Florida Keys News - Key West Citizen
Tuesday, April 20, 2010
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
DCA is in legislative limbo
Time running out for a reauthorization bill

The future of a state agency that oversees development regulations in the Florida Keys could remain in limbo for the next year.

The Florida Department of Community Affairs (DCA) is undergoing a sunset review process in the state Legislature -- a process required for each state agency every 10 years. The Legislature, this session, has three options for the agency's future: Continue it, abolish it or modify it.

What may have been the last chance this session to secure the agency's continued existence slipped away Friday when the House Economic Development and Community Affairs Policy Council chose not to act.

The DCA will remain intact in the short term without passage of a reenactment bill, but it's long-term future could be in limbo until next year's legislative session.

Not everyone has abandoned hope.

"We are disappointed that our reenactment bill was not heard by the House last week, but we are hopeful that they will reconsider their decision not to hear the bill and will re-enact this important and vital state agency," DCA spokesman James Miller said.

Charles Pattison, chairman of the environmental group 1000 Friends of Florida, said he has heard the DCA reauthorization may be a bargaining chip or a "negotiating point at the end of session," which ends in two weeks.

"The question is what are they trading it for and who is trading it," said Pattison, whose organization has sent e-mails to newspapers and lobbied legislators on the importance of maintaining the DCA.

The Senate already approved continued funding for the agency. The House's inaction comes a year after Rep. Dorothy Hukill, R-Port Orange, and other legislators filed two bills last year aimed at eliminating the agency. Both bills eventually died in committees.

Pattison is concerned the DCA will be more vulnerable next year, as there are no scheduled elections for House members, allowing them to avoid retribution from voters for eliminating DCA.

Pro-development forces see DCA as a roadblock for big construction projects and development. But in the past three years, the agency approved land use amendments that substantially increased development and development potential. DCA records indicate the agency approved 1,571 amendments that resulted in 483,000 new developments across the state, comprising 515,000 acres.

Developers and some elected officials also have argued that counties should have home rule, and the DCA should not have the authority to approve county comprehensive land use plans, which is a requirement for all counties. Nonetheless, DCA records indicate the agency approved nearly 90 percent of submitted comprehensive plan amendments.

The DCA also intervenes when counties approve developments or rules that violate their comprehensive plans or other land use rules. The agency overruled the Monroe County Commission two years ago after it approved changes that would have allowed construction of a large hotel, condominiums and marina on Stock Island that would have displaced historical waterfront commerce, such as commercial fishing. The controversial development was opposed by the Navy, environmental groups and commercial fishermen.

The DCA also intervened when the County Commission approved a plan for more homes near the Navy's runway on Boca Chica Key, an area subjected to loud jet noise and greater potential for crashes. The DCA sided with the Navy, and the plans were scrapped.

The DCA and other state agencies have greater authority in Monroe County than most other counties because the Keys are an Area of Critical State Concern and held to more strict building and development rules. The state limits the number of new residential construction permits that may be issued each year in Monroe County.

tohara@keysnews.com

Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

Flush the DCA, Time to Build NOW

Just more government control over our lives. If as a person living in this community you still want to blame the "gang of three" get a life. Put your self out there and make a difference get elected and do it better, but don't give up our community control to people who do not even live here. If the "County Government" would open up the building for home owners and business, repeal the illegal tier system that will eventually be dismantled after we residents pay out millions in lawsuits. they would find that we have a bigger tax base to fund the county and it's necessary programs. Time to stop letting big government control people who live here. Flush the useless DCA, repeal the illegal tier system, lets get back to the constitutional rights of people who OWN their land and Build baby Build!!!

God!!!!!! a Morovian with a brain

I didn't think they were any of us left.

Guess someone in Tallahassee got paid off

So the developers finally got to the powers-that-be in Tallahassee and persuaded them to eliminate DCA, the only protector of quality of life in the Keys. Let's hope there's a big hue and cry to save the DCA... they're the only ones who can save us from realtors and developers.

Too Stupid

Your argument for keeping the DCA is that we, the citizens of Monroe County, are TOO STUPID to take care of our own homes, lives, islands and destiny. WOW! I don’t know about you and your intelligence level (though your post points towards the lack thereof), but I assure you I, along with the vast majority of the County citizens, are perfectly capable of intelligent thought and balanced decisions. We do not need someone else, particularly big government from outside the County (who we did not vote into a position of authority), doing so for us!

Then why do you elect such

Then why do you elect such stupid people to represent you? If not for DCA, there would be high rises all up and down the keys.

DCA control negates Conch Republic Independence

How appropriate that you publish this article about the DCA, their “control” over the Keys, at the same time as you published the Conch Republic Independence Celebration article. Wilhelmina Harvey is probably rolling over in her grave (bless that wonderful woman!). A founding member of the Conch Republic movement, she fought the government over their intrusion into our lives. Yet here we now sit with the DCA not only intruding, but controlling our lives. It’s time for Monroe County to wake up! We are more than capable of controlling our own lives, homes, and islands. We do not need government doing it for us. The DCA does not “protect us” from big development, nor do we need them to do that for us; we are perfectly capable of doing that ourselves. Until the DCA is removed from its position of power, dictatorship and control over our lives, homes and Keys, we have nothing to celebrate as we are not independent.

You must be kidding me! You

You must be kidding me! You gave up your independence to Developers and outsiders long ago. Thank Goodness for DCA or the entire chain of Islands would look like Duck Key or be full of high rises. Wilhelmina Harvey would be disgusted by what Key West has become. Without DCA it would be 1000 times worse.

The DCA

The DCA is vital for our Keys! Thanks to the DCA the old "gang of three" were stopped on their tracks. They prevented developers from rapping our working water fronts in Stock Island. Is time for the community to start writing letters to their Senators and ask them to protect this vital government agency. Without the DCA the Keys will become another South Beach, and what we have fought so hard to keep, the charm and the uniqueness of our Keys will be thrown out in a pile of concrete. I don't know about you, but I want the DCA to regulate and keep an eye on our Board of County Commissioners, they can NOT be trusted!

At least South Beach

has an economy and folks working, soon the keys won't be able to support it's Gotminers and Tree huggers.
More Florida Keys Headlines
Monday, February 6, 2012
Monday, February 6, 2012
2 comments
Monday, February 6, 2012
1 comment
Sunday, February 5, 2012
4 comments
Sunday, February 5, 2012
Sunday, February 5, 2012
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Monday, February 6, 2012 -
Sunday, February 5, 2012 -
Friday, February 3, 2012 -
Thursday, February 2, 2012 -
Wednesday, February 1, 2012 -
Wednesday, February 1, 2012 -