Florida Keys News - Islamorada/KL Free Press
Wednesday, February 3, 2010
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
Sea-level researcher: Florida Keys to resemble Venice, Italy

KEY LARGO -- You might not be able to hire a gondolier along U.S. 1 any time soon. But sea level rise could have portions of the Keys looking a little bit more like Venice in the coming decades.

That's was the message of University of Miami geologist Harold Wanless, who spoke about sea level rise before a packed crowd of more than 100 at John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park last week. The lecture was part of the park's "Delicate Balance of Nature" series.

Wanless jokingly titled his lecture "The State of the Conch Republic Address" because he delivered it at the same time as President Obama's Jan. 27 State of the Union Address. According to his report, the Keys union is in some peril.

"What I am saying is don't think about your investment in coastal areas as something that is going to be passed down to your great grandchildren," Wanless said.

Since 1930, sea level in South Florida has risen nine inches, an eight-fold increase over the rate of the previous 2,000 years, Wanless said.

That might not sound like much, but in Key West it has been enough to transform roads that were once safely elevated a foot above the mean high tide into ones that are commonly flooded, city officials report.

To date, most sea level rise has been the result of water's tendency to expand as it warms. But experts expect sea level rise to accelerate as global warming melts the Greenland, Arctic and Antarctic ice caps. In 2007, the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change concluded that global sea levels will rise between seven inches and 1.9 feet by 2100. That estimate, however, did not allow for melting of the ice caps.

As the melting of the ice sheets has accelerated, studies in major scientific journals since then have concluded that sea level could rise five feet or more by 2100.

Wanless last week said that even with major worldwide reductions in greenhouse gas emissions, he expects such a scenario to unfold.

"People talk a lot about uncertainty," he said. "There isn't a lot of uncertainty. It's four to five feet this century."

With an average elevation of less than five feet, according to The Nature Conservancy, that could mean disaster for the Keys. Low-lying neighborhoods would be largely underwater.

In addition, coastal wetlands and mangrove environments would collapse, just as they have already along Cape Sable on the southern tip of the mainland.

"Miami-Dade and Broward will be diminished and risky places to live -- including all of the Florida Keys," said one slide Wanless presented at his lecture in reference to a three to five foot sea level rise.

The Wanless speech came as skepticism of climate change science is on the rise. A recent CNN poll found that the percentage of Americans who believe that global warming is caused by humans dropped from 54 to 45 percent between the summer and December.

The decrease came on the heals of this fall's "Climate-gate" scandal, in which hackers obtained thousands of e-mails from climate change scientists at the University of East Anglia in England. In some of the e-mails, the scientists appeared to be attempting to suppress information that did not fit with their conclusions.

Wanless urged attendees at his lecture to take global warming seriously.

"If you don't buy global warming, learn about it," he said. "It is too important. Don't listen to Rush Limbaugh. He is not a scientist."

Attendees on their way out of the lecture were convinced.

"Very informative," Islamorada resident Will Dunbar said. "I'm just going to be a grandfather. They're the ones that are going to be affected. They'll be the ones who'll inherit the earth."

rsilk@keysnews.com

Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

The Keys

Don't you remember in the late 8o's when folks skied down Duvall St. 4 wheelers took people on dingy rides.Had to put your feet on the first rung of the bar stool to to keep your feet out of water.While sitting Sloppy Joe's. Watching the goings on as you have canceled your charter. Another in Ricks, Captain Tony's .May hit the Bull & Whistle,Green Parrot for sure.And maybe the Compass Rose on the way home,etc-etc. Next day we were dry. Basically we will adjust to circumstance. Please don't cause a bureaucracy of an Army of Life Guards. Kit-Key's 79 t0 95

