Florida Keys News - Key West Citizen
Saturday, July 11, 2009
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
Court: Acevedo e-mails are in
But prosecutors not to release them to media

A circuit court judge said Friday he will not stop prosecutors from obtaining electronic communications from the work computers and cell phones of Schools Superintendent Randy Acevedo and his wife, former Adult Education Coordinator Mo- nique Acevedo, because that evi-dence already had been turned over to the Monroe County State Attorney's Office.

Monique Acevedo is charged with theft and fraud in connection with the alleged theft of $180,000 in Adult Education tuition and related course fees. Randy Acevedo is charged with official misconduct in connection with an allegedly falsified document he submitted to finance officials justifying his wife's purchase of a satellite radio subscription with district funds.

Circuit Court Judge Mark Jones said the defense's motion to block release of electronic communications was moot, but instructed prosecutors not to release the material to the press before its admissibility is determined.

Assistant State Attorney Mark Wilson told the judge that about 10,000 e-mails are among the material he wants to investigate; perhaps "7,000 are from Mr. to Mrs. Acevedo and the reverse."

Randy Acevedo's attorney, Catherine Vogel, argued unsuccessfully that the e-mails involve communication between a married couple, and that the two cannot be compelled to testify against each other.

The Acevedos' attorneys also asked Jones to order prosecutors to comply with Florida Bar rules governing professional conduct.

Those rules prohibit attorneys from making public comments intended to damage the other side's case.

Vogel and Public Defender Patricia A. Docherty, who represents Monique Acevedo, cited comments in which Wilson called Monique Acevedo a "fugitive from justice" after she failed to turn herself in to investigators at a time her then-attorney, Nathan Eden, had agreed to bring her in.

Docherty also criticized Wilson for a photograph in The Citizen that showed Monique Acevedo being handcuffed before entering the Monroe County Detention Center, alleging that it was staged for the press.

"The press was there, waiting," Docherty said.

She also cited comments by Wilson and State Attorney Dennis Ward that she believes suggested the couple were guilty of the crimes for which they were charged.

Vogel cited one such comment from a news story describing credit card purchases by Monique Acevedo that match amounts listed on her husband's re-election campaign expense reports.

Wilson told The Citizen at the time that it would be "the mother of all coincidences" if the matching expenditures weren't the same purchases recorded in two places.

Wilson, who denied that his past comments to the press were out of bounds, told Jones he did not object to the motion, and said he would continue to follow Florida Bar guidelines governing statements to the press. Thus, the motion was granted without objection.

Responding to a third motion, Wilson also provided Vogel with details supporting the state's charge against Randy Acevedo.

Vogel had filed a motion to compel Wilson to provide the information, but Wilson willingly handed over supporting documentation without challenging the motion.

The charges against Randy Acevedo are based on a letter on Monroe Association of ReMARCable Citizens letterhead that says an XM Satellite Radio subscription was purchased by Monique Acevedo so MARC House residents would remain calm during trips between Key West and Marathon.

MARC is a nonprofit organization that teaches life skills to developmentally challenged children and adults.

MARC Executive Director Diane Flenard told investigators in April that no one from the agency had written the letter.

Wilson alleges that Randy Acevedo gave the falsified letter to Finance Director Kathy Reitzel to justify the subscription purchased on his wife's school credit card, thus obstructing the investigation.

jguerra@keysnews.com

Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

To Tom Tuell

Can you add the Citizen's editorials that relate to the School District? Thanks,

This is attached to every email I get from my wife who is MCSD

"Florida has a very broad Public Records Law. Email addresses and virtually all written communications to or from School District Personnel are public records available to the public and media upon request. E-mail sent or received on the School District system will be considered public and will only be withheld from disclosure if deemed exempt from disclosure or confidential pursuant to applicable state and federal law. "

The husband/wife priviledge isn't made in stone.

This will be a decision for the courts. It will get appealed by both sides all the way to the Supreme Court (The ACLU will pick up the Acevedo's side along the way). But the court will decide what the intent of the law was. It was not to protect crooked employees who happen to be married. The intent was for bedside admissions. It may take a while, but this is a great case to have this issue hashed out once and for all. I would bet it has been decided somewhere else already. This can't be the first Bonnie and Clyde team in America, but we just haven't found it yet. There must be a person in the legal world out there that can find other situations similar to this that have been ruled on.

