Florida Keys News - Key West Citizen
Sunday, July 22, 2012
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
School Board billed $6,600 for 10-day job

The Florida School Boards Association has billed the Monroe County School Board $6,600 for 10 days' work on the superintendent search -- including two days' travel expenses. Had the board hired the agency's head, Wayne Blanton, for the entire monthlong search, the bill would have been capped at $8,000.

The nonprofit association, to which the School Board hasn't belonged since 2009, also has offered membership to Monroe County for $15,000. But three of the five local board members said Friday they would vote against joining.

The board is set to meet at 10 a.m. Monday in Key West at the administration building, 241 Trumbo Road.

The single-page bill, dated June 20, isn't itemized, and board members said that's all they've seen.

The invoice has a four-line abbreviated description of services rendered: "Superintendent search; recruitment of candidates; PH calls, review of resumes, discussion with citizens committee, assist with ad placement, 10 days @ $500 each. Travel cost -- 2 days plus mileage."

Let the sticker shock begin.

"They are really hitting us with a big bill for the superintendent search," said Chairman John Dick, who was never a fan of the agency. "I'm not happy. I would suspect we're stuck with it. That's good enough reason to show we really shouldn't belong to this organization."

Dick said the board could spend $15,000 on school supplies instead.

But Vice Chairman Andy Griffiths, a 20-year incumbent up for re-election this year, has argued to his colleagues that the nonprofit provides training, legal services, guidance and consultation.

He also pointed out that of Florida's 67 school districts, only Monroe and Nassau don't belong.

Griffiths brought in Blanton to get the superintendent search off the ground.

On the campaign trail Thursday, Griffiths said the district wouldn't have an incoming superintendent if he hadn't taken the lead.

At least one board member has some questions about the invoice, saying he has yet to see any receipts.

"We've got to talk about it," said Ron Martin, who represents the Upper Keys. "I was going to bring it up for discussion."

Monroe's a la carte plan cost $5,000.

Blanton racked up $1,605.20 for two days' travel from Tallahassee to the remote Florida Keys, according to the invoice.

"Show me the 10 days," said Robin Smith-Martin, who represents Key West.

The travel expenses sound about right, though, he said: "I can believe that."

Blanton visited the Keys in February for a board meeting and again in April, when he met with the board-appointed citizen search committee, which reviewed the original batch of 56 applicants and delivered to the board a shortlist of five finalists, including appointed, and now outgoing, Superintendent Jesus Jara.

The board selected Mark Porter of Minnesota by a 4-1 vote on June 28.

Blanton did not return a phone message left at his office, nor an email.

But in April, before the board cut him loose, Blanton said the agency makes no profit from the superintendent searches and that the School Board didn't owe dues in exchange for his help.

"They are under no obligation to join," he said then.

With little comment, the board in late April voted 4-0 to fire Blanton, deciding it had only needed him to kick-start the search.

Blanton by then had billed the district about $1,800, having promised not to charge more than the blanket fee of $8,000.

He has 37 years in the education field and 76 superintendent searches on his resume. The agency charges $500 a day plus travel expenses, such as mileage and hotel rooms, but caps its total bill at $8,000 for overseeing school district superintendent searches.

However, the agency typically only works for school districts that are dues-paying members. Blanton appeared to have made an exception for Monroe County after Griffiths reached out to him for help launching the national search for the Keys first hired schools chief.

Charlotte County recently paid $4,500 for a complete search, while Palm Beach County was billed $7,400, Blanton told the board in February.

In July 2009, Dick led a 3-2 vote to quit the school boards association and the state superintendent's association in order to save about $26,000 in annual dues.

"I didn't think it was worthwhile," said Dick of the association. "I didn't think they did anything."

gfilosa@keysnews.com

Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

who went?

Just check the board agenda from May 22nd. District approved travel.pages 9 & 10. But in all fairness, the $42,000 was all paid for with a grant. But on the other hand, 6 grand a month to a consulting firm that specializes in solutions for companies affected by rhe current financial crisis; that's a good one. Just a quick glance over the recent check registers shows $24,000 paid over the past 5 months to this company. That's a good one; we don't have any money, so let's give away more of what we don't have. Oh yeah, this company, if the right one, is supposed to be based in London, England and boasts a total workforce of 10 people according to their website. I believe there was also a substantial payment made to another company that lists it's home office on an island off the northern coast of France in the English Channel.

The List

How can I see the list of who went to Orlando? I am interested

Go to May 22nd school board agenda

I noticed slight corrections, it was 42,000.00 and at the JW Marriott - this all went before the board with ALL names listed and price tag- no one batted an eye. As I said this is an annual trip with the same administrators each year. Axford, Bosco, Henriquez, etc.....

Seriously 6 thousand?

I can't believe this is news, when the same district just sent a huge group (including Jara and Axford) just this month, to stay at the Ritz in Orlando, costing 50,000.00- but wait there is more, this is the THIRD year in a row! Check out that list of people and it would. E a heck of an eye opener! 150,000.00 over 3 years with most of the same people!

REALLY? How about some perspective...

Superintendent Porter has a contract that will pay him between $450-$500K over the next three years. The School Board hired a professional consultant to narrow the field from 56 applicants, many of whom would have appeared qualified at first blush.

The consultant recommended five finalists, one of whom was the current superintendent (of course). One of the other four was Mark Porter, whom we now welcome to run our schools. It would appear as though the consultant performed a beneficial service.

I commend the board for recognizing that they do not have the same experience in this field as the consultant, who has performed this service 76 times previously. Pay the bill and move on. The School Board was fortunate to find a seasoned professional who presented them with a qualified applicant. That was his assignment.

Stop shouting like a bunch of Tea Party lunatics, before Porter changes his mind. Shame on The Citizen for stirring up the invective. 25% of the bill was for travel - unavoidable. Consultants more typically charge $500 for an hour, not a day. If the county ever wants to hire professionals in the future, it's time we start behaving like civilized human beings.

Agreed

I completely agree. I do not think the bill is unacceptab;e for the service provided. If you need a head hunter, you hire one. That's what we did.

No receipts is normal in Monroe County

No receipts is normal in Monroe County look how long the former Vocational administrator took to provide any or did he ever before being let go? Dick is right on this again.

Sickening

Thanks Andy for getting help for us.

Why can't MCSB do their own job for once instead of farming

it out to private companies when our teachers don't even have enough paper to print up their tests? Why don't their advertise in all the major Sunday papers across the the country and in the educational trade magazines. The board is too lazy to do their job but not too lazy to spend our the school district's money at the expense of it's students!

Add this to the list

Here's another reason NOT to vote for Andy this time. Keep 'em coming.

Exactly why Andy needs to go

Just like every other ineffective career politician, Griffiths takes credit for everything and responsibility for nothing. I remember all the times at Rotary where Andy boasted about recruiting Joe Burke and painted himself as some kind of power broker in Tallahassee. Griffiths must have forgotten about FKCC and the City of Key West using selection committees but now he wants to take credit for coming up with the idea. Watch as he tries to distance himself from this huge waste of taxpayer's money. He is so out of touch with reality. The school board sorely needs a change.
More Florida Keys Headlines
Saturday, May 25, 2013
Saturday, May 25, 2013
Saturday, May 25, 2013
Saturday, May 25, 2013
5 comments
Friday, May 24, 2013
3 comments
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Saturday, May 25, 2013 -
Friday, May 24, 2013 -
Thursday, May 23, 2013 -
Wednesday, May 22, 2013 -