The Keys

Don't you remember in the late 8o's when folks skied down Duvall St. 4 wheelers took people on dingy rides.Had to put your feet on the first rung of the bar stool to to keep your feet out of water.While sitting Sloppy Joe's. Watching the goings on as you have canceled your charter. Another in Ricks, Captain Tony's .May hit the Bull & Whistle,Green Parrot for sure.And maybe the Compass Rose on the way home,etc-etc. Next day we were dry. Basically we will adjust to circumstance. Please don't cause a bureaucracy of an Army of Life Guards. Kit-Key's 79 t0 95

man-made global warming

The Earth travels through different orbital paths over time. Some paths are closer to the sun and some further. This is why climates of the past vary. At one time Los Angeles was a sub-tropical environment, but today it is warm-temperate. This transition could not have been related to man's activities since it happened long before the industrial revolution. And besides, it is said that the Earth is 4.5-6 billion years old. How can anybody judge what normal climate change is with only 150 years of temp. data? Not to mention the fact that temp. measuring equipment was not as accurate 100 years ago as it is today. Allowing for this margin of error would certainly make claiming the Earth is warming a bit premature.

We Know What To Do

1) Bulkheading, dredging and filling have been going on down here forever. Much of Key West was once bay bottom -- Trumbo, Fleming, Ft Zack, Publix, the airport, etc. 2) More and more of our homes are being elevated. In other words we know what to do and are doing it already. However, the long-term rate of sea-level rise is more like 1.5 mm/yr, not the 7.5 mm/yr Mr Watson quotes, from what I know and moreover I see no reference to his data source. In reality the Keys are a good source of sea level data as we are geologically stable and we have a long period of record in our tidal gages. jimijr

What a load of nonsense. The

What a load of nonsense. The Keys realtors will be excited; they can spin this as more "water-front" property.

Old town

Does that mean we won't have the old town trolleys anymore and now there will be old town gondoliers everywhere? "one gondolier in the channel equals three outboards out of the water"

And this is bad?

This is just Nature's way of paying back developers and real estate agents for screwing us all. I can't wait to see all the high rises in Miami under water. The same thing will happen to those that will sooner or later rise here. Ice bergs in the Casa swimming pool will be a major tourist attraction, though.

'No evidence for accelerated sea-level rise'

'No evidence for accelerated sea-level rise' says Royal Netherlands Meteorological Institute – December 12, 2008 Excerpt: In an op-ed piece in the December 11 issue of NRC/Handelsblad, Wilco Hazeleger, a senior scientist in the global climate research group at KNMI, writes: “In the past century the sea level has risen twenty centimeters. There is no evidence for accelerated sea-level rise. It is my opinion that there is no need for drastic measures. It is wise to adopt a flexible, step-by-step adaptation strategy. By all means, let us not respond precipitously.” http://www.climatedepot.com/

'No evidence for accelerated sea-level rise'

'No evidence for accelerated sea-level rise' says Royal Netherlands Meteorological Institute – December 12, 2008 Excerpt: In an op-ed piece in the December 11 issue of NRC/Handelsblad, Wilco Hazeleger, a senior scientist in the global climate research group at KNMI, writes: “In the past century the sea level has risen twenty centimeters. There is no evidence for accelerated sea-level rise. It is my opinion that there is no need for drastic measures. It is wise to adopt a flexible, step-by-step adaptation strategy. By all means, let us not respond precipitously.” http://www.climatedepot.com/

Bye-Bye Florida Keys

Seems like property values will continue to drop in Florida, especially in the Keys. Nobody wants to be the greater fool throwing good money after bad in that environment. It may be a good time to reverse the migration and head back up north, or out west, looking for some higher elevations to call home.

Actually, the IPCC's estimate...

... of future sea-level rise is on the conservative side as it doesn't take into account any melting of Greenland or Antarctic ice. The rise cited by Wanless in the past century is valid... and in fact, the rate of rise was higher in the last 1/3 of the last century than the overall 100-year rise. If, as some of you claim, global warming is some kind of myth or hoax, how would you explain the loss of ice that is well-documented and undeniable? You may not feel any warmer, but do some news research on what's happening in the arctic.

In 1973, experts told us that the world was almost out of fuel!

Back in 1973, when there was a very serious gas shortage, lines to buy fuel and "on" days and "off" days for buying fuel....we were told by "experts" that there was no more fuel. It was over. We had abused it too much by overcomsumption and driving big, gas guzzling cars. Very convincing arguments. What year was that? Oh ya. 1973. Huh. Guess they found some more someplace.

GO RUSH...

The treehuggers have been exposed for this global warming scam

And we should believe the head of the IPCC?

