Florida Keys News - Key West Citizen
Tuesday, December 15, 2009
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
School Board mulls appointed superintendent vote

The Monroe County School Board is expected to approve a ballot initiative today that once again asks Florida Keys voters whether their schools superintendent should be appointed rather than elected.

If the ballot language is approved, it will be the fourth time since 1976 that the question has gone to voters, who repeatedly have rejected the option of a superintendent hired by, and answering to the board. That was before this year's alleged theft and lack of financial oversight, coupled with former Superintendent Randy Acevedo's conviction on three official misconduct charges.

What happened this year may have changed the public's mind about the issue, board member Debra Walker said.

"I've always supported having an appointed superintendent," she said. "If the political climate is different now after what happened in the past year, the only evidence I have is for the first time ever, the board is unanimous in its support of it."

The board will discuss the hoops it must jump through to bring the initiative before the voters. It must ask the County Commission to put the question on the ballot, ensure the proper paperwork is filed at the Supervisor of Elections Office and figure out how to educate the public on the initiative.

If the board approves the language during its meeting at Coral Shores High School, the question will be part of the Aug. 24 statewide primary elections ballot. It will read: "Shall the superintendent of schools of Monroe County be appointed by the School Board upon expiration of the current superintendent's term?"

The term ends in November 2012.

Also on today's agenda, the board will:

• Discuss Y-Net Inc. of Melbourne, a contractor allegedly paid at least $408,000 more than its contract cap by contract administrator and Instructional Technology Director Ken St. James. Burke on Monday said co-owner Danny Yahn also subcontracted the work to unknown workers without notifying the district or School Board.

"I would have expected to have them follow the rules to notify the district and I'm kind of assuming at the moment that we do not have that," Burke said.

Any workers entering schools must be have passed criminal background checks and have proper bond insurance. Burke said St. James has been asked to identify the workers and show proof that they have been vetted for work on school property.

• Consider renewing a contract for Julie Davis, an independent accountant in Harrison County, Miss., who reviews the district's budget, account balances, payouts and incoming payments, cash receipts and monthly financial statements.

Davis, who would make $27,500 between Jan. 1 and June 30, has been criticized for not discovering instances of financial mismanagement as she reviewed the books in past years, board member John Dick said.

"It's something we've been saying for a while," Dick said. "In fact, [former Finance Director] Kathy Reitzel told me she was going to cancel this contract, but Kathy's employment ended before she could do so. We'll talk about what to do next with this contract. I'm not sure it's one we want to keep."

Board member Steve Pribramsky said he'll approve the contract long enough for Burke to create a new leadership team. The district's new chief financial officer, Michael Kineer, started work Monday. His first task will be to tighten the district's financial policies and accounting procedures.

"I'm not for yanking the job right now and leaving a black hole in the system," Pribramsky said of Davis' contract. "We need time to get the new procedures in place."

• Consider a 2009-2010 contract with the United Teachers of Monroe.

jguerra@keywsnews.com

Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

You wait!

The bad news is the voters are going to vote this one down! We will be stuck with some Bubba. Let me predict it now! Here is who will run: Mikey H., Harry Russell, Pedro Fraga, Morgan McPherson, Double Dippin Gootee, Mikey's Sister or some other croney looking for a handout from Ed Swift. Y-Net will be back. Sonny Booker will be a principal and Mark Hooper will be in the saddle again. Probably as some exective director of solid waste. We need a pro, not another Bookie.

Maybe, maybe not. Rumors are

Maybe, maybe not. Rumors are that if KWHS does not inprove it's bottom 25% of FCAT scores, the entire school administrative staff might have to be replaced. Marathon might just get it's wish; Harry Russell at KWHS as principal next year!

Marathon's wish

... is Harry Russell ANYWHERE ELSE next year!

I'd rather have the School Board do it.

I would much rather have the School Board search for (via a nationwide search, the way most good school systems in the US do it) and hire a PROFESSIONAL EDUCATOR to run the school system than continue using the popularity contest (election) that's been used in the past... a popularity contest which is almost always between just two people. And if the School Board had that responsibility, voters would need to be more careful in choosing School Board members. Some on the present board are probably not qualified, given how long some of them supported Mr. Acevedo, who is now a convicted felon. The Superintendent is too important a position to be trusted to a local election where the field is always extremely limited.

