can the PUBLIC school be that involved with a religious organization? Why can't the shop classes do something like this on their own? Then no one would have to look into who gets paid what. Let the construction teacher design a plan and submit it to the school board. Why does anyone else have to be involved? Too many people are involved and the right hand doesn't seem to know what the left hand is doing...and that's how all this trouble started.

Habitat is a good idea except that the involvement

has been lacking. Even during the afordible housing crunch not many were built. Many employees at Marathon high have said that no students actually worked on the project. This seems odd since Mr. Hooper has consistantly said That this was a student involved project! I think a full investigation needs to be done to see what really was going on.

Ferraro is an alledged thief

He knows exactly what he is doing. The little weasel should not be trusted. Everything I heard about student participation was that students were graced with the clean up: sweeping floors, moving supplies, lifting materials. WHAT? Habitat takes our money and then gets to hold the mortgage?? Outrage!!

You are right

then the district should participate in the projects other common area expenses and utilities. I guess the district owes Habitat about $300k and they can call it even.

All incompetent

Staff = incompetent, MCSB=incompetent, Habitat=incompetent Nice to live in a community so full of idiots who thrive on pissing away public money. Reitzel=incompetent, Acevedo=incompetent, newspaper editor=incompetent, reporter=incompetent. This really is Moron County we should ask incompetent George Neugent to change the name.
More Florida Keys Headlines
Tuesday, February 9, 2010
1 comment
Tuesday, February 9, 2010
Monday, February 8, 2010
4 comments
Monday, February 8, 2010
43 comments
Monday, February 8, 2010
14 comments
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Tuesday, February 9, 2010 -
Monday, February 8, 2010 -
Sunday, February 7, 2010 -
Saturday, February 6, 2010 -
Friday, February 5, 2010 -
Friday, February 5, 2010 -