Florida Keys News
Wednesday, November 18, 2009
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
Mugging suspect wants mental health tests

A 17-year-old boy accused of mugging three people on Key West streets this summer may be incompetent to stand trial, according to his attorney, who has asked the state to pay for mental health tests.

Thomas Reza's "erratic behavior" warrants an evaluation, Key West attorney Victoria McFayden wrote in a motion she filed last week.

"The defendant's mother is concerned that ... (he) is having a mental breakdown because he has been exhibiting disturbing behaviors such as head-banging, causing physical injury to himself," the motion states, adding that he is being treated at the Care Center for Mental Health in Key West.

It remains unclear whether Reza "possesses the ability to appreciate the charges or allegations against him and the nature and range of possible penalties," McFayden wrote.

Reza, who has pleaded not guilty, faces at least five years and eight months in prison if convicted on three felony charges of robbery, battery and aggravated battery. The State Attorney's Office is seeking to prosecute Reza as an adult.

The cost of the mental health evaluations has not been determined, but the average price for similar tests in other cases has been about $200, Monroe County Chief Assistant State Attorney Don Barrett said.

The state is prepared to argue that Reza is mentally competent to stand trial.

"I think that although Mr. Reza has some issues, I doubt that a court would declare him incompetent, though that remains to be seen," Barrett said. "We're prepared, despite whatever the doctor or doctors may find, to argue that he is not incompetent. I'm hesitant to say why at this time because it deals with specific arguments that I intend to make in court."

McFayden could not be reached for comment Tuesday.

Circuit Judge David Audlin has not set a date to hear the motion. A trial date also has not been set, as attorneys are still interviewing witnesses and gathering evidence, Barrett said.

Reza and his co-defendants -- Christopher Harris, 17, of 322 Truman Ave.; Cornelies Jones, 17, of Duck Avenue; and Jonathan Bien-Aime, 18, of 1300 15th Court -- are accused of beating former Key West City Commission candidate Tom Milone moments after mugging 65-year-old Key West resident Don Sullivan on July 13.

Sullivan was mugged in the 600 block of Elizabeth Street; Milone was attacked near the cemetery at Frances and Angela streets, according to police. Milone, whose jaw was broken and several teeth knocked out, was taken to a Miami hospital for treatment.

Reza also was charged in the July 8 mugging of a 64-year-old New Jersey resident, Suend Lee, at the corner of Fleming and Grinnell streets. Lee was attacked from behind about 9 p.m. as he returned to a guesthouse after dinner, reports say.

Reza, Harris and Jones were released from jail after posting bond; Reza's was $75,000, while Harris' and Jones' was $45,000. Bien-Aime remains in jail in lieu of a $45,000 bond.

alinhardt@keysnews.com

Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

b.s.

he is banging his head because he got caught!

If his name isnt Acevado

hes screwed.

By the way, where ARE you, coach?

You need to remind us again just how wonderful this "troubled" young football player really is.He could score! Come on, coach, please tell them about him. You did mean what you stated earlier, didn't you? You are going to stick with him to the end of this, aren't you? Please do. He needs you now.Don't bail on him, now.He was our hero on the field.

This is a rare opportunity that must not be wasted.

Some of our violent young felons were finally apprehended in a high profile case that now has to be addressed by the justice system. These ideal circumstances are unlikely to be again any time soon.This is exactly the time to make an example, especially to the parents of the borderline thug wannabes, that they must start being parents.That's who is responsible for puking these animals out and inflicting them on this world.Especially if thier mentally defective. That is your reponsibility just like it was my family's to deal with. It's not easy, but it is the family's responsibility. If you relinquish that duty, then it becomes the Justice system's duty to protect us all from them. If a CCP owner doesn't do it first.This young man has bought a nonrefundable ticket by his actions...5 yrs. would be an insult to Mr. Milone...Please don't let him loose on us again,or he will be dealt with. I'm a little sorry for Mom.Because Moms raise thier sons, too. How does Dad feel about his son? Is he a little bit concerned, too? Why weren't you paying enough attention to him before this? Good luck.To all of us.

So what if he has "mental issues"?

I don't go for the "insanity plea" BS at all. If the guy has "mental issues", OK, recognize that he's sick in the head, and mete out the punishment. If he's nuts, he's probably even more dangerous on the streets than if he weren't. Reagan may have shut down a lot of mental institutions, but under him we sure built a lot of prisons. This kind of character is exactly who should be in them.

How's Harry Bethel's son's Arson Prosecution Going??

It's all bubba all the time down here

A

FOR CRYING OUT Loud you people act like these kids are repeated offenders um hello dont you think kids makes mistakes in life. every one desreves a secound chance. not just rich white kids!!!!!!!!!!! and i happin to know one and he is as sweet as can be never in any trouble before.so stop being jerks i know they aare wrong for what they did .

Oh, you're totally delusional - or a parent of one of the thugs

You don't read for comprehension, do you? This one kid has been involved in THREE muggings. THREE!?!?!?! So...he's NOT a repeat offender? This kid lost his second chance after his first mugging. Nail his scrawny, underwear-exposed a**.

Cry Baby

People like you aren't part of the solution, you are part of the problem.

Get your head out of there

Get your head out of there and see the daylight.

for crying out loud

In today's Crime Report is a nice story about Key West kids just having fun (beating and urinating on a man). Last night I came across 2 tourists from Italy at the corner of Petronia and Whitehead. They had been given directions to Hemingway House by two black youths on bikes. "Go down Petronia to Fort St." I got them in the right direction and watched them as they got to Hemingway House. Sorry that your "MUG and THUG just didn't work out this time. Where are these thug kids parents. I'm sure that when they got to the end of Petronia these sweet kids were going to serve these tourists ice cream and cookies. IT"S TIME TO TAKE OUT THE TRASH!!!!!!!HDR

They are repeat offenders

They mugged one old man and traveled a couple of blocks and almost killed the second

I'll bet this was just the first time the sweet things were caught

His second chance was after

His second chance was after he robbed the first guy. It came and went when he decided to rob the second guy. End of story.