He's not a scientist either. He's a railroad engineer! AGW is the greatest scam in the history of mankind. Hide the decline! Mann and Jones will be going to prison in the near future and people like Witless, sorry, Wanless will be out of jobs and on the streets.

So...

where are the glaciers going? Are they just making themselves invisible to trick us into recycling and using less? Just curious...

Once again

You right-wingers missed the point. I don't care if it's called global warming, global cooling, climate change, or Gore-aid. Humans have an undeniable effect on the planet. For one, look at mount trashmore as you enter or leave KW. Did Gore put that there? You people are so angry that times change, and someone may "force" you to recycle, or Obama spends money on researching cleaner energy sources. Keep denying the fact that we are changing the earth. That's really productive. Thanks for helping out!

Who's really productive? Who's really helping out?

The effect humans have on the climate is still in debate. What is not is that people like you have made it a fore gone conclusion in order to advance your agenda. You said it yourself "and someone may "force" you...” You let the cat out of the bag my statist friend, it's not really about the climate or green energy is it? It's about exerting control over people, and if those people have to suffer greatly to make it so that’s OK because when you have established your nanny state things will magically become better. What you and your leftist ilk don’t understand (or don’t care about) is that your agenda doesn’t push people up it brings people down to equal misery. Your progressive agenda is hitting a wall and people in the mainstream of America like me aren't going to take it anymore. We're taking our country back one election at a time, and there's absolutely nothing you can do about it.

You are nuts...

missed the point again angry man....My agenda, today, is to clean up my yard of all the trash that my "neighbors" let fly all over the place. After that my agenda includes having acouple drinks and watching the Super Bowl. And I'm going to recycle the bottles...ooooh scary agenda huh?...quit being so damned paranoid.

Say what?

You mean to tell us that the Rosenstiel School of Marine and Atmospheric Science hired a RAILROAD ENGINEER as a geology professor? I doubt it. And you purport to be exposing a lie?

The IPCC is the lead cheerleader for AGW

If you pulled your head out of the sand you would know that. Wanless is just an echo chamber for them. Besides, 20 years ago dr. hansen of NASA predicted we would already be underwater. That prediction failed, so the alarmist crowd adopted their new tactic of lying louder http://wattsupwiththat.com/2009/10/22/a-little-known-but-failed-20-year-...

That's why

the good loard maded fill dirt.....

Good Loard!

Maded fill dirt???

Yeah, and just where...

... do you think all the dirt will come from? By digging holes somewhere else?

But The Local NAR Keeps Pushing Us To Buy A Home

Ruh-roh. If sea levels rise, as the article suggests, 4 to 5 feet this Century, then who is going to buy an underwater house from some homeowner who is underwater on their loan?

the rise in sea level

has something to do with all the vessels on top creating pressure..not global warming every ship,cruise liner,container ships boats subs,all add to sea level rise.was this figured into your equation as these things werent here 500 years ago either.

rise in sea level,

so if we hauled all the ships out ,it would be like a low tide ? All the time? Also that would mean when New Orleans flooded , the sea level should have dropped worldwide? So , therefore the flooding of New Orleans was benifical to the global community ?. So we should have left it flooded to slow global warmings effects. Next , Holland, that should drop sea level a few feet. No, pump the water into the Grand Canyon, it's could hold a lot of water. Death valley, or Salt Lake city, It seems there may be many places to store this "problem water" So global warming is just a new job opportunity if you are a plumber.

re: rise in sea level

using that logic ,if I take enough fish out of the ocean ,sea levels will drop? Now, that's how I can help.

seriously?1?!?!?

C'mon man!

Then I would own "baybottom"

even more valuable than dirt.

chicken little , the sky is falling

many other countries have dealt with water sucessfully, so can we. Look at Holland as an example.

I am not a scientist. I

I am not a scientist. I just have to use common sense when I look at the changes in my canal over the last 30 years to know something is happening.
More Florida Keys Headlines
Thursday, February 9, 2012
Thursday, February 9, 2012
Wednesday, February 8, 2012
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Thursday, February 9, 2012 -
Wednesday, February 8, 2012 -
Wednesday, February 8, 2012 -
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 -
Monday, February 6, 2012 -
Sunday, February 5, 2012 -