Florida Keys News - Key West Citizen
Saturday, March 20, 2010
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
Archer exit to bring change
City manager is creating new job descriptions

The upcoming retirement of Key West's port director will lead to some organizational changes within the city.

Port Director Raymond Archer's last official day is March 31, but he has been enjoying retirement for the past week by using accrued leave time.

City officials are accepting applications for Archer's successor, but it is a different job than the one being vacated.

City Manager Jim Scholl wants to hire a port and transit director, who will oversee all modes of transportation within the city, including buses, cruise ships and ferries.

"I want a specific director of focus on all transportation modes because of the necessary relationships with state and federal government agencies," he said, adding that the new director will have to work with the Florida Department of Transportation, the Florida Ports Council, Homeland Security and law enforcement. "That person also will have to preserve our transportation funding."

No municipality can operate a public transportation bus system without subsidies, and the new director will have to ensure that those subsidies continue for Key West buses.

While the new port and transit director will have greater responsibilities than the previous port director, Scholl has lightened the load by removing marina management from the job description that includes a minimum annual salary of $85,000.

Marilyn Wilbarger has been promoted to senior property manager, and will oversee all city-owned property that generates revenue through leases, Scholl said.

Wilbarger also will oversee the operations of Key West Bight and Garrison Bight. Those duties previously were handled by Archer.

"Marilyn was hired as property manager for the port-area properties, but I have increased her responsibilities to include all of the city's income-producing resources," Scholl said. "A lot of things fell under the Port Department, but I believe will be better served by putting them under the property manager."

The impending development of Truman Waterfront will be overseen by Doug Bradshaw, who handles the city's areas of redevelopment, Scholl said.

Bradshaw also is one of five applicants for the port and transit director position, according to the city's Human Resources Department.

The reorganization may work well, as Archer said he often felt pulled in too many directions -- a situation that sometimes led to a reactive, rather than proactive position.

"The port is a high-profile area and someone in the new director position needs to get out there and reach out to the community to ensure that we're going in the direction people want," Archer said. "The Port Department needs to allocate more time and energy to the community."

He used the cruise ship industry as an example.

In the wake of the Sept. 11 attacks, the cruise ship industry increased exponentially, Archer said, but the city did not discuss its growth with the citizens.

He also encouraged his successor to be prepared for the opening of Cuba, and anticipate its impacts on Key West.

"It behooves us to start setting parameters now," he said, adding that he always did his best for the city. "The city needs an impact assessment of cruise ships to strike a workable balance."

Archer started working for the city in 1990 and was the director of engineering services before taking over as port director in 1998.

"I just thank the citizens for giving me the chance," he said.

mbolen@keysnews.com

Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

About Raymond...

I'm pleased to hear Raymond Archer finally state that we need (long ago needed) an impact study on cruise ships disgorging thousands of people onto one narrow Key West street. It's not just the unwashed throngs, but the environmental impact on the channel waters, the dying reef and our once-clean air. With Raymond speaking out, now maybe someone at City Hall or on the city commission will listen to what we've been telling them for years-- Cut back, limit or eliminate entirely the unwanted cruise ships packing our port.

It will not matter. Until

It will not matter. Until people who are against cruise ships really organize and take action (like protest at meetings and at the cruise ship docks), nothing will change. The business interests control this town with thier cheap tee shirts and thousands of electric cars and scooters. Even Fort Zach has turned into a nightmare of cruise ship tourists and ruined the one peaceful beach in Key West. However the concession owner and State Park loves the money! Cruise Ships are here to stay and there will be more and more, not less. Soon this town will be a destination for Cruise Ships, Stag Parties, and trashy drunks. Oh wait, it already is!

Um, have you even a basic CLUE? There are no more cruise

ships now than there were 15 years ago. There are probably even fewer since old smaller ships have been replaced by bigger ships which cannot get into our harbor. I'd be interested in seeing the city's figures on this. This fable that there are more cruise ships is something that is being concocted by some newcomer 'I got mine-rs', I guess. It surely appears to be a transparent network by a small group.

No fable, no newcomer

I've lived in Key West for 20 years. I watched Raymond Archer and John Jones stand before the city commission and promise "Oh, there won't be more than one or two cruise ships a week." I knew then that it was a lie. Since the days of the wreckers the leeches in this city have jumped at any opportunity to take as much money for doing as little work as they can. Cruise ships were manna from heaven. I've personally watched the increase in cruise ships... check out Pier B. They've got a ship virtually every day but Saturday, and soon that day will be filled. You're right about one thing... the size factor. That's the next thing they'll try to slip past us... dredging the channel to allow for the mega-cruise ships, carrying as many as 5-6K passengers. Well, we won't stand for it. Mark me on that. We will not stand for it.