Public Defender

"Patricia A. Docherty" Oh yes...the wife of Key West City Commissioner Barry Gibson. I get it.

You've got to be kidding me!

Bubba Barry, Bubba McPherson, Bubba Randy, Monique. Does the train of cronyism ever end?

Don't forget about Swift,

Don't forget about Swift, Randy's new employer...

Yes, I forgot...the caboose...Swift

One long "train" with Swift bringing up the rear.

only 6 comments posted ..

A new low record on this subject. Finally, we can focus on more important news topics, like Michael Jackson's life and death.

The Lawyers got

exactly what they wanted; a Gag Order on the Prosecution giving any e-mails to the press before the court case is settled. The Judge only did this because of the way the Prosecutor is trying this case in the press. If the Prosecutor had the evidence they need to win they wouldn't have to do this. Not saying they don't, but does make one wonder.

emails

Will the contents of these emails be made public? (This would be better than the mysterious, curly-haired, thin, 40ish woman on Olivia Street nr Galveston Lane close to Harris School)

Newsppaper

Already has asked for them as soon as they are available.

Was there ever a doubt?

Now lets get busy and request our public officials start releasing this stuff to us under Florida's Sunshine Laws http://www.fsne.org/sunshine/laws/ and the State Attorney's own legal opinion http://www.myflsunshine.com/ago.nsf/sunopinions/DA13B2A9AB186FDA8525728F... The public is entitled to know what our public officials have discussed on specific issues of public record, authorization of XM radio subscription communications between the MCSD budget and purchasing officials (Reitzel), P-Card holders (Acevedo), and approving/reviewing officials (Henriquez).

YAY!

The writer of the post urging the public to request those documents is absolutely right on the button! The Florida Sunshine Law and open records laws are not written for reporters, TV newspeople or special interest groups. Members of the public simply need to ask for them in person by walking into the school board or any government agency one wants to inspect the e-mails or other notes, phone logs, meeting minutes, handwritten communication and even doodling by public officials during meetings and the course of business and get them right away, if possible. It's not about reporters ... any memberr of the public should get those documents any time they ask. The agencies can ask for time to get them together for you, but you don't have to show an ID or hand in written request. A written formal request is not necessary, but it helps both sides understand exactly what the member of the public expects them to hand over. The agency or department must tell you within a certain period of time (30 days often) whether they can accede to your request. The agencies can also charge "reasonable admnistrative fees" for copying the documents. In most cases, that's 15 cents a copy something like that. Other searches can cost an hourly wage of a secretary for four hours, something like that, but it has to be reasonable. Please, ask the school board anything you want: salaries, vacation time, supplemental pay, trips employees have taken ... anything! Ask teh city for the proof on what they spend their grant money on, dollar for dollar! Go for it! Have fun!

I'm the writer

but forgot to sign. JFKulick

By merely requesting

the e-mails to be inadmissible is a sure sign of guilt. Randy was supposed to be the 'computer expert'....surely, in the pursuit of his degree, he took at least one class in Technology Ethics and Law. Any student who is enrolled in tech info and service must take these courses, and as a part of any HS tech curriculum it must be covered as a part of the state educational standards.

Randy's degree

Is it true Gardner-Webb in North Carolina doesn't offer a Management Informtion Systems (MIS) degree?

I dug into their web site to

I dug into their web site to check out the Management Information Systems info. The class (yes, it consists of one class) is offered thru one of their on-line classes. Management Information Systems is not a degeree, but instead a listing for a course that requires one class. He might not have a degree, but a piece of paper saying he attended at least one class.

If you really dig thru the

If you really dig thru the web site, you will find an undergrad program thru Broyhill.

Verified degree

Has anyone checked to see if Randy actually has a degree from G-W?

Go to their website...

no where is there a listing for an MIS degree. You can search each department, and find nothing about an MIS degree. http://www.gardner-webb.edu/academics/departments/index.html

There is no listing for an

There is no listing for an "MIS degree". It is a subject offered thru one of the affiliate programs or on line. It consists of taking one class for 3 credit hours and attending a lecture either on-line or in class for another 3 credit hours. It seems to be the only class offered under this subject; "MIS 460 data communications & networking". I find it very hard to believe you could get a "degree" for attending one class. I guess this is another thing that needs to be clarified. My apologies if I am wrong.

Computer science degree

Gardner-Webb does list a computer science degree in its Math Department. Does that translate into MIS?

