Florida Keys News
Wednesday, February 24, 2010
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
Musicians want symphony to pay
More concerts planned despite rocky finances

Musicians who performed with the local symphony orchestra are no longer playing a happy tune, as many of them have not been paid for their January performances.

The Key West Symphony Orchestra is struggling financially while reorganizing and expanding its reach to Fort Lauderdale venues.

Musicians who played in the January concert series, which ended Jan. 16, have not been paid for those performances or reimbursed for their travel expenses. They claim the symphony management is ignoring them while continuing with plans for an April concert series before paying for the January shows.

Edward Boreth, president of the symphony's board of directors, on Tuesday acknowledged the problems, but said the organization is working with a new board of directors and new CEO Jacqueline Lorber to correct them.

"A lot of this happened well before my time and I am still trying to come to an understanding of what happened," he said. "We are working to get the musicians paid, because without them, there is no symphony."

Boreth, who joined the board three or four weeks ago, said many former board members resigned in November while there were plans in place to hold shows in Fort Lauderdale and Key West.

Those shows were dependent on a variety of funding sources, including private donations and a grant from the Rodel Charitable Foundation.

"But some of the money did not come in, essentially leaving [Music Director Sebrina Alfonso] holding the bag," Boreth said.

Alfonso founded the local orchestra and continues as its conductor.

"Sebrina was working frantically, but being a conductor and not a businessperson, she may not have handled the communication with musicians as well as she could have," Boreth said.

Lorber said she and others were expecting a lump-sum payment from Rodel for three concerts, but instead the money was spread out among all three shows.

"It was my understanding that all the money would come in around the second concert, but that was not the case and we were caught off guard," she said, adding that Rodel has been one of the symphony's most unflagging supporters.

Boreth said most of the musicians have received some money, but the plan is to have them all paid before the April concerts.

"There are a lot of bills to be paid and there is a certain amount of juggling going on," Boreth said, estimating each musician is owed less than $1,000, but that he did not have exact figures in front of him.

He and Lorber would not say how much money is owed, how much Rodel pledged or how many musicians performed in January. Alfonso did not return The Citizen's phone calls Tuesday seeking comment about the number of musicians who performed in January.

Lorber and Boreth emphasized that plans are moving forward for the April concert series, and the new board is seeking support from patrons that could be financial or in the form of volunteer hours.

For example, the symphony Web site is outdated and does not feature the names of current board members, Lorber said.

"We can't have an outdated Web site that potential donors will see," she said. "But that's not something we can spend money on right now."

Lorber asks anyone interested in helping the symphony with volunteer hours, Web design or financial support to contact her at jlorber@keywestsymphony.com.

mbolen@keysnews.com

Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

Key West Symphony Orchestra

As a musician who has played with the KWSO many times, I take exception to the mean-spirited comments made on this page in regard to the quality of the orchestra and the character of the conductor. You should be ashamed of yourselves. Certainly the KWSO is not the NY Philharmonic but the orchestra presents fine concerts and outstanding soloists. Ms. Alfonso has dedicated her life to bringing good music to Key West. What the group needs now is assistance both financially and administratively. This is a very grim situation for the musicians who are owed money for the January programs. Not only are they owed the stipend for the week, but also the reimbursement of their transportation costs. They gave up work at home to travel to KW to provide music for YOU. Instead of whining here on this page why don't you all step up and try to help the situation? Make some constructive suggestions instead of slamming everyone. Music helps us to experience what it is that makes us truly human. It moves the soul. The arts are what separates us from the beasts. Anyone who rejoices in the possible demise of an organization such as the KWSO is sick.

About Rodel money

The Rodel foundation trades its contributions for political favors on behalf of its benefactors. Well known among local politicos. This rag-tag symphony is an example of Key West's arrogance and bravado, serving only Snowbirds who can't live without their Brahms, together with a few locals who want their pics in Conch Boy Color. Give the money to an affordable housing fund to subsidize rent for workers who need it. Let Sabrina eat cake.

An Extravagant Conceit

The Key West Symphony is a phenomenon that requires some serious rethinking. Can a small city with a resident population of fewer than 23,000 people afford to import and house musicians from around the country in order to pretend that it is home to a symphony orchestra? In fact, the only thing local about the Key West Symphony Orchestra is Sabrina Alphonso. Musically, as symphony orchestras go, it is unexceptional and it consumes a disproportionate portion of the local financial resources that would serve better if used to support what are genuinely Key West arts enterprises. Why hasn't the Arts Council explored inviting an organization like the New World Symphony, to visit the city two or three times each year? Travel and housing expenses would be reduced because its participants are supported through stipends, could travel down together by bus, and would not need as much time down here for rehearsal. Among the justifications for the Orchestra is its involvement in school programs. In fact, members of the New World Symphony already engage in such activities in Miami and Miami Beach, and if persuaded to perform in Key West may be willing to do the same here.

