Florida Keys News
Saturday, October 6, 2012
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
Life raft law creates cost concerns
New federal regulation intended to address hypothermia

Fishermen, charter boat owners and others making a living in Keys waters are holding their collective breath while figuring out how to meet new federal safety requirements mandated for vessels that operate more than three miles beyond shore.

The Coast Guard Reauthorization Act of 2010 requires -- among other things -- that the compact life buoys and net-bottomed floats used for emergencies by passengers be replaced by inflatable rafts or other approved inflatable equipment.

While the law does not take effect until 2015, companies, individual boat owners and safety officials are already gearing up.

Lt. Rafael Arizmendi of Coast Guard Sector Miami already has met with commercial fishermen on Stock Island to inform them of the new law and explain how it affects them. A more immediate change, he said, is the requirement that all commercial vessels venturing beyond three miles display a sticker verifying that they have undergone a Coast Guard safety check.

"The life raft requirement will be effective Oct. 1, 2015, so for now anybody who uses a life float can go up to 20 miles out, but change is coming," Arizmendi said. "When the new law takes effect you must have life-saving equipment that will keep a person 100 percent dry."

The intent of the raft law, according to congressional documents, is to ensure that passengers needing to use a raft in an emergency are kept dry to prevent hypothermia, or loss of body heat.

Local boat operators say there is not much of a potential for trouble with that here in the Keys, especially since help is often close by if an emergency occurs.

But some data suggests hypothermia can be a problem even here.

The U.S. Navy Diving Manual says a water temperature of 91 degrees Fahrenheit is required to "keep an unprotected, resting man at stable temperature. ... The unprotected diver will be affected by excessive heat loss and become chilled within a short period of time in water temperatures below 72 F."

Scott Saunders, president of Fury Water Adventures Inc., said the change will cost thousands of dollars for each of his company's vessels, which include catamarans and glass-bottomed boats.

"The regulatory environment right now across the board has become a lot to deal with," Saunders said, noting that his company and others had to have their boats re-certified last year due to new regulations that otherwise would cut down on the number of people permitted to travel on an excursion boat. The change was due to the increased weight of the American public. "We feel the regulatory environment is very strict right now, maybe rightfully so. And for us it's safety first and everything else second."

Commercial fisherman Lee Starling, who travels routinely beyond three miles in his small boat, questions how he will carry the equipment, especially considering other changes that have added gear.

"I am not sure what type of life raft they want us to get," Starling said. "I have got so many different agencies saying I have to carry certain types of equipment, I am running out of room to carry fish. ... I just spent $800 on a raft which is perfectly serviceable, Coast Guard recommended, a newer raft with a Duracoat lining, but every couple of years they change everything and you have to buy something new."

Leslie Levis, manager of the Ann Street dive shop Captain's Corner, said the new law will cause added expense for her company's vessel, the Sea Eagle.

"It will be expensive," Levis said. "The others you have to replace every couple of years anyway, every two years it has to be approved and you have a safety inspection every year. Ours cost about $1,200 each depending on the sizes. I am guessing the new one will cost more than $3,000. It will be a financial hardship."

Knowing the law doesn't take effect until 2015, Levis said, was some comfort.

"That will give me a couple of years," she said. "Maybe the economy will turn around by then."

jdesantis@keysnews.com

Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

Here is your reason....

If you didn't know how much you need to vote, here is another fine example of government regulation intruding into our lives to only make it harder to stay in business! Vote!! Vote for those who will work on REDUCING the draconian size of government! Amazing how we made it 235 years without this monstrous monkey on our backs!

Lack of common sense approach?

It's not just the expense; these rafts can range from $3600 for a 6 person raft to $6000 for a 10 person raft. They will also require a special cradle with a hydrostatic release. This will be several hundred more. And the expense is not the only issue; the size is too. For many of the commercial inspected passenger boats that go to the reef, this mean as many as 4 to 10 of these canisters on deck. They weight as much as 200-250 lbs each and are as large as 2'x2'x5'. So this added weight will change the Stability letter, conceivably reducing the number of passengers allowed, as well as space required for the storage of these devices. They will have to be mounted on prime deck space so they can be easily and readily deployed. And the yearly inspection and service will be thousands too. Looks like most of us will be sailing close to shore with the jet skis! Safety is everyone's first priority in the business, but is this really the most practical and common sense approach? Just about every commercial operator here in Key West operates within a 7 to 8 mile distance from the harbor. And they all carry a satelite EPIRB and radio that automatically notifies search and rescue within seconds. Is this really necessary? Another example of over regulation vs. common sense.

