Florida Keys News
Monday, February 8, 2010
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
Board member's nonprofit seeks funds

A nonprofit that provides a music program and summer school and college prep classes wants the Monroe County school district to consider it a "vendor," making it eligible to receive district funding.

School Board member Duncan Mathewson said he wants the district to pay for half the utilities and other operating costs such as buses and teachers for the Collegiate Arts Magnet and Careers Program, which he created with Marathon resident Tina Belotti.

The program's name was changed this year from the Cultural American Music Program, and its parent organization is the Educational Coalition for Monroe County (ECMC), also created by Mathewson and Belotti.

"We want to establish more of a collaborative basis with the school district for ECMC to provide excellent programs as a vendor," Mathewson said. "It would establish the school district as a real cost-sharing partner. These are district kids, all in the same classrooms, and our summer program is an extension of the school year."

Under the plan that Mathewson is still finalizing, the coalition would provide arts credits, an environmental science course, and Scholastic Aptitude Test and American College Test prep courses. The coalition also wants to provide dual enrollment courses -- high school classes that provide college credits -- at Florida Keys Community College.

It would be the only nonprofit to receive such financial help from the district, according to School Board member and former ECMC bookkeeper John Dick. No other nonprofits provide credited courses, Mathewson argued.

"The school district didn't tell them to expand into all these different areas," Dick said Thursday. "What this appears to be is ECMC overextended itself and is now coming to the school district for a bailout. If we bail out one, we bail them all out."

Other nonprofits have mixed feelings about Mathewson's request.

Dan Dombroski, executive director of the Boys & Girls Clubs of the Keys Area Bayview Park, said it would be unfair for the district to help pay ECMC's expenses without offering the same help to other struggling nonprofits. The Boys & Girls Clubs provides after-school programs for children whose parents work in the evening and during the summer.

"We paid a total of $100 a day for electricity for the cafeteria at Glynn Archer Elementary School; that comes to $4,000 a summer," Dombroski said. "We also had to pay the school district $2,500 for school buses and had to hire a bus driver."

As ECMC and other nonprofits, Dombroski's group faces a cut in grants and thus matching funds. To pay the electric bill, Dombroski came up with a unique idea.

"We had to charge the parents an energy charge of $2 a week," he said. "We made it up with some of the parents but some couldn't pay."

The Monroe Youth Challenge Program's executive director, Sunny Booker, who also is the school district's Safe and Healthy Schools director, said she thinks ECMC should receive district money because it offers credited courses.

"I think the School Board should consider what the nonprofit is offering. Some nonprofits, like ECMC, are directly serving the school district's focus, academic achievement and providing dual enrollment and remediation credits," she said. "ECMC also provides performing arts credits. Others, while good for youth, aren't such a direct support."

While Monroe Youth Challenge receives no district money, it enjoys in-kind support. It receives bookkeeping help from the district's Finance Department and Booker has used the district's ConnectEd system, which automatically dials thousands of student and staff phone numbers to alert them of Challenge Program events. She also hires school employees to work in their off-time and uses part of her workday to organize her nonprofit's events.

Mathewson's program will use district teachers in some of the courses it offers, which makes it possible for the district to use full-time equivalent money to help pay for the teachers, Superintendent Joe Burke said.

"ECMC is unique in program offerings in the summer in which they pay staff," he said.

The School Board will meet Tuesday to discuss a proposed memorandum of understanding between the district and the coalition, but Mathewson said he may tweak it before the board discusses it.

jguerra@keysnews.com

Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

Is there any truth to the

Is there any truth to the rumor that more money was spent on the CAMP program last summer than what the district allocated for all of the high school and middle school band programs in the district last school year (teachers salaries excluded)?

rumor

I don't know but I heart a good (or bad) rumor so carry on.