In 1996 there were often three ships in port at a time, and on

some busy days, there would be two anchored out and tendering in as well.

I don't know who 'we' are that will not stand for it, but I think you have a very skewed view of what Key West is. It's (Read it slowly now so you understand) a TOURIST DESTINATION. Yes! And those people with those super-white shoes on the cruise ships? Those are what we call (Ok - pay attention again) TOURISTS. And those businesses in all those high-rent crappy shops on Duval - those are TOURIST BUSINESSES. (Are you following me now?) Now..here's a big thing for you to also note: Those tourist businesses are often owned by your neighbors and they employ locals, and they pay taxes to the city. They pay rent to the landlord who pays taxes as well. Those taxes help support the infrastructure of the city, as well as the port fees from the ships.

Do you honestly think this town could have the huge number of fantastic restaurants, for instance, that we all enjoy, if it were not for the tourists and indeed, cruise shippers are still tourists??? NO. These restaurants could not exist and again, those are your neighbors working there.

Yes, tourists can be annoying and the cruise shippers are cheap but surveys show that they do come back without their ship, and spend more money over longer visits. You really need to get over this cruise ship obsession of yours. You really need to realize that this is first and foremost, a tourist destination. If you don't like it, then I'd suggest you might enjoy Big Pine Key.

Work for the Chamber?

Is your name Panico? She'll take anything that calls itself a "tourist," even the trailer trash from the cheap cruises which find their way to Key West. Yes, unfortunately, KW is dependent upon tourists (because they never took my advice to create a Economic Development Council to explore other options). But there are different classes of tourists. We seem to have chosen the lowest possible element. And that's not only the cruise shippers. We cowtow to fat old flashers who want to get naked in our streets (and we allow them) every Halloween. If you insist on your dear tourists, it would be far wiser to court the Family market, which has made Orlando quite fat and happy financially. But the way Duval Street looks right now, combined with the number of bums we provide street housing for, a family market is out of the question. I would never allow my young kids on Duval Street (had I young kids). Now, dig me up facts about those cruise ships in '96. I was around the harbor quite a bit and certainly would remember three ships in one day at that time. Don't remember such at all. Further, I have never, ever seen a cruise shipper in a real restaurant. Never. They eat for free on the ship. Hell, the only thing they do regarding food here is leave large digested amounts of it in our facilities. You'll have a hard time defending this trailer trash to anyone but Eddie Swift. I don't know one person who has to deal with them who has one kind word to say about them. No, wait... they buy a lot of refrigerator magnets with pics of the Southernmost buoy on them. Sink the cruise ships.

I am afraid I agree with the

I am afraid I agree with the anti cruise ship postings. I have lived here my whole life and there HAVE NEVER been more ships and passengers then there are now. NEVER. It is well documented that cruise ships change a destination. These changes impact the viability of other tourists markets. The pro ship posts here are full of lies and the same fear mongering Swift uses to protect his $$$. Remember the stupid adds about how "cruise ships benefit us all"? Maybe if these businesses paid a living wage or provided good benefits, I would think differently. Cruise ships are floating sewers. They have driven up rents and brought in hundreds of distruptive businesses like scooter rentals. Key West can do better. There are other industries we could tap and other high paying jobs we can bring here for our kids. Instead, thanks to a group of powerful business interests running Old Town into the ground from their homes in Key Haven, our kids have no future staying here beyond driving a conch train or waiting tables. My guess is the poster in favor of Cruise Ships directly benefits from them with a tee shirt business or some other shop on Duval. It is all about moderation. We may be a tourist town, but there is such a thing as too much. We are there now with cruise ships.

Please prove there are more cruise ships now than in 1997.

I'd like to see your numbers .

Good heavens! You're delusional and obsessed!

AND I SUGGEST HOMELAND SECURITY LOOK AT ANYONE WHO THREATENS TO SINK CRUISE SHIPS.