People Get Type Of Leadership They Deserve-- Losers Breed Losers

School Board Member Duncan Mathewson will not even enroll his own children in the Monroe County School System. Mathewson's action speaks volumes. He has chosen to direct his attention away from improving the academic standing of our students and the schools they attend, in favor of concentrating on the interests and success of his children, in their private schools. Great Leadership from a Board Member who will be determining who will run our schools. Have you ever attended the School Board Meetings and been forced to try to make some sense out of the incoherent ramblings and 'gobly gook' of Board Members Griffiths and Debra Walker. Griffiths & Walker have been on the Board for approximately 17 years. During their tenure; Teachers, Staff and Administrators who politically aligned themselves with them and their failed methods of instruction, were rewarded as they worked their way up and through our criminally corrupted school district. Little or 'no oversight' was given to the fiduciary responsibilites of our school district. Our children and citizens were robbed blind. Our students 'rank last and near the bottom' in every measureable academic area in the world, yet large sums of our hard earned money has been stolen from us on a regular basis. Is this the School Board you want deciding the fate of our children?? In fact these three should be brought before a 'grand jury' and closely examined for their part in the fleecing of our schools. We must be rid of individuals such as these. Not empowering them with additional authority over our lives and children. Every child in this county must be protected, while having their true potential and greatness cultivated by competent, brilliant and courageous individuals capable of providing them a world-class education. This will not happen with School Board Members such as these. It will never happen if they appoint our next superintendent.

How can someone write so

How can someone write so many negative comments with misinformation? Monroe Schools have been in the top 10% for over 2 decades with whatever measures the State has used for assessment. Can we do better? Of course but to print such outright lies is just plain wrong and insulting to our teachers.

Earth to poster

What planet are you living on? Monroe County kids at best rank in the middle of the state ranking. A state that itself is in the bottom 20% of the country as a whole.

They rank number one in

They rank number one in cosmetics classes and driving conch trains...

Yes, but WE hired the past administrations

It's fine to blame the school board for the acts of the past administrtation, however they did not have the power to HIRE or FIRE the hands-on leadership that has systematically raped the school system for these past many decades. It is "We the People" who have been responsible for electing the criminals who run the district. The school board is relatively powerless in the day to day operation of the district. All they have the power to do is approve the budget, or approve recommendations forwarded by the Superintendent. When you have an elected Superintendent, they have a tendency to get a little "Rogueish," because the do not have to answer to the school board at the end of the day. The question should be, given our history, should we continue to trust OURSELVES to hire the top educator in the county?

How about a fresh start?

Let's disband the school board and the entire school system, and start over from scratch. Find a way to run a school system with far fewer "administrators", and hire more TEACHERS.

Fresh start?

Slate boards and a piece of chalk! Maybe Laura Ingalls is available and we can get Mrs. Olson to run for the school board.

Julie Davis contract

Once again the Boards reaction to realizing that they have been screwed out of tax money is to ask how much longer they can keep paying the thief for not doing their jobs. If the Board had a collective brain, the first thought they should have had is, "I wonder if Julie Davis carries malpractice insurance?".

How many times NO

This board is incompetent and not capable. The voters and taxpayers can just as well make their own mistakes. Does this board not have enough to do. Stop asking Andy.

Andy did not ask in 1994 or

Andy did not ask in 1994 or 2004. Please check your facts before posting such trash.

18 years old and a registered voter

That is all the qualifications you need to have and you can be Superintendent of Schools. Our children need a professional educator and not a politician running the school system. People will never be 100% in favor of all five school board members but there are school board elections every two years and just like the County Commission, if these elected officials are not what the people want and need, they will be voted out. Superintendent of Schools is too important a position to be left to the Bubba political machine, our kids and teachers deserve a professional educator not a politican running the school system, it is just that simple

18 yrs old and a registered voter

is just what I fear selecting an Supt. of Schools. While a big part of me wants a two-year elected term, I fear the 18 y/o mentality of voting for their friend's father/mother/friend/bubba. If you saw the teens (friends of Acevedo kids) circling the wagon around Monique/Randy and cursing out anyone against them you'd know why I am concerned.

"Hired" Superintenent

It is nice to see the MCSD is trying to move into the 21st Century with the hiring of the next Supt. The system of electing our Supt, a popularity contest, for these many years has gotten us in our current shape. Rest assure, it didn't start with Randy, right Bookie. Since all 5 current board members support the hiring policy versus electing, we are moving in the right direction. Simple facts, there isn't any one on the horizon living in Monroe County qualified to be an elected Supt, Mikey?, pleaseeeeeee, that is enough right there to hire the next Supt. In defense of Dr. Burke, Rome wasn't built in a day, this mess wasn't created in a day, he is on the right trace, I admit, moving slowly. Let them do there job, come back at the end of the school year, you will see the changes and hopefully, support the "hiring" format.

