Florida Keys News - Key West Citizen
Sunday, February 7, 2010
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
Sea-level researcher says Florida Keys will resemble Venice, Italy

You might not be able to hire a gondolier along U.S. 1 anytime soon. But sea level rise could have portions of the Florida Keys looking a little bit more like Venice in the coming decades.

That was the message from University of Miami geologist Harold Wanless, who recently spoke about sea level rise before a packed crowd of more than 100 at John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park. According to his report, the Keys are in some peril.

"What I am saying is, don't think about your investment in coastal areas as something that is going to be passed down to your great-grandchildren," Wanless said.

Since 1930, sea level in South Florida has risen 9 inches, an eightfold increase over the rate of the previous 2,000 years, Wanless said.

That might not sound like much, but in Key West it has been enough to transform roads that were once safely elevated a foot above the mean high tide into ones that are commonly flooded, city officials report.

To date, most sea level rise has been the result of water's tendency to expand as it warms. But experts expect sea level rise to accelerate as global warming melts the Greenland, Arctic and Antarctic ice caps. In 2007, the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change concluded that global sea levels will rise between 7 inches and 1.9 feet by 2100. That estimate, however, did not allow for melting of the ice caps.

As the melting of the ice sheets has accelerated, studies in major scientific journals since then have concluded that sea level could rise 5 feet or more by 2100.

Wanless last week said that even with major worldwide reductions in greenhouse gas emissions, he expects such a scenario to unfold.

"People talk a lot about uncertainty," he said. "There isn't a lot of uncertainty. It's 4 to 5 feet this century."

With an average elevation of less than 5 feet, according to The Nature Conservancy, that could mean disaster for the Keys. Low-lying neighborhoods would be largely under water.

In addition, coastal wetlands and mangrove environments would collapse, just as they have already along Cape Sable on the southern tip of the mainland.

"Miami-Dade and Broward will be diminished and risky places to live -- including all of the Florida Keys," one of Wanless' lecture slides said, in reference to a 3-foot to 5-foot sea level rise.

His speech came as skepticism of climate change science is on the rise. A recent CNN poll found that the percentage of Americans who believe that global warming is caused by humans dropped from 54 to 45 percent between the summer and December.

The decrease came on the heels of this fall's "Climate-gate" scandal, in which hackers obtained thousands of e-mails from climate change scientists at the University of East Anglia in England. In some of the e-mails, the scientists appeared to be attempting to suppress information that did not fit with their conclusions.

Wanless urged attendees at his lecture to take global warming seriously.

"If you don't buy global warming, learn about it," he said. "It is too important. Don't listen to Rush Limbaugh. He is not a scientist."

Wanless jokingly titled his lecture "The State of the Conch Republic Address" because he delivered it the same time as President Barack Obama's Jan. 27 State of the Union speech. Attendees on their way out of the lecture were convinced.

"Very informative," Islamorada resident Will Dunbar said. "I'm just going to be a grandfather. They're the ones who are going to be affected.

"They'll be the ones who'll inherit the earth."

rsilk@keysnews.com

I can not wait for the Conch

I can not wait for the Conch Tram Gondolas. Swifty is already reserving space for them! We can also sell Ernest Hemmingway galoshes for the tourists. What a great opportunity! This place is already like Venice. Over priced tourist tack, rude people, smelly dirty water... At least we have our bums and Canadians living in their vans so people can tell the difference.

Can you imagine

Randy on the back of one of those Gondolas???? Ed would have to install trim tabs on his to trim down the bow.

A Different Estimate

http://books.nap.edu/openbook.php?record_id=1345&page=99 This article offers a good primer on sea level change and estimates a long-term trend of 1.5 mm/yr, not the 7.5 mm/yr mentioned here (9" since 1930). Either way, Key West is a good spot for measurement since we are stable geologically and we have one of the longer tide records on the east coast. Here we see bulkheading, dredging and filling; homes being elevated to 8' base elevation; raising of the roadbeds like the new South Roosevelt. In other words, we'll cope just fine, change will be gradual, no problem boss!

Sinking Keys

The credibility of the Global Warming gang is finished. Stealing government grants for their pathetic "research" is enriching them and only them. It's time to wake up and expose this massive worldwide hoax.

