Florida Keys News - Key West Citizen
Saturday, March 3, 2012
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
Ferro trial to begin Monday
Effort to change venue rejected

Jury selection is scheduled to begin Monday in the murder trial of a man accused of fatally stabbing Marques Butler of Key West in a 4 a.m. fight during Fantasy Fest 2009.

Defense attorneys for Nicholas Ferro sought to move the second-degree murder trial out of Key West, but circuit Judge David Audlin denied the change of venue motion on Monday. Defense attorney Ed O'Donnell of Miami said the issue could come up again during jury selection Monday.

Defense co-counsel Carlos Gonzalez had argued in the motion that angry locals and biased media coverage of Butler's death would make it impossible for Ferro to get a fair trial in Key West.

Defense attorneys previously attempted to have the murder charge dropped altogether, citing Florida's Stand Your Ground law, which legalizes lethal force if a victim feels his or her life is in danger, but Audlin and the 3rd District Court of Appeal both rejected that motion.

Barring any last-minute developments, attorneys and Audlin should begin interviewing potential jurors Monday at the Freeman Justice Center. The trial follows more than two years of legal maneuvering by defense attorneys, who have depicted Ferro as a victim in a fight between two groups of people.

Ferro's attorneys have stated in multiple motions that he was coming to the defense of a friend who was being pummeled by an angry mob, and that evidence suggests Ferro was only defending himself when he pulled out a small knife.

Prosecutors, too, say there was a fight between two groups of youth, but they allege Ferro was the aggressor rather than the victim.

Miami-Dade Assistant State Attorney's Breezye Telfair and Miesha Shonta Darrough were appointed by former Gov. Charlie Crist to prosecute the case because of a potential conflict of interest with the Monroe County State Attorney's Office. Three employees in the Monroe County office either knew Butler or know witnesses in the case.

Miami-Dade State Attorney's Office spokesman Ed Griffith said prosecutors were in Key West preparing for the trial, but declined to comment further.

O'Donnell said he expects the trial to take at least two weeks.

"I think everyone is expecting jury selection alone to take a few days," he said.

Ferro, 25, of Hollywood, is being held without bail in the Monroe County Detention Center on Stock Island.

alinhardt@keysnews.com

Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

Olivia and Petronia Street

I say if he can run once down Oliva Street and once down Petronia Street without loosing his breath he should be let go.

The Appeal for this has been written

already and waiting only for the verdict. He will be found guilty in Key West and his Lawyers will get him a new trial in Miami because of the refusal of a change in venue. Honestly, if you lived here would you find him Not Guilty.

I would if he were.

There is evidence that must be looked at. There are witness accounts that must be heard. Everyone seems to have a different account on what happened. The man Butler was first written up to be a model citizen and then other facts were brought to light. The "visitors" were saupposedly in defense mode against a group of angry local men, the suspect went out with a knife on him>..one wants to know why. Was the victim walking away as stated and rushed after a racial slur was shouted and then stabbed by the person yelling the racial slur, or was that a lie? So no, I would not automatically convict the suspect without knowing all the evidence.

I applaud your stand

but I believe you are in the minority. Even if the jury does have only honest people like you, and he is found guilty due to the evidence, there will still be an appeal that he will win because of all the publicity favoring Mr. Butler in Key West.

Wow - this is unusual

Since when do we try our cases in the courtroom? I thought all Monroe County cases were tried in the press. No details about the evidence from the prosecutor's office? Not sure I like how this is going.

It would be worth doing a

It would be worth doing a stretch to avoid being on that jury.
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Sunday, May 26, 2013 -
Saturday, May 25, 2013 -
Friday, May 24, 2013 -
Thursday, May 23, 2013 -
Wednesday, May 22, 2013 -