Florida Keys News - Key West Citizen
Sunday, February 3, 2013
Cruise control? A city divided
Proposed $3M dredging study on the ballot this fall

Key West is marking a peculiar anniversary as 2013 breaks over its tourist-driven economy, which includes some 800,000 cruise ship passengers padding over its narrow Old Town streets each year.

A decade ago, the city placed a limit on the number of cruise ships allowed to dock per week, settling on the number seven.

In 2003, that seven-ship cap meant no...

For the complete article, please pick up a copy of The Citizen for this day or purchase this day's electronic edition at http://secure.floridakeys.com/keysnews/enews. Home Delivery & Electronic Edition subscibers to The Citizen may access this article, once logged in to keysnews.com, at no charge. If you forget your password, please call us at 305-292-7777, ext. 4.
Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

I don't now and never have

considered cruise ship passengers 'tourists'. They are not on land long enough even to be called day trippers. They get just enough time to hit all the garbage filled, $5 stores, grab a Chinese made souvenir cup of vile watered down beer and some fast food. Dump all the garbage on the street and waddle their fat asses back to the ship. The rest are too fat or old even for that, they get the tour train fiasco.

The math here says it all.

Not a single one of the more upscale destinations, or even just the nicer bars and shops, get even a passing glance, not that any of these disgorged sheep could afford to pay a visit even if they wanted too. Same goes for those self serving lobbyists who try and convince the people of Key West that somehow these, $300 for a 4 day cruise, asshats, are going to come back to Key West in the future and spend some actual money on a longer stay. PROVE IT. They just spent their entire years spare cash on the cruise.

The ONLY benefits to these visits are the fees paid to the City by the Cruise lines, the few tacky, shit filled shops, bars and fake "historical recreations", on the first 4 blocks and the tour train operator/plastic faux key west salesman.

I wish you had posted earlier...

... so that more people might have seen your comment.

cruise ship destruction

simple , let's raise the disembarcation fee to $80 and let the market sort it out..

I have been saying this for

I have been saying this for a long time that cruise ship people don't spend much when in port, but they most likely do is barter to get the cheapest price they can get. The mega cruise ships are a floating city that has many shops, bars, international cuisine, games and fun entertainment; why would they want to leave the ship? to buy cheesy souvenirs that says 'KEY WEST'? Most of you so call establishments claim that they do more business with cruise ships, I only see a few close to the pier where the ships dock, Front street and Greene street and Duval up to Eaton street and don't bother to go any further thinking the other end of Duval is void of activity unlike the lower end. The visitors who spend most here and give businesses a reason to stay open are the fly downs and drive downs, they spend on hotel/motel/guest houses, restaurants, shops up and down the whole length of Duval and sightseeing.

Contact your commissioner.

As all of the facts have emerged, it's clear that very few of us want more cruise ships and more passengers dumped on our streets, destroying our quality of life.

Only Swift, Rossi and the T-shirt shops profit from them.

Contact your city commissioner and ask him or her to propose a new ordinance limiting passenger numbers and raising disembarkation fees.

Forget widening... question now is, do we want cruise ships at all?

Lets look at the numbers.

With all the drama and hyperbole you would think our whole economy is based on Cruise ships. Actually, very little is. As you can read, $24M out of $660M is from cruise ships. This is less then 4 percent. Yes, all these thousands and thousands of visitors contribute 4 percent to our economy according to this article. I have read other estimates from the pro cruise ship Chamber of Commerce closer to 7 percent, but regardless, 93-96 percent of our tourism has nothing to do with cruise ships!!! Now, look at the impact. There are seven $5 stores within one block of the B dock. When ships are in port, hundreds more scooters and electric cars pack our streets. Thousands of peope are dumped at he reef at once. all of this impacts the experience for other visitors ( you know, that 93 percent plus). There are many other impacts. This has been proven over and over. I have no issue with some cruise ships and keeping them consintrated by Front street. However, lets worry about the 93-96 percent of our economy that has NOTHING to do with these ships, and not expand a segment whose impact so far exceeds its contribution.

Oasis of The Seas

Dredge and bring more money into our island.

Amen!

Well said. (This comment was in response to "Let's look at the numbers"

Pack them in

Duval street is a dump lined with t-shirt shops, bars, and overpriced restaurants. Any pretense otherwise is a joke. Bring the cruise ship passengers in by the thousands. They buy a t-shirt, spend money, and leave.

Yep

As long as this city allows vulgar t-shirt shops, tasteless bars and Carnival ships, the downtown area will always be a dump by both day and nght. Key West is a paradise for the drunken, trash tourists and anyone who thinks otherwise is delusional.

You act like it's a bad thing

to be a drunk
More Florida Keys Headlines
Saturday, May 18, 2013
Saturday, May 18, 2013
Saturday, May 18, 2013
Saturday, May 18, 2013
Saturday, May 18, 2013
Friday, May 17, 2013
9 comments
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Saturday, May 18, 2013 -
Friday, May 17, 2013 -
Thursday, May 16, 2013 -
Wednesday, May 15, 2013 -
Tuesday, May 14, 2013 -