Florida Keys News - Key West Citizen
Friday, August 7, 2009
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
Teacher pay remains in limbo

Monroe County public school teachers will return to their classes next week, but still don't know how much they'll be paid for their work.

Union salary negotiations for teachers and non-instructional staff remain stagnant, leaving United Teachers of Monroe President Leon Fowler critical of the School Board for spending money to investigate the financial scandal -- money he said could have funded the raises the union wants.

"Our salary request is still at the initial position as it was on June 23, the first day of negotiations," Fowler said Monday.

The union has requested a step increase and a 3.5 percent cost-of-living increase for teachers, custodians and blue-collar employees in maintenance, transportation and food service. The union also wants a $50 monthly tool allotment for maintenance mechanics, union documents show.

"They didn't have to bring in outside attorneys to investigate something the state attorney is already looking into," Fowler said. "They have already wasted more money than it cost to pay the employees their step raise, and the spending hasn't stopped yet. It is frustrating to watch all of the dollars saved from budget cuts going to attorneys and auditors."

The investigation has cost $214,594, school officials said.

"The money that was stolen also could have gone to teacher salary increases," board Chairman Andy Griffiths said.

The School Board in spring hired investigator Richard Fechter and attorney Latour Lafferty, the former to determine how many employees might have misspent school money or violated financial policies and the latter to advise on possibly disciplining them.

Though several administrators and employees were criticized for not catching former Adult Education Coordinator Monique Acevedo's alleged theft of school funds, the School Board disciplined no one.

To date, Fechter has charged the district $121,898 and Lafferty $92,696, School Board secretary Sally Smith said.

Teacher pay starts at $42,330, according to this year's salary schedule. The union has requested a step increase to $42,769 for teachers in their second year, said Holly Hummell-Gorman, union vice president.

School Board members said they couldn't talk about union negotiations.

"This is something we really are bound to not talk about, as it's part of negotiations," board member John Dick said. "The board should not be quoted on it."

Negotiations were to restart Monday, but the school district postponed the meeting to prepare for its annual school preparation conference at Key West High School.

If the union and district have not reached an agreement by the time teachers report to class on Tuesday -- the mid-1990s was the last time that happened -- teachers and employees will return to work at the 2008-09 rate of pay. Declaring an impasse is a process that "takes a few months to complete," Fowler said.

The union last year negotiated a 2 percent cost-of-living increase and an average 2 percent step increase.

jguerra@keysnews.com

Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

letter of apology

I must agree with this letter. As a teacher, I am embarrassed and appalled at the actions of our union leaders. What does Mr. Fowler make and why is Ms. Hummel Gorman on special assignment? These are good questions. When I went to the union last year with a serious situation and needed their help I was told I was a day late. A day late??? I asked earlier for the union to make a stand that said we were sorry for the actions of our superintendent since we(the union) had supported him in the election. We needed to show that we were upset by his actions but nothing ever happened. How can we stand by one who takes from us and then bad mouth those that are actually trying to make it all right again?

The Union, School Board and Teacher's Pay

It's time for a change, and the spineless School Board members should quit counting all the cash piped into their pockets by the union and start thinking about what's best for kids. Until they do we're stuck with the status quo: shameful dropout rates, parents abandoning public education and bitter disagreements between the district, teachers and the union. It's a schoolyard fight in which nobody wins, and the biggest losers are the students. It's outrageous, people -- including parents -- have started rejecting that kind of nonsense. The Citizen's Commission on Civil Rights has just released a report that blisters teacher unions for their "fierce opposition to reforms." Parent groups are rising up demanding accountability. Alternative schools are springing up everywhere, and recently it was proposed allowing charter groups and other educators to bid for control of new schools. My daughter attends an amazing school in Key West, with amazing teachers, who show up for work every day though their salary barely covers necessities. However, when my daughter hits sixth grade, I want more options than the so-so middle school she's slated to attend. I don't care whether it's a charter or collaborative, and I don't care who runs it. I only care about the quality of education and whether there's a system of accountability. Time after time, the union is in the way rather than in the lead. Come on Fowler, do something constructive. Show us what you can do!

Teacher's Salaries and the Union

It has been said that union's in the US need a major overhaul, the United Teachers of Monroe and their President Leon Fowler, are a prime example of why. For a competent, responsible teacher a salary of $42,330/year is an insult. even if it is starting. Sadly, in the name of living in paradise people willingly sacrifice their professional worth. If anyone's salary should be linked to the local high cost of living is the teacher's salary, not administrators, but the teachers who are on the front lines everyday not only dealing with the kids but also the parents. Teachers, parents let's rock the Union's cruise ship and see who survives!