You have to be kidding

I can buy that you make a mistake, once....maybe. You don't repeatedly BRUTALLY attack people. SWEET? I think YOU might be the with mental issues.

Hey Coach....

Where's your big support now? He was such a responsible student. Now he's incompetent or is it just ok to lie to a court of law? Nice example for our students and community - ok go beat someone to a pulp and then we'll make up stories to keep you out of jail.

How about testing him for

How about testing him for drugs!! That likely the reason for his 'erratic' behavior. Since he's under a microscope and not using, they need to do the hair test for long time use. It's disgusting that when they are caught they scream mental problems.

Agree

They are all "MENTAL". Would a “Normal” person even consider beating up people and stealing their money? If they weren't, “MENTAL” they wouldn't be committing crimes such as this. Being “MENTAL” shouldn't be an excuse for committing crimes and not being held accountable for them.

the Law should apply for everyone!!!!!

Three kids beat up 3 elderly people and they want to plea insanety? I'm disgusted!!!. Them boys are living well, while their victims will never be the same!!!. They need to punish them, like the THUGS that they think they are!!!!!

I noticed in the crime report today that three teens kicked and

beat a man by the Regal Cinema, then urinated on him. Way to go, Conch parents. You're raising some real gems! Guess these little thugs will be on the City Commission soon.

Not All conch parents!

Dont single out conch parents! Kids doing these horrible things to others come from all walks of life from all over this country. Many of them come from decent families. Singling out Conchs and blaming US for this behavior is just ridiculous!!

See post below:

"Well, I'm not aware of a stream of 16 yr olds coming down from Submitted on Thu, 11/19/2009 - 9:19am the mainland just to hang at the cinema in New Town and kick and urinate on a guy. It stands to reason that kids out at that hour, at a local hangout are going to be local kids and of course, their parents are generally Conchs, as are they. "

Conch Parents?

What makes you think these are Conch kids? This has nothing to do with Conchs. It is all about BAD PARENTS who allow their kids to grow up as thugs. There are bad parents who are conchs and plenty who are not. Stop Conch Bashing and focus on the issue. Kids down here are out of control!!!

Well, I'm not aware of a stream of 16 yr olds coming down from

the mainland just to hang at the cinema in New Town and kick and urinate on a guy. It stands to reason that kids out at that hour, at a local hangout are going to be local kids and of course, their parents are generally Conchs, as are they.

The parents of these teens need to be prosecuted as well

and forced to pay the medical for the victims, and damages. Where do they learn this stuff? At home! I agree that 5 years isn't nearly enough punishment for what they've done.

Ut Oh - the Acevedos 'get out of jail for free' judge Audlin

Judge David 'set them free without bond' Audlin is not a good sign for the victims

Give the Head Banger 4 Solid Walls

And a reservation in the Hotel Graybar for about 20 years

Feed him more lead-based paint chips

only 5 years

only 5 years for mugging and almost killing 3 people...Certainly not enough time to pay for his crimes...5 years each MINIMUM. Violent crimes deserve long prison sentences. Reza does not deserve sympathy...His victims do

Another case of criminals

Another case of criminals failing to take responsibility for their actions. Poor me. "It was my upbringing." "The school is at fault." "The government didn't take care of me and should have known." I say hang 'em all.

And this is one we're seeing lately "It's the CITY's fault for

hosting Fantasy Fest". HUH??? The CITY is at fault because a couple of gangs of thugs, one local and one from Broward, mixed it up and someone died? I agree....I'm tired of these supposed adults not talking responsibility for their own actions. If you're old enough to buy your booze, you're old enough to be responsible for what you do when drinking. And parents, YOU should have taught them better.

And parents failing to take responsibility for their own actions

The parent never noticed head banging before? Well, duh. The parent obviously didn't notice that her brat was out at 2 AM, right? She's as much at fault as he is.

Test This...

He didn't know you are not supposed to attempt to kill people??

The lengths that some Lawyers will go to these days....

Well, let's see. Did this punk exhibit any of these "mental issues" prior to these muggings...with his little buddies? Is there anything on record with any facilities or doctors about these "mental issues" prior to these attacks? Doubtful. Very, very doubtful. More than likely, these "head banging" attacks come as symptoms of a much larger problem.....facing 5 years in jail. (That will do it every time!) Why didn't the other 3 17 year old youths try desperately to stop him? Do they all have "mental issues" now? This is bull. Honestly, it is scary to me what lengths Lawyers will go to, to create lies intentionally to counteract the truth. What is the truth anymore? Do we even know? "If it looks like a rat, walks like a rat and smells like a rat....it "ain't" a mink. Try them as adults, and throw the book at them.....if they're found guilty. Stop this violence.

only 5 years ?

If this is the sentence they would receive ,time served would be much less according to prison guidelines for "good behavior". They would come out more schooled , more hardened for more of the same. Next time killing someone. Answer...send them to Somalia.

Looks

like the Acevedo defence is contagious.

Good one!

Ya beat me to it.
More Florida Keys Headlines
Thursday, February 9, 2012
Thursday, February 9, 2012
Wednesday, February 8, 2012
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Thursday, February 9, 2012 -
Wednesday, February 8, 2012 -
Wednesday, February 8, 2012 -
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 -
Monday, February 6, 2012 -
Sunday, February 5, 2012 -