Florida Keys News
Wednesday, August 4, 2010
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
Girl's hand mauled by barracuda

Nine-year-old Michelle Casasola plans to stay away from the water for a while after her right hand was mauled by a barracuda Sunday, her mother said.

The Poinciana Elementary School student and cheerleader underwent about seven hours of reconstructive surgery in Miami the day after the 3-foot fish bit her while she was snorkeling with her family near Rock Key, Jessica Segura said.

They were with Fury Water Adventures.

Segura said she didn't know how bad the injury was until she saw her daughter's blood in the water.

"There are dozens of stitches," she said. "I don't know how many, but it is a lot. Her hand looked like someone took a knife to her palm and back of her hand."

The barracuda probably was attracted to the many yellowtail snapper in the water, which in turn were attracted to bagels the Fury crew threw in as chum, Segura said.

Fury co-owner Scott Saunders denied that any crew members were chumming the waters.

"We're very sorry that this occurred, and we have never had an instance of this happening before," Saunders said. "The boat does have bagels and muffins on it for customers. Is it possible that customers were feeding fish with them? Of course that can happen, but as far as the crew doing it, that's absolutely not the case."

Segura hopes Michelle will regain full use of her hand, but the doctor said she won't be able to properly grasp or hold anything for at least six months and may need more surgery in a year.

Michelle was taken to Lower Keys Medical Center and then to Miami Children's Hospital, where a plastic surgeon hand specialist removed nerves from her arm and leg to reconstruct her hand, Segura said.

"I knew her hand was hurt, but didn't know how bad until the doctor in Key West said she needed to see someone who is an expert with hands," she said.

Michelle was doing well after surgery, but was upset that she can't join her fellow cheerleaders for months, Segura said. She enters fourth grade this school year.

"She says she doesn't want to talk about the fish or get in the water for a while," her mother said. "She's very upset that she can't cheer, but first we have to do physical therapy and that is going to be painful for her."

alinhardt@keysnews.com

Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

Fury water adventures

Fury water adventures have some interesting history. Its known that they Key west area is corrupt and laws are waived for certain companies. I wouldnt be too sure they have insurance. Google search fury with combinations, MICHAEL HALPERN GALEON HOTEL, scott saunders etc. I hope she makes a full recovery, its a shame laws arent obeyed on that part of the country.

Maybe the TDC should use

Maybe the TDC should use footage of this in a new add. Come on a snorkel trip to Key West and lose your hand!

Does Saunders expect anyone to believe...

... that all those fish just come and gather around his boat? For what reason, might I ask? They just happen to like him? And besides the fact that there are many very good reasons not to feed wildlife, in the water and on the land, I have to ask: BAGELS?????!!!!

Get Well Soon :-)

Get well soon Michelle . Everyone is praying for your full recovery and hope to see you out there cheering as soon as possible . Here's a Thousand hugs and kisses :-)

barracuda

I smell a million dollar lawsuit, I smell a quick settlement out of court, I smell barracudas, oops 'er lawyers circling the little girls door steps looking for some flash! It's time to feed.....................on Fury.

don't feed the fish!

I have worked on the waters of KW for 14 years and am a former captain for one of the big cat company's. FURY crew routinely bait the yellowtail snapper; saying otherwise is a blatant lie. Marine Conservation groups have tried repeatedly to get these companies to cease this practice citing the information below....maybe now they will stop..... Indeed, it is against the law for ANYthing to be thrown overboard within the Sanctuary per Federal MARPOL regulations and Sanctuary Regulations (- 15 CFR 922.163(a)(4) Discharge or deposit of materials or other matter. (i) Discharging or depositing, from within the boundary of the Sanctuary, any material or other matter, except: (A) Fish, fish parts, chumming materials, or bait used or produced incidental to and while conducting a traditional fishing activity in the Sanctuary) Additionally, in 2001, the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) unanimously voted to prohibit divers from feeding marine life in Florida. You might be wondering why the FWC believes these “interactive marine experiences” are harmful. After all, the fish get an easy meal, and divers get entertained, so what’s the problem? Overall, feeding marine fish is a bad idea for everyone, including divers, fish and the ecosystem. Contrary to popular belief, fish have memories and can learn. Through behavioral conditioning, fed animals learn to associate people with a meal. When this happens, fish anticipate the hand-feeding experience and depend on handouts from divers. Hand-feeding marine fish results in a variety of negative impacts. Most marine fish have around 10 essential amino acids required for growth and health maintenance. Fish cannot make these acids on their own, and they receive these building blocks from food. Fish generally consume a wide variety of prey in order to meet dietary requirements. To obtain the necessary nutrients, fish have complex feeding cycles. Seasonal, daily and other temporal feeding strategies make up a fish’s foraging behavior. Fish conditioned to take an easy meal from divers begin anticipating meals, which interrupts natural feeding cycles. A fish conditioned to feed on diver deliveries may actually stop normal foraging patterns and become malnourished, stressed and can even die. In addition to nutritional consequences, hand-fed fish are especially vulnerable to predators. In carnivorous fish, sensations associated with feeding can override other associations, including predator avoidance and protection. Competition for the handout interferes with natural instincts and behaviors, which are essential for survival and cohabitation with other species. Hand-feeding-induced attacks on humans do occur. Feeding wildlife can place people in harm’s way.