IF YOU OBJECT THAT RANDY MAY NOT HAVE A DEGREE

Than you need to be aware that our deputy County Administrator, Debbie Frederick, has only a high school degree, which is subpar on a good day. Her experience is only secretarial in nature, and yet she holds a position that in the past required a masters degree. Apply your complaints equally among all of our local governmental agencies that have failed miserably

Judge Jones is going to look over emails if used in case

Look out Judge Jones is going to look over emails to see what can and cannot be used when it come to Husband & wife convo. If he removes some of the emails due to that fact, the school board, county & city Commissioners and board members will have to look at letting go either the husband or wife from working for the same public entity if not our public taxpayer dollars are not protected. If they don’t do that then its open season on our taxpayer dollars, all you need is a husband & wife team to steal our money and you cant use the emails between them as evidence. Just another law that protects the criminals and not the Public.

The Acevedos will be Vogel's downfall

Re: Vogel's comment: She also cited comments by Wilson and State Attorney Dennis Ward that she believes suggested the couple were guilty of the crimes for which they were charged. Well big friggin' DUH! The prosecutor HAS to believe they're guilty. That's how the legal system works. This Vogel is one vindictive piece of work. The Acevedos will be her downfall.

yeah i'm first?

does this smell like justice? I think it might

they got caught.....

they [allegedly] lied they [allegedly] stole hell with them!dress them in orange,enjoy the cavity search and put them on the chain gang!randy could use the exersize anyway.

ACEVEDOS E-MAILS

IF THEY ARE USING SCHOOL COMPUTERS TO E-MAIL EACH OTHER DURING WORKING HOURS THAN ISN'T THAT MATERIAL SCHOOL PROPERTY AND THERFORE NOT HUSBAND AND WIFE PRIVLEDGED.

QUIT YELLING

I can't read uppercase trash!

Yes,

most definitely.

educashun

Has no one figured out that whatever Monique did or did not do her position and her actions were overseen by John Padgett before Randy Acevedo and by the School Board which approved her appointment? Spell check anyone?

John Padgett wasn't there long enough to uncover

all the skeletons in the district. Padgett was getting close and that's why the admin. people got nervous about finding a bubba to run against him. Remember Monique took over Adult Ed. in 2003 when "I know nothing" Andola retired. Randy was elected in 2004. After that, it was open season for Monique to do what she wanted without reprisal. Why do you think they were so desperate by spreading lies about Colvard and assure Randy was re-elected? They knew Colvard would have 4 years to get to the truth.

Andola Retired After Randy was elected

but everything else is about right! http://keysnews.com/node/14083

Nice Try!!!!!

John Andola was her direct supervisor until 2005 when he retired. She along with MArk Hooper were promoted together AFTER Randy took office. I am not saying that crooked behavior wasn't necessarily going on while Padgett was in office but his term was only 1 year and if you recall the administration fought him on every move he tried to make. You can't blame this mess on him.

The Bubba System

Why are so many outsiders so concerned about the Key west Bubba System ? I was born and raised here in Key West and am a witness to how the outsiders have ruined this once quiet ,peaceful and family oriented little town . I am sick of the prejudice against Key Wester's ! There are so little of us true Conch's left here because of you outsiders that it makes me sick . If you don't like the way the system works down here , GO BACK WHERE YOU CAME FROM and concentrate on your own home town's system . I'm not saying that Randy and his Wife are right for whats going on with them but please quit with the PREJUDICE B.S. about the Bubba's . If you don't like the way things work down here , Leave !Steve Bowman..........................................................

You know, unfortunately, Key

You know, unfortunately, Key West's "Bubba Sytem" affects the unincorporated parts of the Florida Keys! I think it's time for Key West's system to be investigated and "Thank God" that this happened with the Acevedos. Unfortunately everyone paying taxes in the unincorporated parts of the Florda Keys suffers from the mishandling of OUR monies by KW! And furthermore I too love my Florida Keys and we as residents need to stand up for ourselves and our tax dollars and get rid of the "traitors"! Fix the system and maybe people wouldn't claim it to be the "Bubba system"! Salt Life is the Only Life!
More Florida Keys Headlines
Thursday, February 9, 2012
Thursday, February 9, 2012
Wednesday, February 8, 2012
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Thursday, February 9, 2012 -
Wednesday, February 8, 2012 -
Wednesday, February 8, 2012 -
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 -
Monday, February 6, 2012 -
Sunday, February 5, 2012 -