Florida Keys News - Key West Citizen
Wednesday, July 18, 2012
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
Cyclist sues Conch Train over injury

A California woman who was hit by a Conch Tour Train while bicycling in Old Town last year is suing, claiming she faces substantial medical costs due to the injuries she suffered in the accident, according to a civil lawsuit filed last week.

The accident occurred in September as Hilary Cline was bicycling on Whitehead Street in front of the Old Town post office between Fleming and Eaton streets, said her attorney, William Wolk of Miami.

The lawsuit states Cline was riding in the center of the northbound lane just north of Fleming Street when she was struck by the fourth trailer on the train, which threw her from her bicycle causing a "complete superior labral tear in her left shoulder, which will require extensive reconstructive surgery."

A superior labral tear is an injury to cartilage that covers the upper area of the shoulder socket.

The lawsuit alleges that the Conch Tour Train driver was negligent and failed to take due care in avoiding Cline.

"The train just got too close and didn't give her enough room," Wolk said. "Unfortunately we see a lot of this in Miami, and I know everyone in Key West bikes. It's a situation where motorists get impatient and the bicyclists take up the road."

Cline is not alleging that the Conch Tour Train hit her intentionally, Wolk said.

"There is no allegation here other than the driver made a mistake," Wolk said. "We're not alleging malice. We do, however, need to get her medical bills covered. Like so many people, she does not have medical insurance and the bills are mounting."

The Conch Tour Train is owned and operated by the Historic Tours of America. Company officials told The Citizen they do not comment on pending litigation.

Chief circuit Judge David Audlin is scheduled to preside over the case. No trial date had been scheduled as of Friday.

alinhardt@keysnews.com

Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

It's hard to know who to blame here. Bicyclists are out of

It's hard to know who to blame here. Bicyclists are out of control and don't obey traffic laws. They forget an important rule - the tonage rule. And the train and trolley drivers often take two lanes to do their jobs. In this case, I'm betting two wrongs made a mess.

It will keep piling up as

It will keep piling up as the duck ass tour comes to fruition. Of course they wont comment because I am sure they will pay her off for pennies.

In the middle of the road

If she was in the middle of the road how did she not have enough room to move over to avoid being hit?

Really???

Did you really just in some way put the blame on the victim?

Quackers

Over/Under on the first person to be struck by one the new ducks = 10 months.

Just wait for The Ducks! Go

Just wait for The Ducks! Go drive over and look at these monsters. They sit so high you can not see a bike or pedestrian in front of you. Get out your money people, Swifty will collect all the money and leave the city to pay for the law suits. The city has the responsibility to provide for public safety, not to enrich swift. Have the duck tours on the 4 lane roads in new town and "splash down" at the key haven boat ramp. How about it Ed? You will not mind 50 people with noisemakers and amplified tour information in your neighborhood, will you?

Trial Presided Over by the Same David Audlin ................

.............. who was hired by the city of Key West to represent the position that the city could lawfully grant Ed Swift and his Conch Tour Train an unlawful monopoly???

What did that cost the taxpayers again? .... $14,000,000.00 + ?

Perhaps someone should suggest to attorney William Wolk of Miami that a recusal motion might be in his client's better intrest

More Florida Keys Headlines
Wednesday, June 19, 2013
1 comment
Wednesday, June 19, 2013
Wednesday, June 19, 2013
Wednesday, June 19, 2013
1 comment
Available Only in the Electronic Edition