Disgusting

I am willing to bet a month's paycheck that most of the whiners that wrote comments about Ms. Belotti, don't even have children that attend MC schools. When you talk about another human being, make sure that your reputation is spotless. I don't know Ms. Belotti and I probably will never meet her, but it seems that at least she is trying to do something positive for the kids. If you have a kid that is too stupid to appreciate the program, don't blame Ms. Belotti, instead look in the mirror. I use to work at the tax collector's office and I remember how many people called every year complaining that they no longer had children in the MC school system and they felt that they should not continue to pay taxes to support the schools. Ms. Belotti must be a great lady if she has motivates so many bitter people to post their nasty comments on this board. Yes, it's a free country, but where do your right to spread hearsay stop and her right for respect begin? You people in this "paradise" sure are a bitter bunch.

Bravo..

You hit the nail right on the head!!

disgusting

And do you have children in the school district? Do you know what is going on in the schools? I do. Teachers have to buy their own supplies in order to help ALL the students even the "stupid" ones. Who are you to decide who is "stupid" and who is not? COme visit the schools and see what is really happening for all the kids not those that Ms. Belotti deems good enough for her program. Schools need the money to run the programs that will help the students find success with their academic learning...not something that works against their learning academically. Learn your facts first.

Excuse me????

"deems good enough for her program.."???? Who the heck are YOU?! CAMP is open to ALL students in Monroe County. I have children in the district schools. Am I 100% happy no. I have both children very active in the arts. If it were not for the non profit programs such as ECMC's CAMP and Key's Kids my children would be denied what they love to do. The school board AND the community from Key Largo to Key West should support these programs.

I know what's going on in the Schools

Not only do I know what's going on in the schools, but I have a 9 years old and a 6 years old that go to a MC school. I've made a number of supply runs to Office Depot and K-Mart, snack runs to GFS, and have paid out of my own pocket. I was actually calling the parent stupid for not instilling in their kid respect for people that are trying to teach them something. If the shoe fits, wear it. I agreed, the schools need the money to run the programs that will help the students find success with their academic learning...not something that works against their learning academically. But let's not demonize Ms. Belotti, she could not had gotten this far without the support of parents, teachers and the school board. If you think that the board is giving away money, then make sure you remind us on election day. Or better yet, why don't you run for office?

chill

It's off the agenda,people--chillax already.

This is NOT...

Duncan Matthewson's non-profit. This was presented to him and he supported it.

Educate yourselves...

Here is where the district money goes... http://www.keysschools.com/departments/purchasing/Contracts/Default.asp Want to talk conflict of interest? How about John Dick's firm being awarded three contracts?! The same John Dick who screwed up the CAMP books when he was treasurer!

Very simple

CONFLICT OF INTEREST End of discussion.

Show us your books, your curriculum, your staff ...

Tina - Show us your books, your curriculum, your staff, everyone's certifications,and exactly how your program is now college prep. Does anyone out there know how much Tina and her kids make for working with C.A.M.P.? My child attended the program and enjoyed it. However, I found it to be extremely expensive, despite the promise of scholarships (which the kids have to go out and get on their own). There are better deals with more professional organizations out there. If the program needs subsidizing, how about they find a cheaper place to hold the summer program than at a school?

ECMC transparency

Those of you that are so intrested are welcome to contact me through our web site www.campandcareers.org. I have never have the time to spend on this "NEWS" site,after recieving several phone calls I checked it out. I prefer to be productive with my time not destructive,especially personal attacks on my family. Thank you all for your intrest,I would be pleased to provide information to any valid source. I suppose the old adage holds true "there is no such thing as bad publicity" Tina Belotti

It is not

"College Prep". The students can earn college and high school credits. Get your facts straight. Last year alone there were well over 100 HS credits earned by students at no cost to the district. Did you get that... at NO COST TO THE DISTRICT. The Belotti's do not make anything from this CAMP. Their bills and exceptional instructors are paid first and after losing grants at the last moment they scraped and begged to make ends meet last year. So what if kids and parents have to find their own scholarship sponsors?! The sports teams go around town soliciting for player sponsors. So where are the "better deals" you speak of?? We have not found one. Please share your wealth of knowledge! The CAMP program brings in instructors that hold Master's degrees in their art. Where in the Keys is there a program with this much talent and education available that is a "better deal". Also if YOU know of a "cheaper place" to hold CAMP let them know. If you want to save a buck, share the knowledge you claim to have!! If your child attended CAMP and you showed up for orientation you would know about the staff, curriculum and certifications. Want to know more? All you have to do is ask. Instead of complaining roll up your sleeves and get involved!