No - I'm not in the tourist business but I'm a realist. This was a tourist town when I moved here 17 years ago and nothing has changed. It's also an ADULT venue. It ain't Disney, thank heavens! Exactly how do you think that we could cater to all those little ankle biters and their overly-permissive parents? Umm...no room for a theme park. No room for a dozen more Denny's nor any ChuckeeCheese's. Nothing to keep them occupied that they don't get at home, like their inane video games.

Obviously you've never been on a quality cruise but hey, that's your loss. The buffet people are indeed the waddling people who book the inside bilge cabins and that's fine for them. But to classify all cruise passengers like that is a bit low-class of YOU, since there are very few of those cabins anymore on ships. Most are now balcony cabins. I'm betting you couldn't afford an owners suite if you tried - or maybe you wouldn't know how to act with a butler and private luxury facilities. You shouldn't talk trash about things you know nothing about.

While I have never eaten there, I see cruise shippers lined up outside of Margaritaville restaurant long before they open. It's not my thing but hey, clearly they're there to spend money. I've seen them at the Bight restaurants as well.

I never, ever agree with anything Swift, Belland, Spottswood and their ilk do, but the cruise ships bring much-needed money to many small businesses. Your willingness to deny them a living makes me wonder about your value system.

I suggest the Citizen do an article on cruise ship passenger count and ship count, back in 95 and now. I was very active in the tourist business back then and entire schedules were arranged around cruise ships.

FACTS ARE OUR FRIENDS

Dear people. There is a study you can download from the cities web site that was done to look at impact of cruise ships. It lists numbers of visitors per year. in 1995-1996 there were 321,312 cruise ship visitors. There were over 660,000 in 2007/2008. I do not have the latest numbers, but they have not gone down. The study is fact. Your postings are not. There are at least twice as many now as then. Please stop spreading lies and do your research.

You are wrong. Do the

You are wrong. Do the research. Also, I can afford any cruise I like, not that it really matters. This town was a FAMILY town when I was growing up and we had tourists. Now this town is all about tourists of any class and caliber. Cruise Ship Tourists are low end. I don't care how much the cruise costs, they come on shore and spend some money, but in the process they drive out other tourists. I support keeping them, but with some limits. This is a small island, why does talk about limits scare people. Do we need 10,000 Jet Skys in the water? 10,000 scooters on the streets? I am willing to bet if there were a referendum in town stating a limit of 2 ships or 4500 people per day, it would pass so fast you would not believe it. That is what it may come to if this continues to get worse and worse.

We have met the enemy and he is Raymond

Who do you think was in charge of increasing cruise ship disembarkations exponentially after 9/11? It was Norman! And there was already a cruise ship impact study performed, except it went much further than that. It was the "Cruise Ship Quality of Life Study" which the city performed kicking and screaming (Raymond, mostly). It was the cornerstone of a settlement between Last Stand and the city, in order for that organization to drop its challenge to the Base Reuse plan for the acquisition of Truman Waterfront. It suggested ways to minimize negative impacts, only... thanks to Raymond... the city never did anything with it. It's a little late for Raymond to come off now like he has public input at heart and wants to acheive a balance. For the past 20 years the city has paid him to do Ed Swift's bidding.

Wilbarger has been unimpressive so, hey, let's just give her

more money and responsibility!! That's the way Scholl thinks. Just look at the sham of an overpriced lease she 'negotiated' for the city's inane move to the flood zone on Flagler!

I'd like to see the city clean up the Key West Bight. It's an embarrassment! There is garbage overflowing at all times of day and night, the boards are rotting and dangerous in many places, there are derelict dinghy's tied everywhere, with no controls while the employees are chatting on the beat up old golf cart in front of Waterfront Market most all the time. THere's a very clear line between the City property and well maintained, privately owned A & B Marina, as well as the very clear line between the City property and well maintained, privately owned Conch Harbor. Scholl, THOSE are two properties that are run properly. Why can't the city do the same?

The city always claims they

The city always claims they need public input and then they do whatever the hell they want. There will be more Cruise Ships regardless of what residents of the area say. Truman Waterfront will be a continuation of the tourist tack at Mallory Square and NOT a park for local residents. That is why they are working so hard to open Admirals Cut. Who are these people kidding?
More Florida Keys Headlines
Thursday, February 9, 2012
Thursday, February 9, 2012
Wednesday, February 8, 2012
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Thursday, February 9, 2012 -
Wednesday, February 8, 2012 -
Wednesday, February 8, 2012 -
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 -
Monday, February 6, 2012 -
Sunday, February 5, 2012 -