Poor Kid

I cannot believe Scott Saunders lied like that. I am a citizen of Key West and have been on The Fury snorkeling trip. The crew chummed the water to make more fish appear. I thought it was a little odd at the time, knowing there are large fish which can bite out there, but didn't say anything, thinking they knew the waters and knew what they were doing. I can't believe they are not taking responsibility for chumming the water. I hope there is a complete investigation.

They do throw bagels into

They do throw bagels into the water to attract fish. I did a Fury adventure in November 2009 and Capt Chuck was the one tossing in the food while we were anchored near the reef. Quite an impressive school of yellowtail was sustained, while a single barracuda swam amongst them, myself and the other snorkelers. Capt Chuck indicated he is one of the Fury owners.

Saw this in TV, the damage was

extensive, cutting 2 arterys and tendons, a 6 hour operation to put her hand back together. SCOTT SUANDERS, you were not there,in the interview the little girl clearly states THE CREW WAS FEEDING THE FISH. A bagel was dropped in the water beside her and she was bit. Scott ,you are just trying to deny responsibility to avoid a law suit. Pony up, pay the expenses; try not acting like the lawyer you are. Your company has insurance, use it. BTW, we have seen your unscrupalous business tatics over the years. it is ruled by greed. You paid outragous booking fees to put the other glass bottom boat out of business, even paying booth rents to not book competing boats. You won't be happy until you are the only excursion out there. Greed and its results will not make you happy, just smug.

You called it.

I hope that some local attorney will contact this girl's parents and encourage them to file suit. This little girl has suffered greatly because the Fury wanted to put on a show. Now they should pay her. It's the same as the greedy scooter rental companies which are allowed by the City to do business even though they have ZERO insurance (no one will sell it to them at any price 'cause it's too dangerous). They don't care one iota if a college girl scrapes half her leg off in a spill. And if someone dies on one of their scooters, their only concern is charging the credit card for the scooter before the parents find out. All of the entertainment rental companies in this town rely on the fact that out-of-towners are unlikely to return to take them to court. It's time someone did. Also, the hotels should warn guests of these dangers. The hotels themselves could be responsible if they booked the trip.

Two comments on your post.

It's against the law for lawyers to contact potential clients. Think ambulance chasers. Also, the city could close down most scooter rental companys because they lack private property to conduct the required test drive. I have personally seen people side sweep cars in the 900 block of Center street while the rental agent just stands there adding scooter damage in his head, ready to add it to the credit card. There is a city law that reqiures the test drive be on PRIVATE property.

I'm sure they have insurance. Any operator is required to have

insurance by the place where they dock, by anyone who books them, and the people that book are required to be shown as an additional insured. I worked for a local water-based business and handled that part of it, once upon a time. They are not required by the city to have insurance, but why would the city require it? I mean really, the only people who REQUIRE insurance are those who can be sued. The City can't be sued and so they won't require insurance of water-based businesses. But if these businesses want bookings, they have to be insured or booking agents or concierges won't book them. It's a hard and fast rule. So you might want to check up on your facts before you post.

As for scooter rental companies, they are insured properly I'm sure, for liability issues. However they do not insure renters any more than rental car companies insure those who rent their cars. Scooter rental companies are not required to provide insurance for a bunch of idiots who think that scooters are toys.

I personally have seen kids for over 15 years who rented scooters, who were clearly doing things that they were told not to do. I've seen them slam into mangroves off Atlantic because they were busy talking on their cell phones instead of driving. I had one a few years ago, jump a curb, almost take off my leg and I was 8 feet from the street, on a sidewalk because he was trying to drive with his FEET on the handlebars! He fell, was scraped, stank of beer, and I told him "You broke that scooter. You're going to have to pay and I'm a witness that you were behaving illegally" and he said "They'll never know" and I pulled out my cell phone and called the number on the scooter basket "They'll know now". You can't call scooter rental companies crooks when people treat their equipment like toys and bring it back broken into pieces because they feel it's a toy. And don't get me started on scooter renters going wrong way on one-way streets, and they feel it's ok since it's not a 'real car'.

