Florida Keys News - Key West Citizen
Sunday, July 5, 2009
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
County considers lobbying law
Such an ordinance would require registration, create a paper trail

Monroe County State Attorney Dennis Ward believes lobbying in Monroe County has gotten out of control, and he's urging the County Commission to lay down the law -- both figuratively and literally.

Monroe County commissioners and county staff have been courted aggressively in recent years by developers, contractors and would-be county vendors.

For instance, owners of property around Stock Island's Safe Harbor and their attorneys heavily lobbied the County Commission to change its land use plan to allow construction of a hotel and posh condos along the waterfront, as well as generous exemptions to height, density and other growth regulations.

After the commission rejected the most recent series of proposed amendments last month, Safe Harbor property owner Roger Bernstein successfully lobbied for yet another vote on the issue. The commission again rejected the proposed changes.

At times, the lobbying for Safe Harbor became so intense, with developers' lawyers working at cross-purposes, that it clearly hastened the derailing of the waterfront development efforts.

The commission also was lobbied by trash haulers in recent months as the expiration dates of county contracts approached -- and public pressure mounted to put the contracts out for bid. The county instead chose to renew existing contracts.

Most recently, the commission was lobbied by wastewater contractors who sought to take over a county wastewater project -- even though the Florida Keys Aqueduct Authority was well into the design phase of the project. Two separate firms pitched proposals to replace current plans for a central treatment plant with a cluster of smaller treatment facilities spread throughout the Lower Keys.

It was such instances of lobbying that prompted Ward to do some lobbying of his own -- to convince commissioners of the need to prevent influence peddling.

Ward is asking the County Commission to adopt a lobbying ordinance that would establish rules for lobbyists, commissioners and county staff.

"This is something that is pervasive and we need to get a handle on it," agreed Upper Keys Commissioner Sylvia Murphy.

Ward recently sent commissioners copies of a lobbying ordinance enacted by Miami-Dade County. That ordinance requires lobbyists to register with the county clerk "five business days before being retained as a lobbyist or before engaging in any lobbying activities." Miami-Dade County charges a $490 annual registration fee for recording, transcribing and maintaining records.

County Attorney Suzanne Hutton is reviewing similar ordinances from around the state to determine what she thinks would best meet Monroe County's needs. Hutton said she hopes to have a proposed ordinance for the commission to consider at its meeting later this month.

Commissioner Kim Wigington has expressed interest in sponsoring a lobbying ordinance. She said she would like to strengthen public disclosure rules pertaining to lobbyists, and help shield staff from inappropriate influence when evaluating responses to requests for proposals for county contracts. She also proposes sign-in forms at commissioners' offices that state the purpose of visits.

"The public deserves to know who influences their county officials, whether it's the courting of a commissioner by a developer or pressure from bidders for lucrative contracts," Wigington said. "If followed, the process set in motion by the ordinance would leave a clear trail of evidence whether a commissioner was pressured to place something on the agenda as a favor to a developer, or lobbied to change county policy to benefit a select few."

Wigington said groups like homeowners' associations should be exempt from registering, but lawyers definitely should be required to register.

"A lawyer who gets paid to represent a client by lobbying county officials is one of the purest forms of lobbyist," Wigington said. "The county's history with lobbying lawyers has proven to be the most troublesome."

tohara@keysnews.com

Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

No Representation

So if I have an issue before the BOCC and want to hire someone to speak for me, since I work for a living and can't make all the meetings, I'll have to shell out $$$$$$ to pay for that privilege. But if the people that don't work and attend all the meetings are against me they can speak and it will cost them nothing. Maybe Ward should investigate these people to see if anyone is paying them.

Censorship by the media

What? Not allowed to use Kay Thackers' name in a negative way? Print my comment. It is more truthful than 90% of what you print. I bet this paper thinks she would make a good county commissioner.

Kay Thacker is a local Gadfly that is present at every county

state or federal funtion. She sticks her nose into everything, and no I don't think ant paper in the Keys would endorse her.

District 1 seat for sale

Lets be clear here. This was proposed by Ward over District 1. The Stock Island developers successfully lobbied the district 1 commissioner to have their land use ordinances voted on time and again.

You ask for it, you got it

Kim Wigington....a blithering idiot.

guess again...

Wiggington is the most resistant to lobbyists and represents district 3.