I have to agree with most of

I have to agree with most of the above, although I am on the fence with teacher pay. Most teachers are on a 10 month contract. This year, a teacher is required to work 197 days. At the high school level, a teacher is contracted to work 7.5 hours a day, with one period not teaching but for planning. If a teacher "works" during their planning period they are compensated. After some basic math, this starting pay averages out to a fraction over $28.65 per hour. I don't know of too many people in the private sector that would frown on that kind of starting salary. Yes, there are teachers that do care and give so much more time it is hard to believe how much they sacrifice. I have also seen some teachers that are out the door before the students when the bell rings at the end of the day. If you so want change, it appears it must start from within. Do you get what you pay for in union dues? Sadly, apparently not. The next time you guys elect a union rep, it might be wise to elect someone without ties to the administration and dreams of joining them.

Letter of Apology

Dear Monroe County Tax Payers, I would like to apologize for the disgusting behavior of our teacher union boss, Mr. Fowler, who has been so long out of the classroom that he has no clue what teachers even do anymore. Teachers don't want to raise your taxes, but Mr. Fowler does. Teachers don't blame the school board for the scandal. We blame the thieves who took the money. We are embarrassed that this man claims to speak for us because he does not. Teachers want a raise because we earned it, and we want it granted from a well managed district that uses every single penny that tax payers give with common sense and decency. Sincerely, A teacher & tax payer

Fowler's salary???

If anyone knows what his salary is, please post it here. We pay for it with our union dues so we have a right to know, don't we? And, I think if we take a cut in pay, then Mr. Fowler should also by lowering our union dues. How about that Mr. Fowler? Join us in the trenches and show us how much you really care.

and what about benefits?

The teacher's salary guide is available on utmonline.org what about the union personnel salaries?

union dues

By quitting the union, I could almost make up the cut in pay teachers are going to get this year, right? Check the salary schedule to see what the Prez earns--he's WAY out there at the end, CC25+

The money would have been well spent

if the Board used the information it obtained and fired the employees that were found to have turned a blind eye to the situation. By not firing these individuals, the money was wasted. I applauded the Board in the beginning for wanting a thorough investigation and demanding an attorney who would produce evidence to fire people, but when the time came, they backed down like cowards. Now I say the Board needs to go too.

SAO & SB

It isn't the responsibility of the SAO to investigate incompetence, it IS the responsibility of the SB. This is money well spent if it gets incompetent people removed from their posts.

SB is NOT an investigative agency

You say that the school board is responsible for investigating the whole Acevedo situation and everything that has stemmed from it. Fact is that the school board IS NOT and investigative agency. The states attorneys office is equiped to look into matters like this and the board spending over 200,000 on two people to see who they can blame as well for financial issues and then paying someone to say whether or not they should be fired is JUST AS BAD as Monique's ALLEGED theft. Dicks and Primbransky are guilty of screwing the teachers out of their raises through this Acevedo witch hunt

You are out of your mind

if you think that investigating the financial mismanagement is even close to Monique's theft and Randy's incompetence. The SB is not investigating criminal behavior however it is their job to root out incompetence and in order to do that they need documentation. I can't wait to read the reports and when we do you will see that this was money well spent. So you think a mere 200K would be enoough to provide raises for teachers? What about the 3 quarter million that Monique stole, wouldn't that have provided a much better raise. What about the 7 million Randy sunk into the Marathon Manor in the shady Cay Clubs deal that went belly up, I bet that would have provided an even better raise? Dick and Pribramsky have long championed teachers and if this is what is needed to get rid of all of these leeches at the district office then I support them. Any teacher with a brain is smart enough to know that Dick and Pribramsky are NOT the problems here.

They better start realizing

They better start realizing that without leadership and guidance no organization can be successful.

Witch Hunt?

"Just as bad as Monique's alleged theft" You have got to be kidding. Wow I bet your just the juror the defense is looking for. Were you were one of those that got the gift cards she was always buying? Maybe your next in line for one of those high paying administrative jobs that don't seem to have any responsibilities.

union personnel

Does anyone know why Holly Hummell is a "teacher on special assignment" getting paid by MCSD, yet she is a "union vice president?"

Lesson about negotiations

First of all, the SB doesn't sit at the negotiating table, management does. That means Mikey, principals, and whoever else they appoint to serve (with a huge supplement of course) are the ones who actually do the negotiating, then when they reach agreement the board can approve or not approve. Essentially what is happening is that the teachers have to fight it out with the admin for raises and perks before it even gets to the SB. That is why Leon is pushing for a raise in taxes because that way his admin buddies won't have to give up their fat salaries and cushy positions in order to provide a raise to the teachers who actually do all the work. I hope people realize that Leon F. is just trying take the spotlight off the real problem (spending on admin) by crying over money that was spent on the investigation. He is nothing but a hyprocrite who could care less about teachers and salaries. He will use any excuse he can find to attack the board instead of working with them to fund teacher raises by cutting admin spending.