Yes and No.

Yes, the City does require all companies to have liability insurance before granting a C.O. to do business. All except scooter rental operations. They have NO liability insurance. As I said, no insurance company will write that business. How, then, are they in business? You'll have to ask the City of Key West and the City Manager that. They have renters sign a disclaimer upon rental, so they're not liable. Helluva money-making business, I'd say... plenty of rentals, no liability. Yes, you're right about the "private property" issue. Why, again, are they allowed to operate? Again, ask the City of Key West and the City Manager. Truth is, someone IS liable for scooter accidents-- the City of Key West. Sooner or later, they (we) will pay. Now, back to FURY and the little girl... Yes, they're required to and do have insurance, as required by hotels and concierges. But that doesn't render the booking agent completely unliable... if they are aware of dangerous practices on the part of the operator when they book. There's nothing to prevent a claimant from naming the hotel or concierge in their suit.

I thought Scott was an accountant, not a lawyer?

I wasn't aware they paid such high commissions. I was once in the booking business and I never saw high commissions from Fury, that's for sure. I booked Sunny Days mostly. And I never booked the other main snorkeling cat competitor here (Sebago) because they never seem to get around to PAYING their commission for our work. Big surprise there.

Give me a break! I've been

Give me a break! I've been on Fury boats several times and seen the crew feeding the fish. It is illegal in the sanctuaries! Now will you stop??? I feel sorry for the little girl and wish her a quick return to cheerleading! Maybe someone should drop the dye packs in Fury's heads again to see if they are still "pumping out" while at the reef...

Lucky it wasn't a shark.

These greedy head boats pour so many cruise ship passengers into the water it's a wonder more aren't eaten whole. Do they chum the water to attract fish for a show? Of course they do. Just as they take a boat full of passengers out to the sensitive reefs-- even if it's pouring down rain. Just another example of the greed that rules in this town.

Rain? OH, like they aren't going to get wet when snorkeling?

It IS a snorkel boat, after all. I always laughed at people who were going diving, who were put off by a bit of drizzle, when they were going to be underwater for 45 minutes in a very short time. Silly, silly thinking.

As for cruise ship passengers, the majority of the boats in town do not handle cruise ship passengers. The dive boats do not because the cruise ship's schedules don't work with the dive boat's schedules and the cruise ships don't guarantee head count and payment in advance. Not sure about the snorkel boats. I assume it's mostly Fury doing cruise ship pax.

The Fury lives off the

The Fury lives off the cattle boat tours from Cruise Ships. Cruise Ship support almost every obnoxious business here. Where do you think the 50 jet skiers come from? The only ones who do not benefit are Scuba and Fishing guides since the boats rarely stay long enough. Cruise Ships have really had a terrible impact on this town since we do not limit them to one per day.

Fury has the cruise ship contracts

the cruise ship passengers get a narrow selection of available vendors. As for paying huge commissions, it is true.Once they decide they want your boat out the competition, they will pay outragous commissions. 50% was paid to book Pride of Key West glass bottom boat after it was purchased by Fury. The goal was to put Discovery glass bottom boat out business. Booth fees were paid NOT to book Discovery.After Discovery finally sucumbed to this unfair practice the commissions went back down. Sebago and Sunny Days is Furys next target,Nothing would make Scott and Mike happier than Pablo going under.So Fury puts spring break girls on free, gives outragous discounts, and tries to make up for it in volume.Dumping 120 snorklers in the water at a time on some trips.

This would make a great

This would make a great article in The Citizen assuming you are right. Are you reading this Mandy Miles? Are you reading the Mr. Editor? Investigative journalism... Remember that class in school? This should be a feature article about unfair competition. The Fury Sucks.

If they were chumming it

If they were chumming it would be just another example of the entitled locals doing whatever they feel like doing.
More Florida Keys Headlines
Tuesday, February 7, 2012
3 comments
Tuesday, February 7, 2012
3 comments
Tuesday, February 7, 2012
Tuesday, February 7, 2012
3 comments
Monday, February 6, 2012
3 comments
Monday, February 6, 2012
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Tuesday, February 7, 2012 -
Monday, February 6, 2012 -
Sunday, February 5, 2012 -
Friday, February 3, 2012 -
Thursday, February 2, 2012 -
Wednesday, February 1, 2012 -