Florida Keys News - Key West Citizen
Thursday, October 6, 2011
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
School, union table talks

With 10 grievances and two unfair labor practices complaints from the teachers union pending against the Monroe County School District, both sides decided Wednesday to postpone another sit-down at the bargaining table and consider a settlement that would avoid a lengthy legal battle.

All argument over the teachers' contract remains on hold while the United Teachers of Monroe leaders decide whether to press forward with complaints to the state's Public Employees Relations Commission (PERC) or simply let that agency render an opinion without holding a hearing.

The threshold issue is whether the School Board was correct in reducing the 2011-12 fiscal year budget without first returning to the bargaining table for further negotiations.

"We had a good discussion today," Schools Superintendent Jesus Jara said. "They have a decision to make. They are supposed to huddle up and come back to us with a decision on what the next steps are."

No new date was scheduled for a negotiating session, which initially was set for 11 a.m. Wednesday, then pushed back to 3 p.m., then canceled altogether.

Instead, the negotiation teams from the School District and the union met privately to discuss possibly hammering out an agreement without having to take a lengthy and expensive legal route, union President Holly Hummell-Gorman said.

"It was a closed session so that we could discuss settlement options for grievances," she said. "We are exploring whether we will submit it to PERC for their ruling. I just sent out a notice to our membership hoping that they feel like this is a positive move and it's hopefully going to expedite and save the taxpayers money as far as legal fees."

The sides met for about two hours Wednesday, said Jara, who attended the meeting with Chief Financial Officer Michael Kinneer, Human Resources Director Cheryl Allen and attorney Robert Norton, a veteran labor lawyer hired specifically for the union negotiations.

On the union's side were Hummell-Gorman, chief negotiator Leon Fowler and two representatives from the Florida Education Association.

"We're just trying to get a finalizing resolution before we continue to bargain," Jara said. "They have a decision to make. We're making progress. Anything is possible."

At issue for the union is Jara's decision in July to mandate seven furlough days for teachers -- instead of the three unpaid days the union agreed to earlier this year -- and freeze raises and "performance pay" to balance the 2012 fiscal year budget, which endured some $10 million in cuts before the School Board approved it last month.

gfilosa@keysnews.com

Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

The teachers union's national component has been...

...showing up to the suppoprt the other idiots protesting against capitalism in New York. The Teachers union is good at staging fake protests to suppport their causes. Too bad the day to day teacher is being fooled by them. Current rumored speculation is this whole Monroe County School district fight is being staged possibly by Fowler/Hummel and the union against Jara to portray him as not doing a good job. Current rumored suspicion is the union is big time behind the corrupt school bubba gang to possibly get Little Mikey in the drivers seat in 2012 when the Superintendent seat comes up for filling. That seat is still very profitable for barrowing huge amounts of money and the power to raise taxes. Bubba dont play like that!

I think you're muddling the waters with this comment.

I think you're muddling the waters with this comment. BLESS the people on Wall Street. They're not protesting against capitalism. They're protesting against corruption which has descimated our economy. As for the teachers' union, they're part and parcel of the corruption. They were hand-in-glove with Acevedo and now that their cozy relationship with the crooks is terminated, they're playing these closed-door games.

Bless the people on Wall street???? LMAO

Come on your as ignorant as they are. They look like they suffered so bad. The avergae poor person in the USA is worried about getting a 56" High def Plasma over the 48" one they have now. The current economic catastrophe can factually be shown to be a result of Obama and his Socialist revolution. The idiots on Wall street and the other fools accross the country have been linked with move-on.org and George Soros. Or is the koola aide really getting to you now? I enjoyed the Wall street photo's of all the drug activity and open sex in the sewers and the guy taking a crap on tax payer purchased property; the NYPD car. Your comment is very foolish!