Superintendent

The superintendent of schools should be a contracted position (haven't we learned our lesson, people?) hired by a committee/task force comprised of SUCCESSFUL, RESPONSIBLE and RESPECTED business owners & comnunity leaders representing ALL of Monroe county, not just those looking to promote family members & drinking buddies.

Is this the same Michael Kineer

Time to appoint

Other counties do it and with cause, if there ever was a place that needed an appointed Super that would be in the Keys. If we elect again it will be a Bubba, a bad Bubba, maybe. The entire keys needs to have a say in the matter, still today too many friends and kin are running the schools and not doing a very good job of it. It is time to appoint.

Andy, son, please stop asking. The answer it NO!

“Andy of Mayberry “do you really believe we will allow you to select a Superintendant? The voters spoke loud and clear on this issue before and you again are wasting taxpayer’s money by asking again for a vote. The answer is “NO”!!! We will no allow the school board to take away our right to vote in a superintendant. Enough all ready. You remind me of a child who keeps asking hoping one day you will get the answer you want. It will not happen, STOP ASKING!!!!!!!!!

Andy did not ask in 1994 or

Andy did not ask in 1994 or 2004. Please check your facts before spreading false conclusions.

Counting chickens before egg's hatch???

Don't count on it. After the mismanagement by the prior "voted in" super my vote goes for an appointed one. By the way 2 (D & P) of the 5 presently on the board tried to address all kinds of red flags and were continuously shot down by the other three. They called in micromanagement, I call it doing what they were elected to do. Stay tuned the Conch's will attempt to put the spin on it but the rest of us are to smart for that. Time will tell, while it's unfortunate to have to look at it this way there are now more of us than them. I am most certain that I'm not alone in my thinking.

Know the process

Have you learned nothing. Graduating from Key West High is not credentials enough. If the board appointed a super it would be one with a LICENSE. This means actual training and experience. You fools are so worried about loosing your rights and YOU turn a blind eye to losing tax payer money. Time to wake up and join the rest of the state (not to mention the USA). Lets get an educator in the position of running our schools instead of a BUBBA. Our children are paying for your EGO, grow up.

Andy, son

The right choice isn't always the popular choice, this is the right choice. Why would you want to say, hey, I voted for Randy and I'm a part of the problem. I can't wait to see who lines up in support of electing the supt and why. Who will be the spokesperson, Bookie? Come on gang, the times are changing, Go Andy, John, Debra, Steve, Duncan.

I do not know what would be

I do not know what would be worse, allowing the clueless board to name a superintendant, or to allow local bubbas to keep putting their unqualified friends in the role and then looking for more do nothing jobs. Wow, both options suck for the children of Key West. Maybe we can come up with a third option like The Governor appointing someone. After all, we can not manage our own development well enough to not be an area of critical concern. My feeling is the school district is definately an area of critical concern. Lets let the State take over and the local yokels will have to find other nice jobs with HTA, Key Electric, or the city.

The Governer? He appointed Mario County Mayor !

Do we need another crook from Tallahasse ?

Good point. Bottom line is

Good point. Bottom line is the kids are the losers here and it is a real shame.

He was the only board member

He was the only board member who voted against putting this out for vote in 2004. He has changed his mind. Voters have either a right to vote for superintendent or a right to the best qualified for the students. Pick which right is more important. You can change the board every 2 years. The elected super lasts for 4 yrs unless the governor removes him or her.

Julie Davis Contract

"Davis, who would make $27,500 between Jan. 1 and June 30, has been criticized for not discovering instances of financial mismanagement as she reviewed the books in past years, board member John Dick said." Hey JOHN Dick why isn't the board being criticized for not discovering financial mismanagement. I guess the board members just signed on the line for so long without looking to see what they were signing. You should all man up and quit looking for a fall guy!!!! And the political one-upmanship keeps rolling. How pathetic.

Board members do not sign

Board members do not sign these contracts. The super who supervises staff signs them or his staff signs them. The elected super who has NO ACCOUNTABILITY to the school board. It's time to hold the supers accountable.

Re: Board members do not sign

Yo nit wit they approve the budget don't they? duh

The board approves the

The board approves the budget but not hiring decisions, that responsibility belongs to the superintendent, who does not report to the board. DUH. Nit wit.

Incompetent & Negligent School Board Unqualified To Hire Super..