Regarding ANYTHING given to CAMP...

What part of "NO" don't you understand. I think the college might need to be checked out for awarding credits to students grade 9 and under for BS classes. Let's not start teaching them how to dummy down learning and earning college credits

Audit the camp's records from the past few years...

Things need to be checked out. Where did the money go exactly? Were certified teachers running the classes that students received credit for? Why is there not one professional music educator in the county in support of this program?

Not the whole truth,

I would not say that there is not one professional music educator in the county in support of this program. That is blatantly untrue. The problems goes back several years when Ms. Belotti started this program and antagonized some of the band directors. Some are still in the county, and there is some bad blood. I think the problem is not with the program but with Ms. Belotti herself, who HAS NOT made overtures to the present band directors, which has led to some very bad politics. She should have addressed these issues head on, instead she let them fester. In short, she has jeopardized her own program. If this program were run by anyone else but her, we would not be having this discussion.

How do you know...

none of the area music educators are not supporting the program?? The students that attend come from schools from Key Largo to Key West. Public, private, charter and home schooled. Most are enrolled in music programs at their schools and are told about the program via their music instructor. I have yet to meet one educator who has anything negative to say about the program.

Non profts in glass houses shouldn't throw stones

Dan Dombroski should talk, the Boys and Girls Club receives $29,000 per year from the district. This is also interesting because John Dick is a member of the Boys and Girls Club board.

Karma

Ms. Belotti. My son has to endure your Dancing in the Classrooms program. He absolutely hates it, to the point that he does not want to go to school, and he is not alone. As a former resident of Marathon, I seem to recall that you would create an huge fuss about anything that could, or would, potentially upset your son. How would you have dealt with him if he refused to go to Dancing in the Classrooms in 5th grade? Would you have reasoned with him, because that is not what I remember as your standard behavior. Think about it, and you will find that Karma always has a way of catching up with you. BTW, because of this mess, I will not support anything that has your name attached to it. Peoples attentions spans are not as short as you think.

This is easy....

The school district should not subsidize private summer school. If it is a great program that people love, then let parents pay tuition. If your child needs extra SAT prep or dance lessons, anywhere else on Earth, people pay for it. Fund raise for scholarships for children who are worthy but may not have the financial means. The school district needs it's money to provide a decent summer school program for students that need basic academic help.

The parents

DO pay tuition! CAMP simply wants the same consideration given to other programs in regard to using the school facilities. Boys and Girls Clubs received close to $29000 in support from the district last year and $23000 this year. PLUS a discount on facility fees and federal funds and county funds and a deal on a new facility. All that for afterschool programs where the kids learn nothing.

Comment Board for Comedians

You folks really make me laugh out loud. You put Duncan down, but you know how he got on the board? You idiots voted for him. You get what you vote for. Maybe next time you spineless uninformed will be responsible and educate yourselves before you vote...but at least you voted. Has anyone ever looked at the voter turnout percentages? Half the people whining anonymously on this board don't even vote probably, but are the first to say "this is ridiculous!" How about you people stop whining and vote Duncan out? He deserves it because he has shown his stupidity with focusing on dancing when half the students in the district can't even read and reading classroom are jammed up with students and being taught with uncertified and underpaid teachers at that. Vote him out or live with what you get.

When we first voted for him...

... we THOUGHT he was intelligent... and of course we also thought he lived in the part of the Keys he's supposed to represent. Then he showed his true colors by supporting Swifty's "teacher housing" on Sugarloaf that turned out to be anything but. He got re-elected because the guy who opposed him didn't bother to campaign (but still got a third of the votes). If anyone runs against him next time, I imagine Duncan will get the boot.