The water levels are the same

It's THAT simple. Forget about this idiot's words and look with your EYES. Drive around the Keys and look at old docks, properties. old state roads. Sea level has NOT risen. In fact, I am seeing more of the sea bottom rising through the water now than I ever have. Look at Bahia Honda and look around Ohio Key just south of 7 mile bridge. Look along Sugarloaf Key off the southbound lane. The waters are going DOWN if anything. These idiots are looking to keep getting government reasearch grants so they will do and say whatever it takes--including public lectures--to secure those monies. It's a game and they all play it.

Open Your Eyes

Sorry, but you are wrong. You don't see it by just driving around. If you had a waterfront home that you have been in for at least 5 or 6 years, you would notice the difference also. I do not buy in to Global Warming or any of that B.S., but there is no doubt the sea level around here is rising. Like the other person who refuted you, I also have concrete steps that were always dry and now have water on them at high tides. It certainly is not an illusion.

Good to know...

... there are people who don't believe sea-level is rising. We need to sell a home in a year or so.

this is vey true. its

this is vey true. its nothing but government trickey. they are just putting fear into people that wont even be arond when this so called "flood" happens. these people are dumb and would probably believe the sky is falling and that global warming is really happening.

spell much?

I beg to differ

I live on the water and the water is higher than it was 7 years ago when I bought my house. I have concrete steps on my seawall. It used to be the water would only rise up over the first step during hurricanes. Now, it does it with every high tide. I also have a small ledge about 2 feet below the water that was always exposed at low tide. Now, I haven't seen that ledge exposed in 2 years. My property certainly isn't sinking.

I agree with you.

Thankfully there are some people who don't have their heads in the sand. There are lots of places we didn't see water 30 years ago even at the so-called "spring" tides... that are under water at normal high tides now.

Key West will be like

Key West will be like Venice? Does Venice have tacky t-shirt shops, overpriced bad food, ugly locals and poor service? Of so, then yes, Key West is Venice.

In fact, Venice does offer

In fact, Venice does offer all these things.

go home

You are rude to comment like this. go back home or whatever "fantastic" place you must have come from..

"Go Home" ,Sorry but

the poster hit the nail right on the head! BTW the way since I've always lived here and I agree with them , does that make the truth any more valid?

Venice doesn't have

chronic Bums

Hey, who you calling a bum?

I'm just a free spirit that you jelous of.

Bye-Bye Florida Keys, Take II

Seems like very good times ahead for houseboat sales.

What happened to the 30+ comments here before?

Not sympathic enough to the agw crowd, so you delete them and run the story again? Nothing like a mini climategate for the Keys. Hide the decline! What, you mean Alaskan glacier melting was wildly overestimated? Say it isn't so! http://wattsupwiththat.com/2010/02/07/new-study-using-satellite-data-ala...

waiting for the naysayers' comments...

does global warming exist? YES! whether you believe it is caused by man or not, everyone on both sides of the argument admit it has occurred naturally in the past. then what is the argument? that the current cycle was caused by man or nature? IT DOESN'T MATTER! the only difference i can see between the two sides of this heated (get it?) argument is that the anti-g.w. people seem to be pro big biz and anti enviro and the other side are bleeding heart libs who will do anything to save the planet. sorry, but on this one i gotta go with being able to breathe and eat over $ and greed.

Al Gore

Tree huggers are at it again!

second run on this story

Filler, fill an empty space with an old story

Carbon Credit Sale two for a buck!

Everyone listen to Al Gore! Buy his bull and make him rich! This guy is on the Global warming money train! tell it to the frozen Iguana's and the dead fish in my canal! Was that snow falling! Teeheehee

Smoke

and mirrors....Lived in a wetland for 25 years...water hasn't risen an inch. I'm with Limbaugh.

i am hoping that the sea

i am hoping that the sea level increases that way i can get a bigger boat to my dock.

me to then i will have waterfront

instead of three blocks away>

You're with Limbaugh...

That says it all.
More Florida Keys Headlines
Thursday, March 11, 2010
Thursday, March 11, 2010
Thursday, March 11, 2010
Wednesday, March 10, 2010
Wednesday, March 10, 2010
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Thursday, March 11, 2010 -
Wednesday, March 10, 2010 -
Wednesday, March 10, 2010 -
Tuesday, March 9, 2010 -
Monday, March 8, 2010 -
Sunday, March 7, 2010 -