Much has been written about these school scandals, nonetheless, little or no action has been effectively initiated to remedy this situation. At present, many School District Staff, School Board Members, Principals and Teachers have demonstrated a distinct inability to focus on the Academic Advancement of our Children. I doubt that they could effectively be involved in the hiring of a Superintendent. Apparently appointed School Superintendent Joseph Burke lacks the courage, determination and commitment to terminate Mike Henriquez. Mr. Henriquez was inticately involved in the previous criminally corrupted administration. To many, he is symbolic of a dark and dishonest enterprise, which had taken hold of our school district. The Governor sent Mr. Burke to clean up this district and begin the job of academically advancing our students. Instead, it appears that he has chosen to protect Mr. Henriquez' enormous salary for a job that he is not credentialed for. It would behoove Mr. Burke to avoid the beguilement of this familiar and politically depraved regime; for if not, he will find his potential as a man extinguished, as he becomes another discarded Florida Keys political casuality. The Children deserve fresh clean leadership, why don't you give them some.

The school board can change

The school board can change every 2 years and this is a terrible arguement against moving into the system that 99% of the country follows. Who sits on the school board NOW has nothing to do with this issue.

qualified superintendent

I have been in the education field for over 40 years and have been in several different school districts across the country. I also know many superintendents and how they were hired. Of all the districts and superintendents that I know none have been voted on for their position. Most school districts have a very rigorous vetting process to pick the highest position of a school system. The first requirement of any superintendent that I know of is to have a PhD in the field of education and to also have had been in the school system moving up the ladder from teacher, counselor, vice principal, principal, district administrators and finally superintendent. This is necessary in order to have someone who knows all the various parts and systems within the district. The second requirement of all those that I know is that they have had numerous interviews by various segments of the entire community, including students, teachers, school employees at all levels, community groups, parents and finally all board members. All the the groups involve have a say in the hiring process. I would only hope that Monroe County takes the job of superintendent seriously enough to change they way one becomes the most important person dealing with our precious future and not allow it to be a political game anymore.

qualified superintendent

I have been in education for over 40 years and have lived in several different parts of the country. All the areas of the country that I am aware of go through a very intensive vetting process of hiring the most important person dealing with our children. First of all every superintendent that I know has impeccable qualifications including that of a PhD in an education field, has been in the school systems and moved up the ladder of positions from teacher to principal to other admisinstrative positions to several assistant superintendent postions to finally superintendent. The vetting process is also long, detailed and complete with interviews from a variety of community groups including the public, students,teachers, designated community groups, different school personnel from all levels of employees and the school board - and all groups have a say in the hiring. It seems like a given that the entire community would want to see such a process take place when we are dealing with our precious future.

Really?

In my mind it's the voters who have proven themselves unqualified to choose a superintendent.

Communist

This is exactly the crap that Fidel Castro believes which is why he made himself the leader for life. When you lose faith in the power of one man one vote, then you lose democracy, and when you lose that, then you are in serious trouble. Think before you post here please. I look forward to every election, to vote for and whom I believe in, and I will never give up that basic freedom.

Wow. wake up fool, you vote

Wow. wake up fool, you vote for the board. Your vote puts them there and it is their job to find the best QUALIFIED (not most popular or most bubba) superintendent. Like you said, think before you post!

The other 99% of school

The other 99% of school districts in our nation are not communist you idiot.

I could not agree more! Why

I could not agree more! Why is Henriquez still employeed! Can we please have some accountabiity!!?!??

CAVE people, (citizen's

CAVE people, (citizen's against virtually everything) should not post here. Five elected policy makers have made very good 5:0 decisions. The split decisions look ugly and that's called democracy. You should not equate ugly with incompetent and negligent. I know all of these people and they are not stupid.

School taxes

Can I get a tax break as a non-breeder?

Hey Look, I get your point

Hey Look, I get your point but I don't commit crimes but I'm taxed to build and maintain prisons. Education is cheaper.

Thank your lucky stars you

Thank your lucky stars you do not have kids. All you are losing is money. The breeders down here are losing their kids education to politics and cronyism.

...and who will be paying for your medicare?

You better hope that this county's children receive the best education our money can buy otherwise there is no way we will remain competitive in the 21st century. You can be spending your non-breeder elder years in a dystopian Key West bemoaning the fact that you have no progeny to swat the dengue carrying mosquitoes from your malnourished and sickly body.
More Florida Keys Headlines
Friday, July 30, 2010
2 comments
Friday, July 30, 2010
Friday, July 30, 2010
1 comment
Friday, July 30, 2010
Friday, July 30, 2010
1 comment
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Friday, July 30, 2010 -
Thursday, July 29, 2010 -
Wednesday, July 28, 2010 -
Tuesday, July 27, 2010 -