"You get what you vote for."

Agreed--but did you see what was running against Dr. M last time? He didn't even campaign. (Reportedly he had "issues.") I tried to be responsible and educate myself prior to voting, and found it to be pretty much the lesser of two evils. Therefore, I'm having to live with that I got. A tiny dancer.

Only in Key West would these

Only in Key West would these people not be laughed at and run out of town. More stuff you can not make up!

Mathewson's kids' school

where do his children attend? and how do you know this? If they are not enrolled in the MCSD I would find that veddy veddy interesting!

His kids attend school in

His kids attend school in Vermont.......

B&G Club

Just got a sweet deal from the county for the Stiglitz house on BPK for their club. So don't tell me they don't receive help and support from the county and school board!

Unique???

Why is Dombroski's idea of passing the enrgy cost on to the parents "unique"?? That is how the world works. Costs go up, prices increase and the consumer pays for it. Simple economics... not a "unique" way to cover costs. Duh!

I wish....

Before articles are written and people are interviewed they would know what is really going on. ECMC DOES fundraise year round!!! The Belotti's and volunteers work year round raising funds for the CAMP and Dancing Classrooms programs. What Mr. Dombroski fails to say is that Boy's and Girl's Clubs receive $29,000 a year from the district!! They also receive a great deal of community suport to raise funds year round locally and are a federally funded program. Time to see where all those funds go!! ECMC fights for every penny looking for grants and fundraising opportunites. They do not receieve and federal funding. They do rely on the MCSD to work with them to support the program. As a matter of fact several kids, their parents and Tina and Chirstina Belotti spent the Saturday of the KW Seafood Fest cleaning tables and running a handwashing station to raise funds. YES... they work VERY hard to raise funds for the CAMP program!! They offer a unique and incredible program for our youth in Monroe County. We are an arts community so we should be supporting ALL arts programs for our children!! ECMC does everything they can to stay within and below their budget. What happens when they lose a grant at the last minute... they work to raise the funds in other ways. I, a parent, was blessed enough to have our daughter attend CAMP and the instruction she received was top notch. To see her mature in her chosen art and find a new love for dance in the few short weeks of CAMP was amazing. The confidence she gained was noticed at her next audition. We as a family saw the need for help in many areas and rolled up our sleeves to help. So when the parents of children who receive services from other non-profits complain about having to pay more or something is not done... it is time for them to roll up their sleeves to help!! Thank you ECMC and CAMP staff for all you do. Cannot wait to see you this Summer!!

Thank You Sunny

Wow now I feel terrible! NOT! These activities do not help kids "BRIDGE THE EDUCATION GAP"! Teaching the fundamentals to learning do that. If we are going to spend money spend it in the class rooms. We need a better summer school program for credir recovery and to get these kids up to par. These band, dancing, and group whine activities are hog wash. Theses are things used by people who want to suckle the tax teet and portray themselves as doing something for the ridiculous salaries that they earn! This is fraud in our education system!

REALLY?

Let's see...........how convenient that the very same perk used by the CAMP Program to entice participation is now the rationale to solicit monies from the School District — credits (high school and college) are issued to students who complete the program. What a SHAM. This was a bad idea when Acevedo proposed it as a political payoff to Tina Belotti a couple of years ago. It is a bad idea now by Duncan "the district is good enough for your kids, but not for mine" Mathewson. What can he be thinking?

BURKE THE JERK SAYS:

"Mathewson's program will use district teachers in some of the courses it offers, which makes it possible for the district to use full-time equivalent money to help pay for the teachers, Superintendent Joe Burke said." HOW ABOUT CREATING A BETTER SUMMER SCHOOL SO THESE KIDS CAN CATCH UP AND MAYBE GRADUATE YOU MORON!

A PEREFECT EXAMPLE OF GREED AND POWER BROKING!