Far as Im concerned

Far as Im concerned he is a SCAB, he is not acting like a union president. A real president would have been all over the missing theft of money knowing well it would effect the rank and file latter on. a Real Union President would love to have the board to find out were the money went to stop the bleeding because in the long run it would be more money for rank and file. He's in bed with management and at other places rank and file would have run him out of town. but some of the school board rank and file still think oh poor Randy and they dont mind using there own money for supplys.

Leon Fowler

Leon really shows his true colors when he uses teacher salaries as a way of complaining about The treatment of his Buddy Randy. Leon never has stated that the money taken by Monica could have been used for salary raises. He is a sorry excuse for a union head and will be an even worse school board member. The school union needs new blood working on this year's salary. At the start of all this Leon should have been saying that the 2% raise last year did not even meet the cost of living increase. He should have been saying that teachers are getting hosed while administration has been spending like idiots for years. He said nothing and backed Randy.

Mr. Fowler is worried

about a couple hundred thousand needed to investigate district spending but yet he has forgot to mention that thanks to the board's quick action in getting rid of the P-cards the fund balance is now larger than anticipated because all those district administrators aren't out spending on useless crap.

Fowler- what a waste!

I hope the teachers can see through his BS. He is going to lash out at the board because they spent money to investigate the theft? Which mind you was caused by the fact that Randy's wife stole almost 3 quarters of a million dollars and he is going to complain about the cost of the investigation? Does Fowler have rocks in his head? Does he think the board should just ignore what has happened? They have a duty to get to the bottom of this and when these reports are finished, I expect the board to take action. So Fowler is upset about the money cost to investigate well that's funny because he never complained when Randy created excessive administrative positions, wasted thousands on travel (50 people on 1 trip), spent a couple million on the Marathon manor which has been sitting in ruin ever since, gave administrators almost free health insurance while teachers pay top dollar, and finally has spent thousands on consultant contracts to the "retired" administrators. I am disgusted with him. The teachers need new union leadership and they need it now. He has the nerve to critice the cost associated with this mess that was caused by his hero Randy through his failure to provide oversight for his administrative departments and instead of putting the blame where it belongs, he blames the board. He is as conch/bubba as they come. Teachers revolt!!!!!

negotiations

When is the next meeting with the union and the board?

Union Leader Out of Touch

It’s sad how out of touch union leader Fowler is with the sentiments of teachers. He pushed for a tax increase during the worse economic downturn in America in fifty years. I was, quite frankly, embarrassed that our union leader was out in the community connecting my raise to increased taxes. We all know that people are struggling and can’t pay anymore. I’m one of them also. Now, he is connecting our raise to the issue of the school scandal. Everybody knows he is a Randy supporter, and that the union was in Randy’s pocket for years. Fowler is trying to give Randy some cover while trying to humiliate the school board in general. In the end of all this, the money stolen and the lawyer fees will be taken out of the teacher’s pockets. The only real cuts I have seen is low-level teacher aides, bus drivers, clerks, and so on. The big dogs pulling in the six figure salaries are still there, rehired after retiring because apparently they are so special that they are irreplaceable. Teachers pay $600 per year to be in the union, and I for one don’t think I am getting a good return on my investment. The union, the acting Super, and the board missed a wonderful opportunity to send teachers a positive message. They could have made it a top priority to reach a salary agreement, and given us the peace of mind of knowing our pay for the year. Saying you were too busy with other things is an insult, on top of the swift kick in the *ss we already have from the scandal. To start the year without a contract sends a clear message to us about what you think is important. If an education system doesn’t put the educators at the top of the priority list, then we have a BIG problem.

Leon Fowler is a joke.

He claims to have the teachers' interest at heart, but he's part of their problem, not one of their advocates. He is so entrenched in the Bubba culture of course he doesn't want the Board spending money to investigate his pals. Instead of railing at the Board, he should be taking the administration to task for their theft, largesse, and payroll padding, but that will never happen. This is the first time I've agreed with Andy Griffith in a long time, but he's right. Fowler ought to be targeting the cost to the district of the illegal acts themselves rather rather than the cost of the investigation of those acts.

Teacher's pay remains in Limbo

This is disgusting! The people that spend probably the most time with children, shaping their and our future are paid less than the person that picks up your trash? Shame! Shame! When is Monroe County going to open their eyes to reality? If we want a bright future, teacher's compensation is a good place to start. Where is Griffiths in all this? The stolen money does not erase the District's responsibility to the kids and the quality of their education. If you are sure that Randy and Monique stole that money then put a lien on their personal property. Stop using the Acevedos as an excuse for crappy teacher's salaries! Let's move on and deal with the quality issues. Griffiths, if you are not going to be a quality chairman then you too need to move on!
More Florida Keys Headlines
Thursday, February 9, 2012
Thursday, February 9, 2012
Wednesday, February 8, 2012
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Thursday, February 9, 2012 -
Wednesday, February 8, 2012 -
Wednesday, February 8, 2012 -
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 -
Monday, February 6, 2012 -
Sunday, February 5, 2012 -