Florida Keys News - Key West Citizen
Tuesday, October 23, 2012
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
Body in harbor ruled a drowning

The body of a homeless man was found floating in Key West Harbor on Friday, hours after he had a drunken argument with another homeless man, according to reports released Monday.

While the death case remains open, nothing so far suggests anything more than an accidental drowning, Key West police said Monday.

"At this point the initial rulings were drowning," said spokeswoman Alyson Crean. "Nothing suspicious involved."

Crean would not release the name of the dead man, but a source close to the case confirmed that it is Guadalupe Montiel, 47, of Key West.

A Coast Guard crew pulled his corpse from the water just after 6 p.m. Friday.

Montiel was wearing only black shorts and had one small cut under his chin, police reports said. His body had been floating in the harbor between Mallory Square and Sunset Key resort.

A paramedic at the scene recognized Montiel from an earlier call at Simonton Beach, where she saw him alive at about 10:50 a.m.

Montiel was among several homeless people who drew police attention at Simonton Beach at 10:30 a.m. Friday, reports said.

Police released five reports Monday, and the batch included a man threatening to kill Montiel eight hours before his body was found floating.

But police have not linked the drunken verbal fight between two homeless men to the death.

"They're trying to be responsible and document what went on," said Crean, of the reports that officers pooled together after the body was found.

Appearing intoxicated, from his glassy red eyes to his unsteady gait and boozy odor, Montiel was arguing with Lonnie Helms, 49, police reported.

All four homeless people were obviously impaired by alcohol, the reports said.

One man was so bad off, drooling on himself and unable to walk, that police placed him in protective custody and took him to jail.

"Montiel told Helms that he did not want any problems," Officer Matthew Johnson wrote in a report dated Saturday. "Helms was sitting down in the sand and told Montiel he was going to 'f--- him up.'"

As Montiel gathered up his things and began leaving the beach with his girlfriend, Vicki Compton, 39, Helms shouted, "I'll kill you!" according to police.

But Helms only made threats, reports said. Police said they separated Helms and Montiel "before a physical fight could ensue," and asked Montiel to leave the beach.

In another officer's report, Helms is depicted as telling Montiel that he would "kick his a--," while standing up and balling up his fists.

Montiel allegedly replied, "Let's go!"

Helms told officers that Montiel had started the problems at the beach.

At noon, police saw Montiel and Compton seated on the sidewalk in front of the La Concha Hotel, 430 Duval St., and more than two hours later, Compton was spotted alone and walking southbound on Duval Street.

At 4:30 p.m., the same officer drove by Simonton Beach and saw Helms sleeping against the side of the bath house.

The final report released so far, on Sunday, details police tracking down Compton in the 700 block of Duval Street at about 7:35 p.m.

She told them that she had last seen her boyfriend on Friday around sunset. They had shared some fries at the Conch Shack and then parted ways.

He appeared "beat up," Compton told police, the reports say, but not from fighting. It was from too much alcohol, she said.

Some other homeless people told her that he had received a bus ticket from his sister and left Key West, Compton reportedly told police.

But she was surprised that he would leave town without leaving her a message or money, police said.

"Compton expressed that she and (Montiel) are in a boyfriend/girlfriend relationship," the report states.

gfilosa@keysnews.com

Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

Irresponsible reporting

"Crean would not release the name of the dead man, but a source close to the case confirmed..." To me, this would mean family had not been notified. If the authorities don't release the name, I don't think the media should.

You are correct.

It's Journalism 101. But when the name of a Duval Street business is mentioned in a negative manner in the Voice column, it's redacted by The Citizen.

Go figure.

Then you and your family

Then you and your family should have had the moral tenacity to provide care for the man. When the POS bum is mentally ill and not just a drunken drug addict perhaps they can be fixed- if someone gives enough of a crap to help them. When the family quits caring and just leaves them on the street then why should we care?

Everlast- What it's like

Everlast- What it's like We've all seen the man at the liquor store beggin' for your change The hair on his face is dirty, dreadlocked and full of mange He ask the man for what he can spare with shame in his eyes Get a job you fuckin' slob is all he replied. God forbid you ever had to walk a mile in his shoes 'Cause then you really might know what it's like to sing the blues

To inquiring minds

Seriously is right!!! This bum and pos you are referring to is my uncle & while you sit there handing out your criticism we, his family grieve his loss. He wasn't always drunk or homeless but the circumstances of his lifes are none of your business. So before you type some more stupidity keep in mind this man was kind he was a brother, a son, an uncle, and I hope he rest in peace. Free from your bullshit unnecessary judgement!

Your Uncle ?

Then you are responsible for his demise also. Are you not your brothers keeper? Or in this case, Uncle? As for the circumstances of his life being none of the publics' business, you are wrong; the second he went out in public and infringed upon others and became a burden on society he became "our" business . You take no responsibility for your own relative but blame the public for judgement, perhaps you are the one in need of judgement.

I don't like the bums either

But your cruelty is repulsive.

Seriously?! Police had this

Seriously?! Police had this much contact with a bum in one single day?!?! Good riddance. With less of these burdens on society around we'd have less cops and therefore less taxes. Do us all a favor and roll a bum off Mallory dock whenever you come across a drunken one. Screw wasting money on a bus ticket to send them all to the mainland. Who in the hell gives these POS money anyways???

Simonton Beach

Wasn't this city owned prime waterfront property leased to an individual over a year ago? The thought being that the property would be cleaned up, maintained and create a new revenue stream for the city? Why is the property still a hangout for drunks and bums? Inquiring minds want to know. I've tried to take my twin sons there several times only to retreat due to the stench of urine & booze, bums fighting & cursing and hypodermic needles laying in the sand like Atocha coins.
More Florida Keys Headlines
Saturday, May 18, 2013
Saturday, May 18, 2013
Saturday, May 18, 2013
Saturday, May 18, 2013
1 comment
Saturday, May 18, 2013
1 comment
Friday, May 17, 2013
11 comments
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Saturday, May 18, 2013 -
Friday, May 17, 2013 -
Thursday, May 16, 2013 -
Wednesday, May 15, 2013 -
Tuesday, May 14, 2013 -