The way I see it, as Leslie says, a new one will cost around

$3,000 so, how difficult will it be? They have three years before this comes into effect so it's $1,000 per year. If they just put back $83 per month, they're there by 2015. I support the local boating community but they are very big whiners.

Only 3 grand ?

Let's see , 3 grand for a raft, / 3500 for VMS and a $43 a month monitoring fee / $400 for flares / $1000 for an epirp / throw ring $80 / $64 for jackets/ assorted updated publications for navigation and charts / medical kit/ the list goes on with required equipment. Suprisingly I'm not required to have a compass but am required to have a compass deviation chart displayed along with a mammal / turtle interaction procedures . The Compass guys must not have a lobbiest. The list goes on and on and a MSO inspection can take hours. If your rec boat had to have all this you couldn't afford to go boating. So add it all up and I need to put about $250 a month away for "safety" gear. Or think of it in lobsters ; thats 60 lbs of lobsters before fuel or any expenses, such as crew, trap fees, lisc, dockage,insurance, or maintaining my vessel. As far 3 years, it is the end of 2012, so basicly I have a year and a half , so double your $83 a month provided you have all the other gear covered. Speaking of Whining, remember this post next time you whine about the cost of retail seafood, now you know why it costs so much; to pay for rafts and flares.

I worked in a marine business for 7 years from the mid 90's

I worked in a marine business for 7 years from the mid 90's, and I can tell you that except for a specific kind of raft most all of that has been required for years. If you can't afford it, you should have never started your business. And Epirbs are a common sense item, that everyone should want. Coast Guard inspections have been required as long as I can remember. It sounds like you shouldn't be in the commercial marine business at all.

First, I NEVER complain about the cost of quality food.

Secondly, the comment was about a raft only. I wasn't commenting on other requirements, most of which have been required for years and years.

Most business have to deal with taxes and regulation. Those who work on the water have the same thing. You're not entitled to operate a business 'for free'. When you went into business, you knew that there would be dockage, fuel, insurance, maintenance, life jackets, throw rings, flairs, inspections and equipment. Real life for real business people. If you weren't willing to do that, then you shouldn't have gone into that business.

And check your math. October 1, 2012 is three years from October 1, 2015, the effective date.

Why is thre no "like button?

Why is there no "like" button?

How often is the water temp below 72 ?

Very rarely, This is some lobbiests plan to increase sales for thier company. VMS vessel monitoring tracks my vessel 24/7, emergency radio beacon , which seems to change frequencies every few years @ $1000 each time or $500 for a damn battery renewal/ flares that cost $400 for the sealed in a box set , expire every 2 years. "Safety " is a cash cow for these companies, and a multitude of other crap , such as a tire to support a turtle in case I somehow hook one while yellowtailing . The difference between your rec boat and my commercial one is the outragous amount of money I spend on safety gear. Your life jacket is 12 bucks mine is 50 , and then it needs a cylume that costs 14 with a renew date. And you wonder why I'm pissed off when you sell your rec fish commercially.

Hypothermia

can occur in any water temperature that is less than normal body temperature when there is extended exposure time.

Just another drop in the bucket

The feds are killing us. You have a small business...you're gonna get hit. Dont dare try to be independent. They will impose taxes disguised as compliance necessities, license increases, and user fees. Beat you down until you get in the line for the free milk and cookies.

I know one thing

I won't go in the water in the winter unless I'm wearing at least a shorty.

I hate neophrene so I don't go into the water in the

winter EVER.

L

L

Next time you cry about the cost of retail seafood

remember you're paying for a mandated raft that replaces another mandated raft.

I don't cry about the cost of retail seafood.

I don't cry about the cost of retail seafood. You get what you pay for. Buck up and stop complaining. Maybe it's time you found another job?

The equipment we carry is already adequete

this is just gouging, I don't need to find another job ; I'm just going to CHARGE MORE for seafood. So next time you want FRESH hogfish or grouper instead of the Mexican crap, bend over and you take out your wallet as my prices will have to reflect the extra 5 grand. After all YOU will get what you pay for Tina.
More Florida Keys Headlines
Sunday, May 19, 2013
Sunday, May 19, 2013
Saturday, May 18, 2013
1 comment
Saturday, May 18, 2013
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Sunday, May 19, 2013 -
Saturday, May 18, 2013 -
Friday, May 17, 2013 -
Thursday, May 16, 2013 -
Wednesday, May 15, 2013 -