Union Bashing

I read these comments and it is very much like many news articles around here. No one bothers to get the facts. I am not a union member, but I have followed this whole situation pretty closely. First, if you are union bashing because you are unhappy with your present employment. Maybe you should try to Unionize. Unions in the US are being trampled for successfully raising the pay, benefits and stability of our middle class workforce. They have helped make this country what it is. So, now it is convenient to kick them around like a political football. Wake up America, your freedom is under attack here. As for the teachers Union. They did not storm out of negotiations if you have really followed this. The Union has pretty much led the charge to resolve budget issues. They agreed to open segments of a legally binding contract that was negotiated...by JARA, presented to the board and Ratified. The district spin Doctors will shape this as some sort of error or sneaky practice by the union. Where in the heck is the accountability by the board for THEIR decision. If you don't understand the numbers you are voting on with my tax dollars...the board needs to do more work. And, to recommend and accept the district employee responsible for this contract as the new superintendant...are you kidding me? The Union at one point terminated negotiations...and why not. They have been stonewalled by an attorney, the district does not appear to be forthcoming with the supporting data on where they are getting there figures for cuts...and the district has trash canned a legally binding contract that they ratified and put in effect. And John Dick, in a school board meeting would say...well the Union hasn't brought anything...and the Union walked out. They have brought solutions where they were not required to by law and have been kicked in the teeth. It is not their job Mr. Dick, it's now on the district, to bring options to a negotiating table. In the meantime, failure to do so has slammed an already difficult budget with costs and legal fees that should be going back into the classroom. That is why I voted for the half mil referendum. Not so you guys can run wild with district funds so you can hide from your own mistakes. The Union seems to be the only party bring viable, negotiated solutions to the table. The district seems to have no accountability or responsibility to the legal document they approved and has made off hand changes without even providing proof of the necessity...without following the agreed upon procedures to make these changes. Isn't that why we need Unions?

"You should unionize................"

You had me up to Unionize. Afer that I fell asleep trying to read your mishmash of caca de torro! You should go read a book or better yet don't post! You really don't have anything to say except you believe only one side of this issue, the left side. And your obsession with DICK. You need a therapist to get over that. You really wrote for ever and had nothing to say. Oh and I was there the Union walked out.

So, exactly how much are your dues?

I'd be interested to know. If you're truly a MEMBER of the union and a teacher, then you should be able to provide t his information. This comment sounds like something that Mr. Fowler might be writing. And Mr. Dick is the best thing we have going for the people of Monroe County.

And no. I own my own business so I'm far from unhappy with my present employment. AND you might like to know I'm a liberal. However, I'm very much against waste, greed, fiscal irresponsibility and stupidity and that's what the unions have brought to the table for the cops and the fire department, and it appears the school union is no different. For the life of me, I can't figure why these union members feel THEY deserve raises on the taxpayers backs when the taxpayers have taken cuts. And why exactly do they feel that it's ok to spend more money than there is?

Makes you wonder

Did you ever wonder why the union never complained about the corruption? All they did was try to block the investigation by claiming it was too costly. Makes you wonder doesn't it? Now they complain about everything. Makes you wonder why? Inquiring minds would like to know

Indeed. What people don't understand is the money that the

union rakes in. They're not a philanthropic group. They didn't complain about corruption because they were receiving benefits from the corrupt thieves in the school administration. Unions are 'for profit' businesses. I wonder how much the union is making in dues, to push through these initiatives? I wonder if all members were no longer paying dues, if the difference would be the amount that the union is bargaining for for them. I wonder how much the legal fees would be for this law suit they're planning to file?

All we have to do is look at the mess unions have made of our city budget, with their demands for benefit, retirement and pay increases for the police and fire department, while the taxpayers who pay their salaries are making less money than before. Exactly how is that the right thing to do? Unions have now outlived their usefulness in society.

Imagine this they actually met

Well at least the union didn't walk out this time --- wait they keep telling everyone they didn't walk out from the previous meetings. Maybe what they meant to say was that they stumbled out of those meetings! Didn't Leon retire? Is he a paid consultant now?

Fowler is a crook. He's double dipping and I really wonder if

the teachers have a clue as to how they're being used.

Again?

Didn't the last "closed door" session give Leon Fowler $40k in retirement, and an illegal performance pay contract without performance pay that cost the taxpayers half a million dollars? I would prefer the doors stay open instead of filling JarJar and Union President pockets again.

Call me crazy but I thought that all of these negotiations had

to be in the 'sunshine'? They're still doing the smoky-back-room deals.
More Florida Keys Headlines
Tuesday, May 21, 2013
3 comments
Monday, May 20, 2013
9 comments
Monday, May 20, 2013
Monday, May 20, 2013
3 comments
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Sunday, May 19, 2013 -
Saturday, May 18, 2013 -
Friday, May 17, 2013 -
Thursday, May 16, 2013 -