Florida Keys News
Monday, November 16, 2009
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
Possible channel widening a long way off

The city of Key West may get permission from the federal government to widen its ship channel with extensive dredging, but such a project likely would not begin until 2017.

City Manager Jim Scholl on Thursday met with representatives from the Army Corps of Engineers, which oversees all permitting processes for such projects.

"The fundamental navigation problem we have right now is that the width of our channel [in one section] is only 300 feet wide," Scholl said, adding that the harbor pilots who guide large ships into Key West Harbor have asked that the narrow section be dredged and widened to 450 feet.

"That would make it possible for longer ships to navigate in and out of the harbor," Scholl said. "The impetus for this is the safe navigation of the growing fleet of cruise ships."

Larger cruise ships are coming into use given the impending widening of the Panama Canal, the width of which historically has been the limiting factor for shipwrights.

The local harbor currently can safely handle a ship that is slightly less than 1,000 feet long, Scholl said.

Royal Caribbean this week launched Oasis of the Seas, which is 1,200 feet long and holds 5,400 passengers.

Scholl's meeting with the corps was the first step in a very lengthy process that could start with an initial reconnaissance study that would determine whether a subsequent -- and tedious -- feasibility study would be completed.

"We have to determine whether it would be appropriate to expend a significant amount of taxpayer money on this project," Scholl said.

The corps examines four areas of concern in making its decision: navigational, economic, environmental and disposal.

If approved, the feasibility study could take until 2017, Scholl said. It includes comprehensive analysis of weather conditions, navigational needs and other factors.

"These projects take time, but every journey begins with the first step," Scholl said. "We may need to widen this area of the channel, so we have to start somewhere."

He added the project likely would include cost-sharing among the federal, state and local governments.

mbolen@keysnews.com

Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

The end is near for Key West! 2012

NYC is the Big Apple, New Orleans is the Big Easy and Key West is the Land of Fruits and Nuts.

2012 is right around the corner!

..."who wants a cruise ship that accommodates 5,400 people? "Unfortunately Key West has become a "cruise ship city". "The opening of Cuba WILL cause Key West to be bypassed." "The Keys fad is over, and Cuba will put the nail in the Keys coffin." "Cuba's tourism economy is TEN TIMES the size of Key West's." "Maybe we could actually develop heritage tourism, instead of merely sex and rum in the sun." Maybe the MAYAS were right!

you right

since I came from Cuba I said when Cuba open his door, I guess must be soon, Key west will be only a old farm, ugly and nasty and all invest in Key west is for nothing, Cuba is the real paradise.

Tail wagging the dog!

Talk about a case of tail wagging the dog, who wants a cruise ship that accommodates 5,400 people? Is that supposed to be a GOOD thing?

Tail wagging the dog

Unfortunately Key West has become a "cruise ship city". Their revenue has way too much impact and cannot be replaced by industry or other tourism. Key West cannot afford to go back to the sleepy little ways of the 1970's. Too much debt to service. The real problems are that the cruise ships will grow and grow until Key West won't work for them anymore. If Cuba (nice deep water ports) opens up then Key West will all but be passed up entirely. Talk about your empty stores on Duval and in town. Talk about your bankrupt business. Talk about closed up bars and people moving away in droves. Talk about a dead infrastructure. Talk about no kids in the schools. Talk about a dead town! The bad thing is that some people actually want this to happen.

The tale IS wagging the dog...

...and has been for years, despite the warnings of many thoughtful people against marrying the city budget to the cruise ship industry. The opening of Cuba WILL cause Key West to be bypassed. The thing to do is start planning now for a sustainable future; don't waste time dumping on "people who actually want this to happen." It's gonna happen, and getting away from this mindless "bigger is better" mentality will be good for the Key West community and its economy.

There is another model

Actually, not all cruise ships will be 1200 feet long or carry 5400 passengers. When Cuba opens up, Key West will be more attractive. The ships out of Port of Miami will be able to visit multiple ports while burning less fuel. Cuba has so much and sees so many Europeans, that marketing side trips to Key West will more than make up for the loss in Key West to Cuba. There has been a long and romantic link between the two islands. People interested in Hemingway can visit La Finca in Cuba and his home in Key West. History buffs can come from Cuba to see the birthplace of Cuban Independence. In this analogy, Key West is the tail and Cuba is the Big Dog!

cuba will open

and key west will be a ghost town.

In

your dreams!

Greed and putting all your eggs

in one basket. we as idividuals should the right to say where our tax money is spent. No money for cruise ships!

Widen the channel, widen the

Widen the channel, widen the 18 mile, and quit pretending the Keys are so "special". It's a joke, just to inflate (try to anyway) real estate prices by maintaining scarcity. The Keys fad is over, and Cuba will put the nail in the Keys coffin. The Keys are overpriced, poor quality, with arrogant attitudes and beaches like cat litterboxes. Make everyday like Fantasy Fest, bring in the tourists, bring in the money. The facade that the Keys is a classy, upscale destination is over.

HEEY!!!!! Your such a ninny!

Why are you so negative. The Keys are special. The housing market will come back! You should be looking to buy now while prices are so cheap. Any one who does not own property in the Keys is stupid. People still want to come to the Fabulous Florida Keys and Key West. We have a diverse tropical splenderful lifestyle. You sound like some stubborn old homophobic person who needs to be liberated. Do you live in the cess pool of Miami or New York! Well maybe your just not a Keysie type person. The Keys the rules are different here! TEE HEE TEE HEE TEE HEE!!!!!

you wrong

I don't know what you want to said but,you are wrong, the keys life styles is merely a insult to the real human life styles. No shoes, no pant, no clean, only orgy and lascivy.

Dear Mr. (or Ms.) Provincial

Cuba's tourism economy is TEN TIMES the size of Key West's. Maybe we could actually develop heritage tourism, instead of merely sex and rum in the sun. Cuba is welcome to that clientele.
More Florida Keys Headlines
Thursday, February 9, 2012
Thursday, February 9, 2012
Wednesday, February 8, 2012
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Thursday, February 9, 2012 -
Wednesday, February 8, 2012 -
Wednesday, February 8, 2012 -
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 -
Monday, February 6, 2012 -
Sunday, February 5, 2012 -