Yes, and

she is resistant to common sense and rational thinking.

Ward wants to save us!

Ward wants to save us from the corrupt politicians, but who is going to save us from Ward?

Oh God

Then all we would have is the "Not for prime time idiots" left, Beruldsen, Thacker, Miller and the Nickersons. Might as well close up shop and move to a Mennonite camp.

While it's like closing the barn door after the horse has

escaped, it's definitely needed. Same goes for the city of Key West. Will the county laws apply to all cities within the county? Just look at all the messes we have now!!!

(1) The unsightly, vile-smelling, graffiti-ensconced White Elephant at the KW Bight by McPherson's Conch buddies, Cortex (who are now masquerading as Keys Caribbean). Just walk by and look and smell. UGH

(2) The building of (or plans to build) condos where Atlantic Shores, the Santa Maria, and Holiday Inn Beachside were, were all approved and now we have - well, duh, failed condos and more motels after ruining the flavor of the old properties.

(3) the newest boondoggle presented by McPherson's sponsors, the Spottswoods, to build a luxury marina, using the people's money, with no exposure whatsoever to the Spottswoods, while a gorgeous marina sits empty where the Peninsular Marina (our only REAL working marina) was.

All the way up US1 are similar messes that were approved by the County Commissioners 'Gang of Three' at the behest of these unregistered lobbyists (I call them special interest bribers) . Just think of all the abandoned, County Commission approved Cay Clubs properties and businesses, all up the Keys!

Lobbying Firms

Other Counties, charge an annual fee of $450 a year be it a lobbying firm or individual lobbyist. Further, lobbying firms must file with the County a quarterly activity reports. If the report is not filed by deadline there are penalties. I bet that if the County starts charging a hefty fee we will see many lobbyists and the wanna be lobbyists go away. The freebees in Monroe County must stop.

The County is way behind on this one...

Glad this has come to light...How could this type of lobbying been going on without any disclosures on behalf of the lobbyist? ...aren't the Commissioners required to disclose dinners with lobbyists and other "gifts"? This is standard in most municipalities. Are we in the dark ages here in the Keys?

Not the dark ages ...

Just in the Keys

More Incompetence

A property owner seeking government relief (land use change, rezoning, etc.) is not lobbying. Safe Harbor property owners and their attorneys meeting with elected officials is not lobbying. Vendors introducing products or offering competitive services is not lobbying. Murphy and Wigington, the dim-wit twins need a reality check. This is another way for these commissioners to limit public input and further their NIMBY, no-change-at-any-cost agenda. When are the people in this county going to wake up? Some change is good. Wigington and Murphy might feel differently if they would quit micro-managing staff. Hard to get their bidding done with all this other static out there.

Codify the Bagmen??

As it now works you write a healthy check to a lawfirm and they carry your laundered 'intent' to the commissioners

This cut out has worked for years as exampled by Jim Hendrick and now Key West's own Denny Crane

Monroe county and the city of Key West have rules and regulations so that they can be enforced selectively for a price

Whoran's work on Snug Harbor has been incredible ... and I mean incredible ... who could believe the rationalizations for that property but a bought and paid for commissioner?

Whoreran!!!!!!!

That's how you spell it. That guy has stuffed thousands in his pockets over the Snug deal.

Informed decisions need more than 3 minutes

Several well known, proven, sewer firms said that they could sewer the lower keys, on-time, and for less money than the FKAA. Maybe it was the FKAA who lobbied Ward to not permit these people to present their case to the Commissioners? The BOCC is not capable of making educated decisions, when the only information they've gotten is the 3 minute public input/brief. And no, I am not a lobbyest or a lawyer, just a citizen who is sick and tired of seeing the BOCC ignore the needs and wants of its citizens because they are making too many 3 minute decisions.

Finally!

It's about time.
More Florida Keys Headlines
Friday, February 3, 2012
3 comments
Friday, February 3, 2012
4 comments
Friday, February 3, 2012
20 comments
Friday, February 3, 2012
8 comments
Thursday, February 2, 2012
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Friday, February 3, 2012 -
Thursday, February 2, 2012 -
Wednesday, February 1, 2012 -
Wednesday, February 1, 2012 -
Tuesday, January 31, 2012 -
Monday, January 30, 2012 -