DUNCAN IS A FOOL. Tina Bilotti is looking to keep a paying job. She does not have the education or experience to be in charge of anything except her baby sitting business. She is a grass roots Flea who takes advantage of the system when ever she can. Sunny Booker is a ladder climber. She obatined her GRANT FUNDED JOB becuase Randy could not find a way to pay her with legitimate tax moneys. Her job responsibilities include Challenege day, Marathon Youth challenge, and then made up programs including school security and useless welfare programs that we need to weed out. In short she needs to go back to the class room where we need teachers. Can she teach? Remember Sunny helped Randy get elected. She asked Judge Jones for clemency at his trial. She is being paid $100,000.00! We dont need this Acevedo political patronage posisition any more! The Grant ends in June!!!! Bye Bye!

Here goes the Gang of Three

So Mathewson may show himself to be more corrupt than even Walker or Griffiths. Here he is lobbying the School Board for a non-profit he started and runs. Hey Duncan, how about showing us how much money you get from this non-profit? Does he get a salary, reimbursed expenses for travel or supplies? This group is so corrupt and I cannot believe I am even reading this. Let's hope Dr. Burke, John and Steve can figure out a way to derail this before the kids and taxpayers get ripped off again.

MATHEWSON

RESIGN NOW!!!!!!!

Tina Belotti

Welfare fraud queen.

CAMP

The name change is a classic tactic to shove another useless program down the taxpayer's throat. Why not name it ....." Cash Added (to) Mathewson's Pocket " ?

C.A.M.P.

Best comment of the day!

nonprofit seeks funds

The only ones that benefit from a nonprofit organization are those on the payroll. Plus, $100 a day for electricity in a cafeteria? What are they "cooking" in there?

My Child atteded Camp and

My Child atteded Camp and Careers program last year and Loved it. He received school credits, made new friends, had FUN and became more well rounded. This programm deserves our support.

Your child did what?

Apparently your child must have helped you spell, and structure that sentence. How many things are wrong with it? Your child should have taken some remedial English courses instead. You have just proven that YOU are not smarter than a 5th grader!

Just say NO!

Just say NO!

Does the MCSD have extra money????

If so lets put it to support core programs, help students to read..write...do math. Put it to meaningful and effective summer programs that produce legitimate and needed learning outcomes.

Funding for a grant-based program with FTE dollars?

Which district does D. Matthewson represent? Is he aware of the fact that there was NO summer school program at Sugarloaf this past summer? That the Big Pine and lower Keys students were asked to bus it down to Key West? Does Dancing in the Classroom or CAMP retrieve credits for struggling middle school students? Ask what programs are are planned for the school district Duncan represents, tell us there will be a fully funded academic summer program available to all at-risk students, and there are extra FTE dollars left over, then . . . . . parents, where are you on this matter? SAC at Sugarloaf meets this Wed. evening in the media center at 6 pm.

Our community needs to care

Our community needs to care as much about providing our children with a good education as is does about high school baseball. Several credible studies have shown that integrating fine arts into the curriculum improves students' skills in what we think of as the basics (reading, writing, math and science). We also need to increase the graduation requirements for the humanities, including civics and history.

Curriculum

If ECMC offers credited courses, let us see the curriculum. Remember Ms Belotti, national and state standards do NOT constitute curriculum. I saw the so called "curriculum" for "Dancing in the Classroom". Your flimsy 10 or so pages does not constitute a curriculum. "Activities that are fun" are not curriculum, although I would say honestly, most kids were NOT having fun. Parents and students are upset. It is time for some scrutiny! If this organization in an educational vendor, lets hold then to the same standards as other vendors, NEFEC etc.

dancing in the classroom curriculum

where does one go to view this curriculum that is costing quite a bit of money

how do you spell...

conflict of interest?
More Florida Keys Headlines
Thursday, February 9, 2012
Thursday, February 9, 2012
Wednesday, February 8, 2012
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Thursday, February 9, 2012 -
Wednesday, February 8, 2012 -
Wednesday, February 8, 2012 -
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 -
Monday, February 6, 2012 -
Sunday, February 5, 2012 -