RE: an extravagant conceit

Yep, why don't we give all our resources to the Studios of Key West, which brings in artists from other locations and then lets them offer classes to the locals at exorbitant rates! The REAL grass roots groups that provide a reasonable fee and add to the arts are groups like the Peoples Theater of Key West. Even people with very limited funds can participate!

Other alternatives

The community should also explore the New Philharmonic Orchestra, which is comprised of former Florida Philharmonic members. They already perform a season of concerts in Boca Raton, and probably could be coaxed to repeat their performances in Key West for a fraction of the cost of flying in an orchestra and housing them. The artistic quality would be much higher and the community would get the benefit of seeing different guest conductors.

Maybe it's time

Fantastic places are fantastic for a reason -- they do fantastical things and conjure up extravagant conceits. Something (Ft. Lauderdale?) seems to have drained most of the "fantastic" out of Key West, which feels more tired and -- frankly -- skanky every time I see it. So maybe the time for Sebrina Alfonso's extravagant fantasy is over. But really -- don't expect the New World Symphony or anybody else of a similar caliber to bother with Key West in its current state of decline. Even the better drag queens don't play the clubs on Duval anymore.

Maybe it's time

Oh honey, that's mean. Funny and mean and TRUE!!

You said it!

You got it right. This city is slowly spiraling down and the locals are too dumb to see it. As long as the conch train keeps running cruise ship passengers around and Rossi sells enough drinks, they all think the town is fine. What a shame this is happening. I come here a few times each year since I sold my house to visit the few friends who still live here. Every visit is more dissapointing. The music scene here sucks. mostly just a few left over buffett wanna be's and some guys making fun of tourists and gays in bars. The restaurants all quadruple the wine prices and serve average, overpriced food, and the shopping is pretty much knock off art, or tee shirts. Thank goodness I sold my house to some sucker about 5 years ago for 4 times what it was worth. I dont think you should worry too much about a symphony when the whole island is becoming a tacky rat hole.

RE: "An Extravagant Conceit"

Well said! Most in the arts community are not business people, and do not think like business people. Therefore they do not know how to effectively and efficiently run a business - as in "make money and pay the bills." No disrespect intended... it's just a fact!

Unfortuntely, it's not just musical artists who lack business

smarts. While I realize everyone has their own forte', many local artists feel somehow entitled to income and don't have a clue as to how to really manage their business. It puts all artists in a bad light when some don't pay their bills, some don't realize HOW their profits are made, and some simply cannot manage their time and money - and when it doesn't go the way they want it to go, they blame others.

Financial cutbacks are hurting orchestras across the country.

Even the internationally renowned Cleveland is squabbling with its musicians over pay cuts. Yes, it is a conceit, but it has always received generous support in the community. The cost of lodging, for many years, was donated totally by the Spottswood family. They still may, for all I know. Another orchestra could be brought and it would be more economical, but Sebrina Alphonso would not be conducting and she was the driving force behind its creation. The board has its work cut out for it. The symphony does bring a certain presige to the community and if it can continue, in spite of the economy, then it a tribute to those who make it happen. Don't forget that one of the greatest opera houses in the world was built in the middle of the Amazon Forest (Manaus). How crazy was that?

Confidence is High .....

.... that the Music Director has not missed a meal or a paycheck

This is the Bahama Land Trust of Symphonies and a good look at just whose and what purposes are served is in order

Re: Confidence is High

Maybe you should check into the facts and see how much of a salary has actually been drawn by the Musical Director. You may be surprised!

No Sym-Phony? Then Ms. Alphonso Would Have To Get a Job

The Key West "Sym-phony" is just another bubba workfare project on the backs of the taxpayers

Ms. Alphonso's professed lack of business acumen is second only to the product produced by her personal Sym-Phony

Regardless it is no excuse

More Florida Keys Headlines
Tuesday, February 7, 2012
3 comments
Tuesday, February 7, 2012
3 comments
Tuesday, February 7, 2012
Tuesday, February 7, 2012
3 comments
Monday, February 6, 2012
3 comments
Monday, February 6, 2012
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 -
Monday, February 6, 2012 -
Sunday, February 5, 2012 -
Friday, February 3, 2012 -
Thursday, February 2, 2012 -
Wednesday, February 1, 2012 -